Principal Recruiter - Insurance

$200k

Talently

Job Title: Principal Recruiter - Insurance

Location: Remote (US-Based)

Compensation: Base Salary + Commissions + Bonus | OTE $200K–$500K+

About Talently
Talently is a fully remote recruitment agency built for high-performing full-desk recruiters with deep vertical expertise and a proven ability to grow strategic client relationships . We provide the tools, tech, and BD support so you can focus on what matters most: winning accounts, delivering for your clients, and growing your book of business.

About the Role
We’re looking for an experienced Principal Recruiter - Insurance to help us build teams across carriers, brokerages, and MGAs nationwide.. The ideal candidate will be our strategic partner in leading sales and growing our Insurance practice.

Target Roles: Producers, Account Managers, Underwriters, Claims, CSRs, Sales Leadership, Commercial Lines, Personal Lines

What Makes Talently Different?

We eliminate the typical friction that slows down great recruiters:

Warm Leads Weekly: We generate warm leads in your vertical every week through targeted outbound campaigns. No cold prospecting grind!
AI-Powered ATS: Our AI-powered ATS streamlines your workflow and eliminates time-consuming tasks.
Candidate Sourcing Stack: LinkedIn Recruiter, job ads, candidate databases, and multi-channel outreach help you connect with the right talent fast.
Account Ownership: We stay lean on purpose so you have access to high-quality jobs, protected accounts, and minimal internal overlap.

What You’ll Do

Own your Vertical: win searches, fill roles, and build key client accounts
Expand accounts and become a trusted partner in your niche
Build candidate pipelines and deliver a world-class experience
Take on team leadership or mentorship responsibilities as we grow

What We’re Looking For

Must-Haves

3+ years of proven success in full-desk/360 agency recruiting
A consistent track record of high billings ($400K+ preferred)
Strong account management and candidate delivery skills
High integrity, reliability, and team-first mindset
Coachable, curious, and driven to grow

Nice-to-Haves

Leadership experience or aspirations
LI Recruiter & Boolean skills

If you’re a top-performing full-desk recruiter tired of building everything from scratch, Talently gives you the support, tools, and leads to win bigger & faster.

Apply

Vacancy posted 1 day ago

Similar jobs that could be interesting for youBased on the Principal Recruiter - Insurance in Chicago, IL vacancy

