Sign up to access all features of our service.
  • Job search
  • Favorites
  • Create a CV
    New
  • Salaries
  • Subscriptions

GUEST SERVICE SHIFT LEADER (OVERNIGHT)

Wally's Operating Company LLC

Guest Service Supervisor

Front-End Leadership Role at Wally's | Full Benefits | Growth Opportunity

Wally's is seeking a dependable and service-focused Guest Service Supervisor to support front-end operations and help lead our Guest Service Team. This role blends hands-on cashier responsibilities with leadership accountability, ensuring transactions are accurate, guests feel welcomed, and daily operations run smoothly.

Guest Service Leads set the tone for hospitality and professionalism on the front end. If you enjoy mentoring others, staying organized in a fast-paced environment, and taking ownership of guest experience standards, this is an excellent opportunity to grow within Wally's.

Benefits at Wally's
  • 401(k) with 5% company match
  • Company-paid medical option
  • Dental & Vision coverage
  • Company-paid Life Insurance
  • PTO
  • Short-Term & Long-Term Disability
  • AD&D coverage
  • Health Savings Account (HSA)
  • Flexible Spending Account (FSA)
What You'll Own at Wally's

Guest Service Leads work directly alongside cashiers to ensure accuracy, efficiency, and hospitality standards are consistently upheld. You will support drawer counts, register balancing, transaction accuracy, and front-end organization while serving as a resource for newer team members.

You will provide real-time coaching, reinforce service expectations, and step in to resolve guest concerns using Wally's BLAST de-escalation approach. Strong Leads maintain awareness of front-end performance, help correct issues before they escalate, and communicate effectively with Guest Service Managers when support is needed.

This role requires strong attention to detail, accountability, and the ability to lead by example in both service and compliance. Guest Service Leads also assist with training, mentoring, and reinforcing company standards across the team.

What We're Looking For

We are seeking candidates with prior guest service or cashier experience who are ready to take on leadership responsibility.

Ideal candidates demonstrate:
  • Strong cash handling and basic math skills
  • Confidence guiding and mentoring small teams
  • Professional communication and reliability
  • Ability to stay calm and solution-focused during busy periods
  • Comfort working in a high-volume retail environment
Flexibility is required, including availability for nights, weekends, and holidays.

Physical Requirements
  • Extended periods of standing and walking
  • Frequent use of hands and arms
  • Ability to lift up to 10 lbs regularly and up to 25 lbs occasionally
  • Ability to bend, reach, and move throughout the front-end area

Why This Role Matters at Wally's

The front end defines the guest's first and last impression. Strong Guest Service Leads protect accuracy, speed, and hospitality standards while helping build a dependable and high-performing team.

If you are ready to step into leadership, strengthen your supervisory skills, and contribute to Wally's continued growth, we encourage you to apply.

10PM- 6AM
40 HOURS/WEEK
Vacancy posted 1 day ago
Similar jobs that could be interesting for youBased on the GUEST SERVICE SHIFT LEADER (OVERNIGHT) in Whitestown, IN vacancy
  •  ...Play like a Champion, and Win as One. Description As an Overnight Shift Lead , you support the Assistant and General Manager by...  ...Members: Mentor and lead your team to deliver excellent customer service. Ensure Excellent Customer Service: Cultivate an... 
    Night shift
    Flexible hours
    Shift work

    Flynn Taco Bell

    Whitestown, IN
    17 hours ago
  • $17.25 - $17.75 per hour

    Shift Leader Whitestown, IN $17.25 - $17.75 per hour PAY TRANSPARENCY: earn between $17.25 and $17.75 plus digital tips!* Do you...  ...to execute outstanding product quality and customer service, build sales and control costs for each shift. What's In It... 
    Night shift
    Hourly pay
    Part time
    Local area
    All shifts
    Flexible hours
    Shift work

    Potbelly Sandwich Works

    Whitestown, IN
    1 day ago
  • $14 - $16 per hour

     ...energized. This role provides direction during shifts, supports consistent execution, and helps create an engaging experience for guests and teammates. The Team Captain influences...  ...experience by setting the standard for service behaviors. Reinforces expectations, and influences... 
    Night shift
    Local area
    10 hours per week
    Flexible hours
    Shift work

    Rally House

    Whitestown, IN
    5 days ago
  •  ...Papa John's USA, Inc. in Brownsburg, Indiana is seeking an Hourly Shift Leader to lead a restaurant team in providing a world-class service experience. The ideal candidate is at least 18 years old, has strong problem-solving skills, and can work flexible hours including... 
    Night shift
    Hourly pay
    Flexible hours
    Shift work

    Papa John's USA, Inc.

