Sign up to access all features of our service.
  • Job search
  • Favorites
  • Create a CV
    New
  • Salaries
  • Subscriptions

Personal Lines Insurance Underwriter

$60k - $65k

Rural Mutual Insurance

Job Description

Job Description

Rural Mutual Insurance is seeking a motivated and detail‑driven personal lines underwriter to join a company that’s proudly recognized as one of the top 50 property and casualty insurers in the nation and consistently named one of Madison’s Best Places to Work. At Rural Mutual, you’ll be part of a mission‑focused organization that has protected Wisconsin families and businesses for over 90 years.  

If you’re passionate about thoughtful risk evaluation, collaborative problem‑solving, and building a meaningful career in a stable, people‑centered company, we’d love to have you on our growing underwriting team. 

Candidates must live and work in Wisconsin and have eligibility to work in the United States without sponsorship.  This role offers the flexibility of hybrid or remote work options after successful training—allowing you to grow your career while thriving both personally and professionally. 

At Rural Mutual, we are dedicated to fostering a supportive and collaborative work environment. We offer a comprehensive compensation package, including health, dental, and vision insurance, a matching 401(k), an employee bonus plan, and generous time off. Rural Mutual is an Equal Opportunity Employer.

Compensation:

$60,000 - $65,000 per year

Responsibilities:

  • Evaluate risk for acceptance, rejection, or modification in compliance with underwriting guidelines for Homeowners and Personal Auto policies.
  • Assess incoming policy change requests and determine appropriate action.
  • Analyze risk alerts from claim adjusters and decide on renewal impacts.
  • Respond promptly to emails, phone calls, and correspondence from agents, assistants, and internal staff.
  • Manage daily, weekly, and monthly underwriting tasks via workbench systems.
  • Make decisions within your letter of authority and follow department service standards.
  • Provide input on product development and underwriting procedures.
  • Perform other duties as assigned.
Qualifications:

  • Personal lines underwriting experience required; 2+ years preferred.
  • Strong verbal and written communication skills.
  • Excellent attention to detail, with the ability to prioritize work, manage multiple responsibilities, and make sound decisions.
  • Demonstrated analytical, critical-thinking, and problem-solving skills.
  • Proven ability to work collaboratively in a team environment while managing responsibilities independently.
  • Self-motivated with a strong sense of accountability and initiative.
  • Proficiency with Microsoft Office applications and other business technology systems.
  • Must maintain a primary residence and work location in Wisconsin and be authorized to perform all job duties within the state, consistent with company operational and compliance requirements.
Preferred Qualifications
  • Associate degree from an accredited college or technical school, or an equivalent combination of education and experience.
  • Additional insurance-related education, coursework, or industry training.
  • Interest in pursuing professional insurance designations or continuing education.
  • Bilingual communication skills, including Spanish or Hmong.
About Company

What You'll Love About Rural Mutual Insurance:

We are a leading property and casualty insurance company based in Wisconsin, well known for our financial strength and longevity in the insurance industry. Our reputation in the marketplace ensures stability and opens up numerous growth opportunities for our employees. 

We created a welcoming place to work with friendly and professional leadership. We are known for the great care we take with our staff, our agents, and our customers. We are passionate and determined about delivering the best customer service, preserving insurance industry knowledge, and making a difference through the work that we do.

We believe in a healthy work/life balance and, to that end, offer a competitive and comprehensive compensation package including health, dental, life, LTD, and vision insurance as well as an employee bonus plan, matching 401(k) plan, and generous time off benefits. Rural Mutual is an Equal Opportunity employer.

Vacancy posted 4 days ago
Similar jobs that could be interesting for youBased on the Personal Lines Insurance Underwriter in Madison, WI vacancy
  • $62.7k

     ...small and mid-sized clients in conformance with established underwriting policies, practices, and standards. May prepare a variety of...  ...connection with this, all employees must comply with both the Health Insurance Portability Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA) as described... 
    Suggested
    Contract work
    For contractors
    Work at office
    Local area

    Highmark Health

    Madison, WI
    2 days ago
  • $60k - $165.1k

     ...addition to medical, dental, and vision insurance. 401K, continuing education opportunities...  ...banking products and services. A CRE Underwriter role has the primary responsibility of financial...  ...(near Rosemont and the Cumberland Blue line station), Lincoln Park, St Louis Park MN... 
    Suggested
    Work at office
    Flexible hours
    Shift work

    Old National Bank

    Madison, WI
    11 hours ago
  • $68.51k - $96.51k

     ...are growing at West Bend! Our Commercial Lines Underwriting team plays a critical role in our...  ...collaboration days, team meetings or other in-person events. The position can be based in...  ...Training Bachelor's degree in Business, Insurance or related field Completion of... 
    Suggested
    Temporary work
    Work at office
    Local area
    Flexible hours

    The Silver Lining

    Madison, WI
    2 days ago
  • $80k - $125k

     ...About MGT Insurance MGT is the first AI-driven, neo-insurer focused...  ...-Making Evaluate and make underwriting decisions on commercial P&C...  ...technical depth across MGT's lines of business through mentorship...  ...fast. For the right person, this is an exceptional place... 
    Suggested
    Flexible hours

    MGT Insurance

    Madison, WI
    11 hours ago
  • $124k - $233k

     ...Underwriting Role in Alternative Risk Transfer The purpose of this role is to underwrite...  ...Progressive experience in complex commercial insurance, specialty underwriting, reinsurance,...  ...Experience with structured insurance, multi-line/multi-year programs, captive/fronting... 
    Suggested
    Full time
    Part time
    Work experience placement
    Work at office
    Remote work
    Work from home
    2 days per week
    3 days per week

    QBE Insurance

    Madison, WI
    1 day ago
  • $97.15k - $194.99k

     ...Production Underwriter, Package Lines The salary range for this job posting is $97,153.00 - $194,...  ...during the hiring process. Encova Insurance has an immediate opening for Production...  ...and thrive both professionally and personally. Encova Insurance is an EOE/E-Verify... 
    Work experience placement
    Work at office
    Immediate start
    Remote work
    Flexible hours

    Encova Insurance

    Madison, WI
    3 days ago
  • West Bend Insurance Company seeks an Associate Underwriter to join West Bend Express. You will evaluate small market submissions, develop underwriting judgment, and foster agency relationships in an in-office role located in West Bend or Madison, WI. Structured onboarding... 
    Work at office

    West Bend Insurance Company

    Madison, WI
    11 hours ago
  • $60k

     ...Job Description Job Description Rural Mutual Insurance is seeking a motivated and detail‑driven personal lines underwriter to join a company that’s proudly recognized as one of the top 50 property and casualty insurers in the nation and consistently named one of Madison... 
    Full time
    Work at office
    Remote work

    Rural Mutual Insurance

    Madison, WI
    4 days ago
  • $65k

     ...~ This is a commission only role with average earnings of $65,000+ in the first year and uncapped room for rapid growth based on performance. State and federal laws require licensing to sell certain insurance products. Ability to obtain a license is required.... 
    Full time
    Flexible hours

    Chamberlain Agencies

    Madison, WI
    13 days ago
  •  ...Lead Senior Underwriter This is an advanced level underwriting position. The Lead Senior...  ...recommending appropriate Credit Union Protection insurance products as well as identifying loss...  ...organizations exposure s for all lines of insurance. Assess the potential for insured... 
    Work experience placement

    Direct Staffing Inc

    Madison, WI
    3 days ago
  • $61.55k - $76.94k

     ...Job Title Surety Underwriting Role Job Description Start your...  ...days, team meetings or other in-person events. The position can be...  ...Bachelor's degree in business, insurance, or related field Salary...  ...recruiting, hiring, placement, and promotion. The Silver Lining
    Temporary work
    Work at office
    Local area
    Flexible hours

    The Silver Lining

    Madison, WI
    3 days ago
  • $53.46k - $66.82k

     ...celebrate our successes and take pride in serving our communities. Job Summary The Associate Underwriter is a Commercial Enterprise role designed to build foundational insurance and underwriting knowledge through structured training, guided practice, and hands‑on... 
    Temporary work
    Work at office
    Local area
    Remote work
    Flexible hours

    West Bend Insurance Company

    Madison, WI
    4 days ago
  • $75k

     ...take charge of your earning potential? At Platinum Supplemental Insurance, we’re looking for motivated individuals ready to learn, grow...  ...with our new AI-driven training platform. You’ll receive personalized feedback, interactive coaching, and real-time support to help... 
    Flexible hours
    Night shift

    Platinum Supplemental Insurance, Inc.

    Maple Bluff, WI
    11 hours ago
  • $51k - $60k

     ...00 Job Category: Sales - Comparion Description Comparion Insurance Agency is hiring self-motivated, relationship-driven professionals...  ...and in the community, communicating by phone, email, and in person, traveling locally, and using a computer and sales software.... 
    Full time
    Work at office
    Local area

    Comparion Insurance Agency

    Madison, WI
    15 days ago
  •  ...Negotiate settlements with policyholders, claimants, and other insurance carriers to reach fair resolutions within established...  ...comprehensive package designed to help you thrive both professionally and personally. Hybrid Flexibility: Enjoy the best of both worlds. With... 
    Work experience placement
    Work at office
    Work from home
    Monday to Friday

    Sentry Insurance

    Madison, WI
    11 days ago
  •  ...is one of the oldest providers of title insurance in Dane County and we take pride in our...  ...-oriented and motivated Title Insurance Underwriter or Attorney to join our dynamic underwriting...  ...Vision insurance Work Location : In person Company Description W3Global was... 
    Permanent employment
    Full time
    Contract work
    Temporary work
    Work at office
    Remote work
    Flexible hours

    W3Global Inc.

    Madison, WI
    4 days ago
  •  ...motivated individual interested in being part of a growing firm, we want to hear from you! We offer comprehensive benefits and a generous personal time off program. More details on benefits for this role. This position requires you to have authorization to work in the... 
    Immediate start
    Remote work
    Relocation

    CORRE Inc

    Madison, WI
    3 days ago
  •  ...then refer appropriately Work cohesively with processing and underwriting to meet closing needs Maintain constant contact with...  ...referral relationships with employees in other bank business lines Monitor past dues and assist with collections if required... 
    Work at office

    Capitol Bank

    Madison, WI
    3 days ago
  • $62k - $100k

     ...as time off in the future ~ ESOP : Receive MSA stock shares annually, at no cost to the employee ~ Medical, dental & vision insurance for you, spouse, domestic partner, and eligible dependents ~17+ days PTO (potentially higher pending experience) + 8 paid holidays... 
    Temporary work
    Work at office
    Local area
    Flexible hours

    MSA Professional Services, Inc.

    Madison, WI
    2 days ago
  • Capitol Bank in Madison, Wisconsin is seeking a motivated individual for a mortgage origination role. The ideal candidate will have 3-5+ years of experience in mortgage origination, strong communication skills, and a passion for providing excellent customer service. ...

    Capitol Bank

    Madison, WI
    5 days ago
  • $60k

     ...incentive program, in addition to medical, dental, and vision insurance. 401K, continuing education opportunities and an employee...  ...compensation plan and in-house operational teams for processing, underwriting and closing. Salary Range The salary range for this... 
    Base plus commission
    Full time

    Old National Bank

    Madison, WI
    5 days ago
  •  ...opportunity and have an entrepreneurial spirit? You may be the Insurance Advisor we are looking for... Ansay & Associates is a...  ...staff need to be successful, and to providing opportunities for personal growth. Ansay & Associates offers a robust benefits package including... 

    Ansay & Associates

    Madison, WI
    3 days ago
  • $7.25 per hour

     ...helping them make strong financial decisions to achieve their personal and financial goals. Our mortgage professionals, carefully chosen...  ..., vision, HSA, FSA, Short-Term Disability, Voluntary Life Insurance, CHUBB Supplemental Insurance, Pet Insurance, 401K · Company... 
    Hourly pay
    Temporary work

    USA Mortgage

    Madison, WI
    2 days ago
  • $20 per hour

     ...bring our shared ambition to life, and each person is unique in their potential. A career...  ...applications, conducts preliminary underwriting reviews, submits loan applications to processing...  ...requirements of various mortgage insurance companies ~ Working knowledge of underwriting... 
    Temporary work
    Local area
    Remote work
    3 days per week

    U.S. Bank

    Madison, WI
    2 days ago
  • $60k - $100k

    Job Location: We are hiring Licensed/Certified Appraisers in the following areas: Milwaukee Madison Green Bay Kenosha Racine Appleton Waukesha Oshkosh Eau Claire Janesville About Us Banks Valuation is a growing appraisal firm, founded...
    For contractors

    Banks Valuation

    Madison, WI
    5 days ago
  •  ...through closing. 4. Takes mortgage loan applications, obtains credit reports and completes/ submits necessary paperwork to mortgage underwriters. 5. Cross sells Landmark's other products and services and makes referrals to Landmark's Investment Center. 6. Represents... 
    Local area

    Landmark Credit Union

    Madison, WI
    3 days ago
  • $62.4k - $93.6k

     ...We’re determined to make a difference and are proud to be an insurance company that goes well beyond coverages and policies. Working...  ...Internet system has sufficient speeds, please visit from your personal computer. Licensing Requirements: As a condition of your employment... 
    Full time
    Temporary work
    Part time
    Work experience placement
    Work at office
    Remote work
    Monday to Friday
    3 days per week

    The Hartford

    Madison, WI
    4 days ago
  • $50k - $55k

     ...to Work® Fortune Best Workplaces in Financial Services & Insurance Claims Representative, Auto | Property Damage **PRIMARY...  ...as required for the position. + Familiarity with personal and commercial lines policies and endorsements + Ability to review and assess... 
    Full time
    Contract work
    Work at office
    Local area
    Flexible hours

    Sedgwick

    Madison, WI
    2 days ago
  •  ...& Brown is seeking a Producer to join our growing team and help agricultural producers evaluate risk and select appropriate crop insurance coverage. You will build trusted relationships, educate clients on programs, and drive profitable growth across an assigned territory... 

    Brown & Brown, Inc.

    Madison, WI
    3 days ago
  • $46k - $70k

     ...Category: Sales - Comparion Description We are looking for an Insurance Sales Associate to join our WI team. This position has in-...  ...this role will require building a strong local network and in-person relationship in the community. Working for Comparion Insurance... 
    Full time
    Work at office
    Local area
    Immediate start

    Comparion Insurance Agency

    Madison, WI
    4 hours ago

Do you want to receive more vacancies?

Subscribe and receive similar vacancies to Personal Lines Insurance Underwriter. Be the first to apply!