Senior GTM Recruiter
...Talentful Recruitment SpecialistTalentful is shaping the future of how high-growth companies build world-class teams. We partner with some... ....Healthcare options From employer contributions to health insurance.Wellness allowance contributions Improve either your physical,...
Suggested
Local area
Remote work
Flexible hours
Talentful
Chicago, IL
4 days ago
L1 Junior Recruiter
...Crystal Equation? Comprehensive medical, dental, vision, and life insurance benefits plus 401k matching · Must be local to Chicago, IL... ...meet or exceed placement targets by effectively managing the recruitment process and ensuring timely and successful candidate...
Suggested
Full time
For contractors
Local area
Flexible hours
Crystal Equation Corporation
Chicago, IL
more than 2 months ago
Principal Recruiter
$166.35k - $195.7k
...together quarterly for intense in-person working sessions called “surges.”learn more about working at Coinbase. We're hiring a Principal Recruiter to join our Core Recruiting team within People Success. This team owns hiring across Coinbase's G&A functions, and you'll be...
Principal
Local area
Coinbase
Chicago, IL
4 days ago
Client Partner, Financial Services - Senior Principal
$144k - $216k
...outcomes.Slalom is actively seeking a Senior Principal Client Partner in Chicago to grow the Slalom brand within our insurance clients. This Client Partner will lead the... ...note, this recipient is not able to support recruitment inquiries beyond this purpose.EEO and AccommodationsSlalom...
Principal
Temporary work
Local area
Slalom
Chicago, IL
3 days ago
Principal Product Manager, Agentic Operations
...platform for the multi-trillion-dollar insurance economy, creating intelligent experiences... ...about CCC at .The RoleWe are hiring a Principal Product Manager to build CCC’s Agentic... ...retained and may be reviewed by CCC and our recruiters. Candidates are not permitted to use...
Principal
Full time
CCC Information Services
Chicago, IL
2 days ago
Vocational Rehabilitation Consultant
$66.75k - $106.8k
...Be Aware of Fraudulent Recruiting Activities : Lincoln values the privacy and security of every applicant and urges all applicants to... ...skills training techniques and offering job placement assistance Insurance experience Application Deadline Applications for this position...
Work experience placement
Work at office
Remote work
Work from home
Relocation package
Lincoln Financial Group
Chicago, IL
1 day ago
Vice President, Principal Owner Development & Growth
...Vice President, Principal Owner Development & Growth About the Company Top-tier mutual life insurance company Industry Financial Services Type Privately Held... ...planning. A deep understanding of recruiting and production metrics is essential. The...
Principal
Home office
Confidential
Chicago, IL
2 days ago
Principal Solution Architect, Insurance
$168.5k - $206k
General Information Job Title Principal Solution Architect, Insurance Job ID 102793 Work Areas Management Consulting, Technology & Engineering Employment Type Permanent Full-Time Location(s) Atlanta, Austin, Boston, Chicago, Dallas, Houston...
Principal
Permanent employment
Full time
Work at office
Local area
Home office
3 days per week
Bain & Company
Chicago, IL
4 days ago
Principal Engineer
...Principal EngineerVouch is the insurance broker that powers ambition. We're a tech-enabled insurance advisory and brokerage purpose-built for growing... ...interview process includes a 30-minute phone call with our recruiting team, a 30-45 minute video interview with the hiring...
Principal
Work at office
Flexible hours
3 days per week
Vouch
Chicago, IL
3 days ago
Principal Recruitment Consultant
$55k - $85k
Overview Principal Recruitment Consultant - Tenth Revolution Group Location: Chicago area Hybrid schedule, at least 2 days a week in office... ...Vision, 401k options, Long and Short Term Disability, Life Insurance, and 22 days of PTO year 1! This is not an HR or Internal recruitment...
Principal
Permanent employment
Full time
Temporary work
Work at office
Relocation
2 days per week
Tenth Revolution Group
Chicago, IL
4 days ago
Technical Recruiter
$100k - $140k
...Technical Recruiter (Founding technical TA hire) Location: Preference for this team member to be based near one of our hubs in New... ...About WithCoverage : WithCoverage replaces the traditional insurance brokerage with AI-supercharged risk management designed for...
Full time
For contractors
Work at office
Remote work
Flexible hours
Withcoverage
Chicago, IL
more than 2 months ago
Talent Acquisition - Sourcer/Recruiter
...partner closely with business leaders to develop and execute recruiting strategies that meet both immediate and long-term hiring needs... ...full range of benefits including medical, dental, and vision insurance, 401(k) with company match, and PTO. A complete description of...
Full time
Contract work
Work at office
Immediate start
Riveron
Chicago, IL
24 days ago
Actuarial Recruiter and Consultant
...DW Simpson Global Actuarial & Analytics Recruitment is the Premier Actuarial Recruiting Firm specializing in the placement of Actuaries... ...expertise in Predictive Modeling and Data Science, primarily for the Insurance Industry. We have been in business for 37 years and have the...
Temporary work
Currently hiring
DW Simpson Global Actuarial & Analytics Recruitment
Chicago, IL
4 hours ago
Principal Engineer
$245k - $285k
...About Vouch Vouch is the insurance broker that powers ambition. About Vouch Vouch... .... This role owns that layer. This is a principal-level individual contributor seat... ...role) ~30-minute phone call with our recruiting team ~30-45 minute video interview with...
Principal
Live in
Work at office
Flexible hours
3 days per week
Vouch Insurance
Chicago, IL
3 days ago
Peoplesoft HR Consultant
...the fields of Telecom, Education, Banking, Retail, e-commerce, Automotive, Life Science, Insurance, legal, healthcare, among others. It also offers outsourcing, consulting, recruitment, career transition, and vendor management services. We strongly believe: " If...
Full time
Contract work
Stemxpert Llc
Chicago, IL
more than 2 months ago
HR Generalist
$100k - $115k
