Sign up to access all features of our service.
  • Job search
  • Favorites
  • Create a CV
    New
  • Salaries
  • Subscriptions

Commercial Insurance Producer

MHG Hotels

MHG is continuing to grow and is looking for a driven, relationship-focused Commercial Insurance Producer to support our commercial insurance program across our expanding hospitality portfolio. This role is ideal for someone who understands commercial P&C (property, liability, auto, umbrella, etc.), has experience with middle-market commercial accounts, enjoys working closely with business leaders, and is motivated to both manage existing accounts and help generate new opportunities.

This is a hybrid-style role that combines day-to-day account management with light business development/production. You'll work closely with property teams and leadership to ensure strong coverage, proactive risk management, and continued growth across a multi-property portfolio.
Position Overview

The Commercial Insurance Producer will:
• Own the day-to-day servicing and stewardship of commercial accounts within MHG's hospitality portfolio, and
• Help drive new and expanded opportunities through internal partnerships, referrals, and strategic outreach.

This is not a purely transactional service role and not a high-pressure sales-only role. It is a balanced producer position with strong visibility across the organization and opportunity for long-term growth within MHG.
Why Join MHG?

• Be part of a growing, entrepreneurial hospitality company
• Work directly with leadership and key decision-makers
• Opportunity to build and strengthen insurance and risk processes across a multi-property portfolio
• High-visibility role with the ability to make a direct impact
• Long-term growth potential as MHG continues to expand
Compensation & Benefits

• Competitive base salary based on experience
• Performance-based incentives (tied to retention, coverage quality, and growth)
• Growth opportunities within MHG
• Paid vacation and flex days
• 401(k) with employer contribution
• Voluntary benefits including:
o Medical, dental, vision
o Life insurance
o Short-term and long-term disability
Key Responsibilities

• Support and manage day-to-day commercial P&C insurance activities across the portfolio
• Prepare and review applications, submissions, and policy documentation
• Coordinate with carriers, brokers, and partners to obtain and evaluate quotes and program options
• Assist with certificates of insurance, endorsements, and renewals
• Maintain accurate and organized records across systems (e.g., agency management or internal tracking tools)
• Partner with property teams to understand operational needs and risk exposures
• Provide proactive recommendations to improve coverage and reduce risk
• Assist with claims coordination and follow-up as needed
• Ensure accuracy, compliance, and timeliness of all documentation

Business Development / Production:
• Support new business opportunities through internal referrals and partnerships
• Identify gaps in coverage and cross-sell/upsell opportunities within the portfolio
• Follow up on quotes and support the close-out/bind process
• Contribute to overall growth initiatives across MHG's hospitality portfolio
Required Qualifications

• Active Property & Casualty license
• Experience in commercial lines P&C insurance (preferably middle-market)
• Strong understanding of core commercial coverages and risk management principles
• Highly organized and detail-oriented
• Strong communication skills, both written and verbal
• Ability to manage multiple priorities in a fast-paced environment and work cross-functionally with operations and leadership
Preferred Qualifications

• Experience supporting multi-location or hospitality-focused businesses (e.g., hotels, restaurants, real estate)
• Familiarity with agency management systems or similar policy administration tools
• Experience working with carriers, brokers, or MGAs on program design and marketing
• Demonstrated ability to balance account management with light business development/production
Physical Requirements

This role requires extended periods of computer use, including typing, reviewing documents, and working across multiple systems. The position may involve sitting for long periods of time and maintaining consistent communication via phone and email.

MHG Hotels LLC is an equal opportunity employer and does not discriminate on the basis of disability, veteran status or any other basis protected under federal, state or local laws. If you are an individual with a disability and need assistance completing the online application, please call View phone number on click.appcast.io. Please leave a message and a member of our Human Resources team will return your call within three business days. Alternatively, an email may be sent to View email address on click.appcast.io. "Applicant Accommodation" should be included in the subject line of the email. Please note that this phone number and email are only for those individuals who would like to request an accommodation to apply for a job.
Vacancy posted 2 days ago
Similar jobs that could be interesting for youBased on the Commercial Insurance Producer in Indianapolis, IN vacancy
  •  ...country, and now we've come together to create the next great insurance brokerage. We offer an unrivaled combination of people, tools...  ...place new business accounts. Works closely with less seasoned Producers to mentor the sales and production cycle to ensure success.... 
    Commercial
    Flexible hours

    Trucordia

    Indianapolis, IN
    5 days ago
  •  ...Commercial Insurance Sales Producer The Industry Specialized Program for Select Commercial Insurance Sales Producer is a comprehensive sales and insurance program focused on outside sales driving new business sales revenue growth of commercial business clients ($10mm... 
    Commercial
    Work at office
    Local area

