Sign up to access all features of our service.
  • Job search
  • Favorites
  • Create a CV
    New
  • Salaries
  • Subscriptions

Production Underwriter

$100k - $125k

Donegal Insurance Group

Job Description

Job Description

About the Role

Donegal Insurance Group has an opening for a Production Underwriter in the state of Indiana. As a member of our Commercial Lines team, this position will play a key role in generating new commercial lines business opportunities within a given territory. This is a full-time, remote position. The preferred candidates will live in the Indianapolis area. 

Responsibilities and Duties

  • Develop strong business relationships with key agents and provide underwriting guidance to the agents.
  • Select, price, and develop coverage terms for commercial lines accounts to achieve profitable underwriting results and assist with providing leadership, support, and coaching for the underwriting function
  • Manage a territory of independent agents to ensure that profitability and growth objectives for the company are being met
  • Review new business applications to evaluate the degree of risk involved
  • Accept or decline risks based on the company's underwriting policies
  • Review application for completeness
  • Contact agents for missing or incomplete information
  • Maintain a profitable book of business within assigned levels of authority by using sound underwriting judgment and technical skills, and continued personal development to meet the company goals of quality and timeliness
  • Interpret insurance coverages for agents and insureds
  • Maintain and establish a good working relationship with agents and communicate underwriting decisions to agents and insureds

Qualifications and Skills

  • Bachelor’s Degree with a background in insurance or equivalent experience
  • 8 years of underwriting and marketing experience at a company or agency level with a minimum of 5 years of underwriting experience should be in the commercial lines sector of insurance
  • Demonstration of self-development through the attainment of professional insurance designations, CPCU, ARM, PLU, etc.
  • Ability to create business opportunities by demonstrating excellent underwriting skills and product knowledge. Must possess a value-added service mentality
  • The expectation is this employee will travel 2 to 3 days per week to visit agents in the designated territory.
  • The preferred candidate will have a working knowledge of the Indianapolis/Indiana territory and established Property/Casualty agency relationship.

Starting Pay: The pay range for this position is $100,000 to $125,000 annually. The specific offer will vary based on an applicant's education, qualifications, professional experience, skills, abilities, and any applicable designations/certifications. The posted pay range reflects our ability to hire at different position titles and levels depending on background and experience. The pay range may also be adjusted based on an applicant's geographic location.

Performance-Based Incentive Opportunity: In addition to base salary, this position is eligible for a performance-based incentive opportunity tied to results within the assigned territory. The incentive is based on individual performance for the territory and is not guaranteed.


To apply, please submit your resume and online application

Competitive Benefits Package

Donegal Insurance Group offers a comprehensive benefits package for all full-time, permanent positions including:

  • Medical, Dental, and Vision Coverage : Available to you and your dependents. Coverage begins the first of the month after start date.
  • 401(k) with the first 3% matched at 100% : the next 6% is matched at 50%
  • Paid Time Off : Paid vacation, sick days, paid holidays, & bereavement days
  • Career Development : Including college partnership discounts and industry designation(s) reimbursements

Additional benefits include company-paid basic life insurance; short & long-term disability insurance; employee stock purchase plan; and employee assistance program (EAP). Learn more about our full benefit offerings by visiting our Benefits page.

Who We Are

Donegal Insurance Group provides commercial and personal insurance products through a network of independent agents in 21 states and across several regions of the U.S. In Texas, Colorado, Utah, New Mexico and Arizona, business is conducted under the Mountain States Insurance Group name; and in Michigan, business is conducted under the Michigan Insurance name.

Headquartered in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, along with four (4) regional offices located in: Athens, GA, Grand Rapids, MI, Albuquerque, NM, and Glen Allen, VA , our steady growth and successes have allowed us to establish a culture of which we're proud. Check out our Glassdoor profile where our rating speaks for itself:

By joining Donegal, you would be joining a team of dedicated, hard-working employees, all with a common goal of providing peace of mind to our policyholders and being There when it matters most.™ .

Work Arrangement

With each department and position being different, the work arrangement for a specific position will be reviewed with candidates during a initial phone screening. For a position not requiring an onsite expectation at one of our offices, the ideal candidate must live within our Donegal footprint. Current approved states are: AL, AZ, CT, DE, FL, GA, IA, IL, IN, MD, MI, MN, MO, NC, ND, NE, NH, NJ, NM, NY, OH, PA, SC, SD, TN, TX, UT, VA, WI, and, WV . (Please note, this list is subject to change without notice.)

E-Verify

Donegal Insurance Group participates in E-Verify in the following states: Alabama, Arizona, Florida, Georgia, Louisiana, Mississippi, Nebraska, North Carolina, South Carolina, Tennessee, and Utah . If you reside in one of the listed states, please review the "Notice of E-Verify Participation" and the "Right to Work Poster" on the links below:

  • Notice of E-Verify Participation Poster (English and Spanish)
  • Right to Work Poster (English and Spanish)

Powered by JazzHR

f6CKnXwsnZ

Vacancy posted 3 days ago
Similar jobs that could be interesting for youBased on the Production Underwriter in Indianapolis, IN vacancy
  • $119.5k - $199.1k

     ...Markets business focuses on mid-sized customers in the US Commercial P&C market.In this role you will be responsible for underwriting our Middle Market products and establishing broker and client relationships in the Central Zone to support growing this business.What you’ll... 
    Suggested
    Flexible hours

    AXA Group

    Indianapolis, IN
    3 days ago
  • $67.5k - $172.5k

     ...culture where all of our employees feel respected, valued and have an opportunity to contribute to the company’s success. As an Underwriter III within PNC's Real Estate Banking organization, you will be based in a PNC location.The Entity Finance Underwriter is responsible... 
    Suggested
    Full time
    Temporary work
    Part time
    Work experience placement
    Work at office

    The PNC Financial Services Group

    Indianapolis, IN
    2 days ago
  • $83.3k - $177.87k

    Commercial Underwriter - ABL Job Locations US-IL-Chicago | US-MN-St Louis Park | US-IN-Indianapolis | US-TN-Nashville | US-MI-Grand...  ...by Loan Review, OCC, and credit approvers. Meet or exceed productivity expectations for annual credit approval memorandum (CAM)... 
    Suggested
    Full time
    Work at office
    Flexible hours
    Shift work

    Old National Bank

    Indianapolis, IN
    4 days ago
  • $62.7k

     ...small and mid-sized clients in conformance with established underwriting policies, practices, and standards. May prepare a variety of...  ...internal departments. Complete workload within established production and timeliness standards. Perform administrative tasks and... 
    Suggested
    Contract work
    For contractors
    Work at office
    Local area

    Highmark Health

    Indianapolis, IN
    2 days ago
  • $90.56k - $152.72k

    ## Business Development Underwriter - Indianapolis/Northern INApplylocations: IN - Remotetime type: Full timeposted on: Posted Todayjob...  ...control a profitable and growing book of business.* