Sign up to access all features of our service.
  • Job search
  • Favorites
  • Create a CV
    New
  • Salaries
  • Subscriptions

Senior Strategy & Performance Analyst

$100k - $175k

First Chicago Insurance Company

Senior Strategy & Performance Analyst

First Chicago is hiring a Senior Strategy & Performance Analyst to find out why results move and help fix what drives them. Claims is the primary focus.

You will investigate adverse trends and deviations from KPIs, work with business leaders to build practical corrective actions, and track those actions to measured results. This is a root-cause and follow-through role. It is not dashboard production, budgeting, forecasting, or ownership of departmental operations.

You will report to the Chief Accounting Officer & Treasurer and work closely with Financial Planning & Analysis, Accounting, department leadership, and Product & Actuarial. The role will be supported by a dedicated data analyst.

What You Will Do

  • Review KPI reports, financial results, operating metrics, and strategic milestones; identify exceptions, emerging risks, and significant deviations from targets.
  • Investigate underlying causes by state, carrier, program, product, distribution channel, department, and vendor, working directly in the data lake and source systems; separate temporary fluctuations from persistent problems.
  • Validate findings with department leaders and subject-matter experts; challenge assumptions constructively and separate observed facts from hypotheses.
  • Develop corrective-action plans with accountable department heads, with clear owners, timelines, milestones, and success measures.
  • Identify opportunities to reduce costs, improve profitability, optimize resources, and increase productivity; assess return on investment in coordination with Accounting.
  • Maintain a central tracker of approved actions; monitor progress and measured results, assess whether improvements hold, and escalate unresolved issues.
  • Coordinate cross-functional analysis and dependencies without assuming authority over departmental decisions or implementation.
  • Prepare concise monthly executive summaries covering priority exceptions, confirmed causes, recommended actions, owners, progress, quantified benefits, and open risks.
  • Align with enterprise KPI definitions; use existing reports where they are timely and sufficient, and work with the data analyst to build supplemental data and reports where they are not.

Areas of Focus

  • Claims (primary): Claim severity and frequency, calendar and accident year loss ratios, loss development trends, handling trends, cycle times, attorney representation, litigation, complaint ratios and types, vendor costs, loss adjustment expenses, and state/program variances.
  • Personal Lines Underwriting (secondary): Retention, loss ratio and profitability trends, new-business quality, cancellations, underwriting exceptions, producer/program results, cost-benefit of underwriting reports, and operational efficiency.
  • Commercial Lines Underwriting (secondary): Growth and profitability against plan, submission-to-bind conversion, portfolio concentration, retention, underwriting discipline, and program performance.
  • Marketing (secondary): Producer and channel productivity, campaign effectiveness, acquisition costs, conversion, distribution performance, and return on marketing investment.
  • Product & Actuarial (secondary): Product/program profitability, actual-versus-expected performance, rate-change effectiveness, emerging portfolio risks, and initiative outcomes, using analyses produced by Actuarial.

Secondary areas are addressed as assigned. The analyst supports technical owners; actuarial judgments, underwriting decisions, and Claims operations remain with their respective departments.

What You Bring

  • Bachelor's degree in Finance, Accounting, Business, Economics, Analytics, Insurance, or a related field, or equivalent experience.
  • Five or more years of relevant experience in P&C insurance, insurance operations, business performance analysis, strategic planning, or a related field. P&C Claims experience strongly preferred.
  • In-depth knowledge of P&C Claims operations and metrics; working knowledge of Underwriting, Product/Actuarial, and distribution. Cross-functional insurance experience strongly preferred.
  • Strong analytical, financial, and problem-solving skills; ability to connect operational drivers to business results and evaluate cost-benefit and ROI.
  • Excellent executive communication, facilitation, and judgment; ability to influence without direct authority.
  • Advanced Excel; proficiency with SQL and BI/data visualization tools.

How Success Is Measured

Timely, credible root-cause findings; recommendations adopted by business owners; completion of agreed corrective actions; cost savings or operational benefits verified against a documented baseline; sustained improvement in targeted KPIs; and clear, decision-useful executive reporting. Success is not measured by the volume of dashboards or reports produced.

Compensation & Benefits

First Chicago Insurance Company provides a competitive benefits package to all full-time employees. Following are some of the perks First Chicago employees receive:

  • Competitive Salaries
  • Commitment to your Training & Development
  • Medical and Dental
  • Telemedicine Benefit
  • 401k with a generous company match
  • Paid Time Off and Paid Holidays
  • Tuition Reimbursement Training Programs
  • Wellness Program
  • Fun company sponsored events
  • And so much more!

Estimated Compensation Range: $100k/year-$175K/ann*

*Published ranges are estimates. Offered compensation will be based on experience, skills, education, certifications, and geographic location. In addition, starting salary may vary by position depending on whether the position is in-office, hybrid or remote.

First Chicago Insurance Company
Vacancy posted 1 day ago
Similar jobs that could be interesting for youBased on the Senior Strategy & Performance Analyst in Bedford Park, IL vacancy
  •  ...Senior Building Performance Analyst Do more than just model! At dbHMS, we are a collection of doers and thinkers. We combine our passion for engineering...  .... This includes but is not limited to: technologies/strategies associated with high performance building design, ever... 
    Senior
    Work at office
    Remote work
    Worldwide
    Flexible hours
    Shift work

    dbHMS

    Chicago, IL
    1 day ago
  • $192.56k - $264.77k

     ...Senior Director R&D Strategy and Performance The Senior Director, Strategy & Performance Global R&D is accountable for shaping and orchestrating the end-to-end R&D strategy and performance agenda, ensuring priorities, portfolio, capabilities, resources, budgets and... 
    Senior

    Mars

    Chicago, IL
    1 hour ago
  • Senior Business Manager- Global Acceptance Strategy Summary: As a Senior Manager, Business Analysis at Capital One, you will apply your strategic...  ...support your projects. You will lead a team of high performing analysts and be expected to support their professional... 
    Senior
    Full time
    Temporary work
    Shift work

    Capital One

    Chicago, IL
    5 hours ago
  • $111.5k - $163.8k

     ...Our Bainbridge Island studio is seeking a Senior Regenerative Design Advisor who is...  ...role, you will guide regenerative design strategies across a diverse portfolio of projects,...  ...bringing expertise in areas such as high-performance water, energy, and carbon analysis; ecological... 
    Senior
    Full time
    Temporary work
    For contractors
    Work at office
    Local area

    Perkins&Will

    Chicago, IL
    2 days ago
  • $175k - $250k

     ...Technology Strategy Senior Principal Publicis Sapient is a digital transformation partner helping established organizations get to their future, digitally-enabled state, both in the way they work and the way they serve their customers. We help unlock value through a... 
    Senior

    Team One

    Chicago, IL
    1 day ago
  • $89.8k - $112.2k

     ...Senior Analyst, BU Sales & Strategy We are hiring across multiple Business Unit teams internally. The primary responsibility of the Senior Analyst...  .... Key components of the role: Analyze business performance (sales, distribution, merchandising, innovation speed... 
    Senior
    Seasonal work
    Flexible hours

    Kraft Heinz

    Chicago, IL
    1 day ago
  • $190k - $200k

     ...Communications. This role involves developing corporate communications strategies, managing media relations, and overseeing events. The ideal...  ..., strong writing skills, and the ability to guide senior leaders. The position offers a salary range between $190,000 to... 
    Senior
    Flexible hours

    Financialnarrative

    Chicago, IL
    1 day ago
  • $84k - $202k

     ...The Opportunity As a Sustainability Strategy Senior Associate Intern, you will engage with clients to develop and implement strategies that promote sustainable growth and competitive advantage. Within our Advisory practice, you will leverage your skills to guide clients... 
    Senior
    Summer work
    Internship
    H1b

    PwC

    Chicago, IL
    2 days ago
  • $84k - $202k

     ...The Opportunity As a Strategy& Deals Strategy Private Equity - Senior Associate Intern, you will engage in supporting our clients through the complexities of mergers, acquisitions, and other business transactions. Within our Advisory practice, you will be part of a team... 
    Senior
    Summer work
    Internship
    H1b

    PwC

    Chicago, IL
    2 days ago
  • Hearts & Science in Chicago, IL is seeking a Senior Associate to deliver effective media plan recommendations and steward client brands...  ...accurately and promptly. You will contribute to audience-first strategies, collaborate with internal teams, and present thoughtful media... 
    Senior

    Hearts & Science

    Chicago, IL
    1 hour ago
  • $84k - $202k

     ...The Opportunity As a Strategy& Strategy Consulting Senior Associate Intern you will support client work within our Advisory practice, focusing on strategy and business transformation assignments that help organizations define priorities, shape direction, and develop... 
    Senior
    Summer work
    Internship
    H1b

    PwC

    Chicago, IL
    2 days ago
  •  ...Senior Vice President of Insights & Creative Strategy About the Company A communications agency specializing in insights, planning, and creative strategy. Industry Marketing and Advertising Type Privately Held About the Role The Company is seeking... 
    Senior

    Confidential

    Chicago, IL
    4 days ago
  • $175k - $250k

     ...Technology Strategy, Senior Principal | Pharma Publicis Sapient is a digital transformation partner helping established organizations get to their future, digitally enabled state, both in the way they work and the way they serve their customers. We help unlock value... 
    Senior
    Local area
    Worldwide

    Prodigious Worldwide

    Chicago, IL
    1 hour ago
  • $50k - $90k

    A leading marketing agency in Chicago seeks a Senior Analyst, Paid Social to redefine brand engagement through innovative strategies. You'll lead a team, manage social media campaigns, and engage with clients to achieve outstanding results. Ideal candidates have 4+ years... 
    Senior
    Full time

    CMI Media Group

    Chicago, IL
    4 days ago
  • iHeartMedia, the leading audio company in America, seeks a Senior Manager for Digital Media Strategy & Planning in Chicago. You will craft integrated digital campaigns across streaming audio, podcasts, social, and live events, and serve as a strategic partner to the sales... 
    Senior

    iHeartMedia

    Chicago, IL
    11 hours ago
  • $84k - $202k

     ...The Opportunity As a Strategy& Deals Strategy Senior Associate Intern you will support client-focused strategy work across deal strategy, diligence, execution, and post-deal value creation within our Advisory practice. As an Intern you will support teams, participate... 
    Senior
    Summer work
    Internship
    H1b

    PwC

    Chicago, IL
    2 days ago
  •  ...Senior Vice President, State Strategy & Partnerships About the Company Ambitious provider of STEM education programs Industry Primary/Secondary Education Type Non Profit Founded 1997 Employees 201-500 Specialties stem education stem curriculum... 
    Senior

    Confidential

    Chicago, IL
    1 day ago
  • $95k - $140k

     ...Building Company in the United States is seeking a Senior Recruiter to lead recruitment for self-perform construction professionals across multiple markets....  ...design and execute divisional and national recruiting strategies, build talent pipelines, and improve candidate... 
    Senior
    Remote work

    Gilbane Building Company

    Chicago, IL
    11 hours ago
  • WPP Media in Chicago is seeking a Senior Associate, Planning to help develop media strategy and media plans, and make insightful recommendations aligned with the approved strategy. You will manage daily tasks for stewarding approved plans and train Associates in media fundamentals... 
    Senior

    WPP

    Chicago, IL
    1 day ago
  • A healthcare consulting firm based in Chicago is looking for a motivated Strategy & Operations Consultant / Senior Consultant to enhance patient care and improve healthcare operations. This role is remote and offers a salary range of $70,000-$135,000 with additional bonuses... 
    Senior
    Remote job

    Impact Advisors, LLC

    Chicago, IL
    2 days ago
  •  ...Studios, a Chicago-based web design and optimization firm, seeks a Senior SEO & AI Search Strategist to lead SEO, GEO/AEO, and CRO for up...  ...of PMs, writers, and analytics pros to craft holistic content strategies that drive visible, high-converting websites. Your role blends... 
    Senior
    Remote job

    Orbit Media Studios

    Chicago, IL
    2 days ago
  • $175k - $250k

     ...company and the customers simultaneously, and a unique fusing of strategy and consulting, experience and engineering with an enduring...  ...Atlanta, and Washington DC. OverviewYour ImpactThe purpose of the Senior Principal, Data Strategy is to work with clients undergoing a... 
    Senior

    Publicis Media

    Chicago, IL
    3 days ago
  •  ...Groupe is seeking an Search Engine Optimization Senior Analyst to contribute to brand online marketing strategy. You will collaborate with Marketing, Creative,...  ...keyword and content optimization, link-building, and performance reporting, with a focus on data-driven decisions... 
    Senior

    Publicis Groupe

    Chicago, IL
    2 days ago
  • $164.6k - $288k

     ...technology and exceptional service. Position SummaryThe Senior Principal, Identity & Access Management (IAM) Strategy & Product Management, is responsible for defining...  .... This role will drive innovation, establish performance measures, and ensure IAM capabilities align with... 
    Senior
    Full time
    H1b
    Worldwide
    Flexible hours

    Northern Trust

    Chicago, IL
    11 hours ago
  •  ...Senior Vice President, Data & AI Strategy & Transformation About the Company Dynamic provider of small business financing solutions Industry Financial Services Type Privately Held Founded 2006 Employees 501-1000 Categories ~ Financial Services... 
    Senior

    Confidential

    Chicago, IL
    3 days ago
  •  ...Senior Vice President, Marketing & New Product Strategy About the Company Innovative pharmaceutical company specializing in needle-free epinephrine &...  ...The leader will also manage budgets, build a high-performing team, and ensure commercial and communications activities... 
    Senior

    Confidential

    Chicago, IL
    4 days ago
  •  ...Senior Director, Strategy to the Chief People Officer (CPO) About the Company Prominent healthcare services company Industry Hospital & Health Care Type Privately Held, Private Equity-backed Founded 1979 Employees 10,001+ Categories Health... 
    Senior
    Work at office

    Confidential

    Chicago, IL
    2 days ago
  • $120k - $140k

     ...Your ambition has a home here. Senior TBM Planning Analyst We are hiring a Senior TBM (Technology...  ...Analyst to join our Enterprise Strategy and Technology Planning function....  ...executive dashboards and financial performance metrics Partner with Cloud FinOps... 
    Senior
    Full time
    Contract work
    Local area

    HUB International

    Chicago, IL
    11 hours ago
  •  ...Senior Vice President, Product Management, Data Products & Strategy About the Company Innovative provider of cloud-based software & services for the senior...  ...also be tasked with driving adoption, commercial performance, and scalable product growth, as well as... 
    Senior

    Confidential

    Chicago, IL
    3 days ago
  • This role is with our Partners in Performance team, part of Accenture.Partners in Performance...  ...boardroom. As a Partners in Performance Senior Principal you will provide overall, on-...  ...methods and tools.Develop and quantify strategies for optimizing the organization's operations... 
    Senior
    Live in
    Work at office
    Local area
    Immediate start
    Remote work

    Accenture

    Chicago, IL
    2 days ago

Do you want to receive more vacancies?

Subscribe and receive similar vacancies to Senior Strategy & Performance Analyst. Be the first to apply!