    USI Insurance Services

    Carmel, IN
    6 days ago
  • $175k

    Producer - Property & Casualty Join to apply for the Producer - Property & Casualty role at USI Insurance Services. Description and Requirements General Description Outside Commercial Lines sales position. Responsible for driving business sales, retention, and growing... 
    Commercial
    Temporary work
    Local area
    Flexible hours

    USI Insurance Services

    Carmel, IN
    6 days ago
  • $80k

     ...Outside Commercial Lines Sales Position Outside commercial lines sales position. Responsible for driving new business sales and retention...  ...market knowledge and advanced understanding of technical insurance issues. Take part in national vertical meetings and video calls... 
    Commercial
    Temporary work
    Local area
    Flexible hours

    USI Insurance Services

    Indianapolis, IN
    6 days ago
  •  ...Job Description About Us McGowan Insurance Group has a concentrated geographic footprint...  ...offering of property and casualty, commercial and personal lines, bonding, and employee...  ...tools to reach theirs. Commercial Lines Producer Position Summary:  McGowan... 
    Commercial
    Work at office
    Monday to Friday

    McGowan Insurance Group

    Indianapolis, IN
    24 days ago
  •  ...directed, strategically minded Business Insurance Advisor who can drive new business...  ...relationships, and operate confidently in complex commercial environments. This role blends...  ...supporting and mentoring early-career producers when appropriate What We’re Looking... 
    Commercial

    Gregory & Appel Inc

    Indianapolis, IN
    15 days ago
  •  ...and high-school interns, and have over 100 years of combined insurance experience. We take pride in serving people, have a fun culture...  ...Base pay plus commission and bonuses. Average first year producer is 75-85k with uncapped potential. No Nights or Weekends,... 
    Base plus commission
    Full time
    For contractors
    Work at office
    Flexible hours
    Weekend work

    State Farm

    Carmel, IN
    4 days ago
  • $80k

     ...-selling strategies for existing clients. • Innovate for clients using market knowledge and advanced understanding of technical insurance issues. • Use USI's contact management and sales automation tool to support sales processes. Input timely and accurate information... 
    Temporary work
    Local area
    Flexible hours

    USI Holdings Corporation

    Carmel, IN
    3 days ago
  •  ...builds foundational knowledge of industry-specific risks and insurance coverages, including general liability, property, workers' compensation...  ...in meeting or exceeding aggressive sales targets in the commercial insurance space. Resilience: A disciplined self-starter who... 
    Commercial

    Gregory & Appel

    Indianapolis, IN
    3 days ago
  •  ...Insurance Producer - Indianapolis, IN Join Horace Mann: Empower Educators, Achieve Financial Success Ready to Make a Difference? Join Horace Mann today and take the first step toward achieving your career and financial goals while making a meaningful impact on... 
    Work at office
    Relocation package
    Flexible hours

    Horace Mann

    Indianapolis, IN
    6 days ago
  •  ...Property And Casualty Insurance Producer Join our dynamic team as a Property and Casualty Insurance Producer, where your expertise will drive success in our thriving agency. We are a 100% employee-owned company with a great culture and excellent benefits. We're... 

    Houchens Insurance Group / Curneal Hignite Insurance

    Indianapolis, IN
    4 days ago
  • $80k

     ...opportunity for equity. Participate in Other Industry New Producer development program. Includes e-Learning modules and live training...  ...program as required by state. Must obtain Life & Health insurance license within 8 weeks of start date. Achieve annualized new... 
    Temporary work
    Local area
    Flexible hours

    USI Insurance Services

    Carmel, IN
    3 days ago
  • $50k - $70k

     ...Sales Producer Join an established, Indiana owned and operated insurance company! Since 1934, Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance has been on a mission to redefine the insurance industry by providing a supportive, community-driven, and training-rich environment for our... 
    Work at office
    Local area

    Indiana Fram Insurance

    Indianapolis, IN
    6 days ago
  • Jurs Insurance and Financial Services, Inc. is looking for an enthusiastic individual ready to help customers and build relationships. The role involves engaging with potential clients, developing new business opportunities, and collaborating with a dynamic team. Ideal... 
    Flexible hours

    Jurs Insurance and Financial Services, Inc.

    Carmel, IN
    3 days ago
  • Houchens Insurance Group INC. in Indianapolis, Indiana, seeks a Property and Casualty Insurance Producer to drive success in their agency. The role involves selling insurance to clients and analyzing their risk needs. Ideal candidates should possess a Bachelor's degree... 

    Houchens Insurance Group INC.

    Indianapolis, IN
    2 days ago
  • ADAM JURS-STATE FARM AGENT is hiring in Carmel, Indiana, for a role centered on customer engagement and relationship building. This opportunity emphasizes a service-driven approach to sales, aiming to make a positive community impact. The ideal candidate possesses strong...
    Base plus commission
    Flexible hours

    ADAM JURS-STATE FARM AGENT

    Carmel, IN
    6 days ago
  • Insurewithjurs in Indianapolis is seeking a dedicated customer service representative to engage with prospective customers. You will build relationships, support acquisition goals, and collaborate with team members to drive new business opportunities. The ideal candidate...
    Base plus commission
    Flexible hours

    Insurewithjurs

    Indianapolis, IN
    6 days ago
  • Horace Mann is seeking an Insurance Producer in Indiana who will support educators by providing tailored financial solutions. The role emphasizes mentorship while allowing for flexible work options. Successful candidates can expect a performance-based compensation structure... 
    Remote job
    Flexible hours

    Horace Mann

    Greenwood, IN
    2 days ago
  • Horace Mann is seeking an Insurance Producer to join their team in Indianapolis. You will receive mentorship and training while helping educators secure their financial futures. The role involves presenting tailored financial solutions to clients and engaging in community... 
    Relocation package
    Flexible hours

    Horace Mann

    Indianapolis, IN
    6 days ago
  •  ...Senior Vice President, Insurance Producer About the Company Top-tier insurance broker Industry Insurance Type Privately Held About the Role The Company is seeking a Senior Vice President, Insurance Producer to join their team. The successful candidate... 

    Confidential

    Indianapolis, IN
    7 days ago
  •  ...Description Job Summary: The purpose of this position is to source commercial, personal and group benefits prospects in order to covert...  .... Duties/Responsibilities: Solicit and procure insurance customers Work closely with Account Executives to service... 
    Commercial

    Dimond Bros Insurance

    Carmel, IN
    3 days ago
  •  ...Insurance Office of America is hiring an Account Manager - Commercial Lines for fully remote work focusing on managing client accounts and ensuring services are delivered effectively. The successful candidate will lead the account management team and handle policy management... 
    Commercial
    Work at office
    Remote work

    Insurance Office of America

    Indianapolis, IN
    2 days ago
  •  ...Amerisure Insurance is seeking a Senior Auto Physical Damage Claims Representative to manage claims in a hybrid work environment based in Indianapolis, IN. This role focuses on investigating commercial auto claims, evaluating damages, and fostering relationships with policyholders... 
    Commercial

    Amerisure Insurance

    Indianapolis, IN
    2 days ago
  • $80k - $200k

     ...homeowners navigate the process of replacing their roofs through insurance. With severe weather events increasing across the country,...  ...reputable company in the roofing and restoration space. Help commercial and residential owners recover from natural disasters and storm... 
    Commercial
    For contractors

    Restoremasters Contracting LLC

    Indianapolis, IN
    2 days ago
  • A reputable insurance agency located in Carmel, Indiana is seeking a Commercial Lines Account Manager. The ideal candidate will assist in handling commercial lines business, providing exceptional customer service, and working closely with insurance advisors. Preferred qualifications... 
    Commercial

    Shepherd Insurance

    Carmel, IN
    4 days ago
  • WalkerHughes Insurance, located in Carmel, Indiana, is looking for an experienced Commercial Lines Account Manager. The role involves managing an established book of business, providing exceptional client service, and ensuring accurate policy administration. Candidates... 
    Commercial

    WalkerHughes Insurance

    Carmel, IN
    3 days ago
  • Houchens Insurance Group INC. is seeking a motivated analyst to manage requests from policyholders regarding insurance policies and provide excellent service. This role emphasizes client relationship management and teamwork within the production team. The ideal candidate... 
    Commercial

    Houchens Insurance Group INC.

    Indianapolis, IN
    2 days ago
  • Insurance Office of America is seeking an Account Manager for Commercial Lines in Indianapolis. Candidates have the option of hybrid or fully remote work setup. The role requires effective account management, addressing client needs and ensuring excellent service. The... 
    Commercial
    Remote job
    Work at office

    Insurance Office of America

    Indianapolis, IN
    6 days ago
  •  ...area and may involve driving to the Carmel office. The ideal candidate will have strong communication skills and experience in commercial insurance. Responsibilities include managing policy documentation, client relationships, and ensuring compliance with U.S. insurance... 
    Commercial
    Remote job
    Work at office

    EPIC Brokers

    Carmel, IN
    2 days ago
  • A private insurance agency is seeking a dedicated individual to provide exceptional service to clients, coordinate with advisors, and...  ...state licensing certification, and a strong understanding of commercial insurance coverages. Work involves a variety of office tasks using... 
    Commercial
    Work at office

    Shepherd Insurance LLC

    Indianapolis, IN
    4 days ago

Do you want to receive more vacancies?

Subscribe and receive similar vacancies to Commercial Insurance Producer. Be the first to apply!