    Brownsburg, IN
    3 days ago
  •  ...As a Shift Leader with Blaze Pizza, you will be part of a franchise organization that will provide you with plenty of new challenges...  ...schedule Employee discounts Requirements: Strong guest service and communication skills Full availability for any shift,... 
    Night shift
    Flexible hours
    Shift work

    Blaze Pizza

    Carmel, IN
    17 hours ago
  •  ...Opportunity for advancement with local growing franchisee! -Shift Leaders perform all functions of leading a shift, opening and closing store Duties: -Provide excellent customer service to our guests at all times with enthusiastic approach -Train, develop and... 
    Night shift
    Local area
    Shift work

    Fan the Flame LLC

    Carmel, IN
    4 days ago
  •  ...Shift Leader at Smoothie King Are you a highly skilled and motivated individual looking...  ...leadership capacity. Ensure a superior guest experience, maximize sales performance,...  ...quality preparation of smoothies and guest service. Enforce sanitary practices for food... 
    Night shift
    Immediate start
    Monday to Friday
    Flexible hours
    Shift work
    Weekend work
    Day shift

    Smoothie King

    Westfield, IN
    1 day ago
  • $15 - $18 per hour

     ...Now Hiring: Shift Leader (Hourly) Department: Operations Reports to: Assistant General...  ...includes managing staff, ensuring an excellent guest experience, maintaining food quality,...  ...members in real time to improve speed, service, and execution. Ensure restaurant is... 
    Hourly pay
    Full time
    Contract work
    Local area
    Immediate start
    Shift work
    Weekend work
    Afternoon shift

    Chicken Salad Chick

    Whitestown, IN
    4 days ago
  •  ...will be responsible for ensuring seamless daily operations, exceptional guest experiences, and team efficiency. Your mission is to lead, support, and inspire the FOH team while maintaining service excellence, guest satisfaction, and operational success in a high-energy... 
    Night shift
    Local area
    Shift work
    Weekend work

    Kona Grill

    Carmel, IN
    4 days ago
  •  ...Overview As an Hourly Shift Leader, you will lead a restaurant team in a fun, flexible work environment, ensuring customers receive a world‑class service experience. Responsibilities Lead and manage the restaurant team to provide a world‑class service experience. Qualifications... 
    Night shift
    Hourly pay
    Weekly pay
    Contract work
    Flexible hours
    Shift work
    Weekend work

    Papa John's USA, Inc.

    Brownsburg, IN
    3 days ago
  • Papa Johns in Zionsville, Indiana is hiring a Shift Leader responsible for supervising shifts and ensuring quality products and customer service. You will manage operations, enforce company policies, and contribute to profitability. The ideal candidate should be at least... 
    Night shift
    Full time
    Shift work

    Papa Johns

    Zionsville, IN
    1 day ago
  • Papa Johns in Westfield, Indiana, is looking for a Shift Leader to supervise shifts in the restaurant, ensuring high quality products and customer service. The role involves managing operations, adhering to company policies, and leading a team to meet performance goals.... 
    Night shift
    Shift work

    Papa Johns

    Westfield, IN
    1 day ago
  •  ...JOB SUMMARY Runs shifts efficiently and continually motivates team members to ensure that every guest who chooses Culver's® leaves happy. ESSENTIAL FUNCTIONS...  ...effectively to ensure quality products, guest service and restaurant cleanliness meet Culver's standards... 
    Night shift
    Odd job
    Flexible hours
    Shift work
    Weekend work
    Day shift

    Culver's (Vincennes)

    Westfield, IN
    1 day ago
  • A fast food restaurant chain is looking for a Shift Manager in Whitestown, Indiana. The role includes leading shifts, ensuring outstanding customer service, and managing team performance. Candidates should have previous leadership experience and the ability to thrive in... 
    Shift work

    McDonald's

    Whitestown, IN
    5 days ago
  • HSLJob SummaryThe Shift Leader supervises shifts and/or work areas in the operation of a Papa John’s restaurant to ensure high quality products and customer service are delivered to ensure restaurant profitability. Other responsibilities include the management of operations... 
    Night shift
    For contractors
    Local area
    Immediate start
    Flexible hours
    Shift work

    Papa Johns

    Westfield, IN
    2 days ago
  • A leading pizza restaurant chain is seeking a Shift Leader to supervise restaurant operations and ensure high quality products and customer service. Responsibilities include adherence to company policies, managing shift coverage, and contributing to profit goals. The ideal... 
    Night shift
    Shift work
    Weekend work

    Papa John's International , Inc.