...Honeycomb At Honeycomb, we're not just building technology, we’re reshaping the future of insurance. In 2025, Honeycomb was recognized by Dun & Bradstreet as “ Top 10 Best Start Up Companies to Work For ” in Israel and named by LinkedIn as “ Top 10 Startups in...
Full time
Work at office
Local area
Flexible hours
3 days per week
Honeycomb Insurance
Chicago, IL
more than 2 months ago
Recruiter / HR Specialist
...About the Role We are seeking a Recruiter / HR Specialist to support hiring and people operations across several growing businesses in accounting, marketing, print/production, and technology services. This role will begin with a strong focus on recruiting and talent...
Full time
Work at office
Flexible hours
Shift work
Idelta
Chicago, IL
more than 2 months ago
Principal Security AI Engineer
$90k - $110k
...This is your opportunity to join AXIS Capital – a trusted global provider of specialty lines insurance and reinsurance. We stand apart for our outstanding client service, intelligent risk taking and superior risk adjusted returns for our shareholders. We also proudly maintain...
Principal
Full time
AXIS (AXIS Capital)
Chicago, IL
2 days ago
Senior Recruiter - 1099
...Job Summary We are seeking a Senior Recruiter to manage full-cycle recruitment, focusing on sourcing and engaging passive candidates for hard-to-fill roles, including legal positions. This commission-based, entrepreneurial role is ideal for a self-driven professional...
Full time
Remote work
Flexible hours
Mbc Talent Connections
Chicago, IL
more than 2 months ago
Senior Business Recruiter, GTM
$126.4k - $200k
...future of professional services is being written today — and we’re just getting started. Role Overview The Senior Business Recruiter, GTM partners with Harvey's go-to-market leadership to attract and close top talent across Sales, Customer Success, Partnerships,...
Full time
Harvey, Inc.
Chicago, IL
a month ago
Senior Business Recruiter
$128k - $150k
...continuous improvement in how we hire! As a Senior Business Recruiter, you will manage full-cycle recruiting across a range of corporate... ...-class benefits to fuel your work, including 100% paid health insurance for employees with 90% coverage for dependents. Lifestyle...
Full time
Work at office
Flexible hours
Shift work
3 days per week
Robinhood
Chicago, IL
more than 2 months ago
Senior Recruiter/Lateral Hiring Team (6-month contract)
$90k - $100k
...drives the momentum of Charles River Associates (CRA). As a Senior Recruiter/Lateral at CRA, you will implement global Talent Acquisition... ...requirements, which may include: medical, dental, and vision insurance; 401(k) retirement plan with employer match; life and...
Full time
Contract work
Temporary work
Work experience placement
Work at office
Work from home
3 days per week
Charles River Associates
Chicago, IL
more than 2 months ago
Senior Recruiter- Construction
$110k - $135k
...project and cost management offering in markets around the world. Job Description Turner & Townsend is seeking a Senior Recruiter to join our Talent Acquisition team. This is a high‑impact, full lifecycle recruitment role responsible for managing end‑to‑end hiring...
Full time
Flexible hours
Turner
Chicago, IL
more than 2 months ago
Senior Recruiter
$55k - $80k
...gives us a unique advantage: the freedom to innovate at speed, with the muscle to dominate the market. The Role As a Senior Recruiter, you will develop and execute strategies to attract, assess, and onboard high-quality Flexers across U.S. markets. This role goes...
Remote job
Hourly pay
Full time
Temporary work
Casual work
Work at office
Local area
Immediate start
Monday to Friday
Flexible hours
Shift work
Night shift
Afternoon shift
Indeed
Chicago, IL
a month ago
Senior Recruiter
$60k - $70k
...Senior Recruiter $60,000 - 70,000 + commission. No draw, no thresholds. Owen Daniels is a specialist STEM recruitment and staffing... .... ~ Flexible start and finish times. ~ Health and dental insurance. ~401(k) with employer contribution. ~ Competitive PTO. Your...
Base plus commission
Full time
Work at office
Work from home
Flexible hours
Owen Daniels
Chicago, IL
4 hours ago
Senior Recruiter
$94.1k - $135.5k
...provide a comprehensive benefits package to enable holistic well-being for you and your family.What you'll doYou will work with recruiters and managers within the QuantumBlack, AI by McKinsey, and Experienced Professional hiring team to ensure a strong pipeline of highly...
Apprenticeship
Work experience placement
Work at office
McKinsey & Company
Chicago, IL
1 day ago
Remote Sr. Direct Hire Recruiter
...Strategic Accounts, and field operations collaborate under the company’s One Team philosophy. About the Role The Sr Direct Hire Recruiter is responsible for identifying, attracting, interviewing, and placing top talent into permanent career opportunities across a...
Permanent employment
Full time
Local area
Remote work
PROMAN Staffing USA
Chicago, IL
4 days ago
Senior Recruiter
$51k - $69k
...and expand nationally, we’re looking for a passionate Senior Recruiter to help us build and strengthen our team of clinicians and help... ...compensation, excellent benefits (including 100% paid health insurance premiums), and an environment that prioritizes professional development...
Full time
Temporary work
AnthroMed Education
Chicago, IL
4 days ago
Senior Recruiter
$95k - $140k
OverviewDo you consider yourself a relationship-driven recruiter with the ability to identify, engage, and attract top construction talent? Next 150 Construction is seeking a Senior Recruiter to lead the recruitment of highly skilled self-perform professionals, including...
Contract work
For contractors
Work at office
Local area
Remote work
Flexible hours
Gilbane Building Company
Chicago, IL
3 days ago
Senior Recruiter - Executive & Stakeholder Recruiting
...ContractCategory: Human ResourcesReference ID: 10081714Job record: a1qPL000008JHDRYA4Valid through: 2027-09-16 Job Title: Senior Recruiter - Executive & Stakeholder Recruiting Industry: Consulting / Professional Services Location (city, state): Chicago, IL Assignment Type...
Contract work
Monday to Friday
Addison Group
Chicago, IL
5 days ago

Do you want to receive more vacancies?

Subscribe and receive similar vacancies to Principal Recruiter - Insurance. Be the first to apply!