    Westfield, IN
    4 days ago
  • $14.2 - $21.1 per hour

     ...largest tanker fleets and providing critical services to oil operations in our nation's...  ...true to us today. Whether we are serving guests, a fellow team member, or a trucking company...  ...to apply. Job Description Deli Shift Leaders are responsible for supervising team members... 
    Night shift
    Hourly pay
    Weekly pay
    Local area
    Flexible hours
    Shift work
    Weekend work

    Pilot Flying J

    Lebanon, IN
    17 hours ago
  • FGF Brands in Lebanon, Indiana is seeking a Production Supervisor to lead hands-on production shifts ensuring efficiency and safety. This role involves coordinating various department schedules, managing teams, and providing training. The ideal candidate will have 3-4... 
    Night shift
    Shift work

    fgf brands

    Lebanon, IN
    2 days ago
  •  ...Hiring Immediately Welcome to Love’s! As a Retail Shift Lead, you’ll be one of the first leaders our customers and team members count on. You’ll help...  ...operations, guiding the team, and delivering great customer service. We believe in growing our leaders from within—this... 
    Work at office
    Immediate start
    Shift work

    Love's Travel Stops

    Whitestown, IN
    4 days ago
  • Love's Travel Stops in Whitestown, Indiana, seeks a Retail Shift Lead to ensure excellent customer service while overseeing daily operations. You will maintain a clean and safe environment, manage inventory, and supervise the team to foster a positive work culture. At least... 
    Shift work

    Love's Travel Stops

    Whitestown, IN
    3 days ago
  •  ...become the world's greatest baker, we need the world's greatest team members Summary Reporting to the Operations Leader and Site Leader, as the Shift Leader, you will provide hands-on leadership on a production shift within the plant to ensure that production... 
    Night shift
    Work at office
    All shifts
    Flexible hours
    Shift work
    Weekend work
    Afternoon shift

    fgf brands

    Lebanon, IN
    5 days ago
  •  ...Auditor at Home2Suites by Hilton Indianapolis Brownsburg. This role requires delivering exceptional service from check-in to check-out, managing reservations, and handling guest inquiries effectively. The ideal candidate will possess strong customer service skills and... 
    Night shift
    Part time

    Commonwealth Hotels

    Brownsburg, IN
    3 days ago
  •  ...daily since 1995. About this role We are looking for a District Shift Leader who will develop into a General Manager. The District Shift...  ...environment. Coach and train staff in food quality and customer service. Perform administrative duties: inventory tracking, vendor... 
    Local area
    Shift work
    Weekend work

    Coffee and Bagel Brands

    Carmel, IN
    1 day ago
  •  ...quality issues; Support food safety including hand washing, glove changes, time/temperature, shelf lives, and Daily Food Safety Checklist; Help resolve customer incidents and ensure positive customer experiences; Monitor crew breaks, shift changes, and line schedules... 
    Shift work

    Chipotle

    Lebanon, IN
    2 days ago
  •  ...Maintain a positive customer experience by ensuring high-quality food is served; Help resolve food quality issues; Support food safety policies and procedures on the line; Monitor crew breaks, shift changes, and line schedules; Develop and cross-train front-of-house crew... 
    Shift work

    Chipotle

    Carmel, IN
    4 days ago
  •  ...want you to provide customers with great‑tasting food, but also with service that puts a smile on their faces and keeps them coming back for more. Position Overview We are currently hiring for Shift Leaders who are motivated people with excellent interpersonal skills, and... 
    Daily paid
    Currently hiring
    Flexible hours
    Shift work

    Flynn Group

    Westfield, IN
    4 days ago
  •  ...Overview Join to apply for the Shift Leader role at Flynn Group . Flynn Wendy’s is part of Flynn Group, a large franchise operator founded...  ..., and can establish a cohesive team that delivers outstanding service and drives both results and customer satisfaction. The Shift... 
    Daily paid
    Flexible hours
    Shift work

    Flynn Group

    Lebanon, IN
    4 days ago
  • $17 - $21 per hour

     ...restaurants nationwide. What We Need As a Shift Leader, you will ensure every shift runs...  ...we deliver a Damn Good experience to our guests. You will balance hands‑on involvement with...  ...Strong understanding of food safety, guest service, and restaurant operations. Required... 
    Hourly pay
    Full time
    Flexible hours
    Shift work
    Afternoon shift

    Torchy's Tacos

    Zionsville, IN
    17 hours ago
  •  ...A popular bagel franchise is seeking a Shift Leader in Carmel, Indiana. The role includes motivating the team, providing feedback, and ensuring a great guest experience. Benefits include a competitive pay structure with tips, flexible scheduling, and a 401K plan with... 
    Flexible hours
    Shift work
    Day shift
    Afternoon shift

    Coffee And Bagel Brands

    Carmel, IN
    3 days ago
  •  ...Our Panda Shift Leader associates are important leaders of our team and are responsible for...  ...management in creating food with passion, service with heart and ambiance with pride.As a...  ...vibrant and welcoming environment for our guests.Gain valuable skills managing store... 
    Full time
    Temporary work
    Local area
    Flexible hours
    Shift work

    Hunter Super Techs - TurnPoint

    Westfield, IN
    1 day ago

Do you want to receive more vacancies?

Subscribe and receive similar vacancies to GUEST SERVICE SHIFT LEADER (OVERNIGHT). Be the first to apply!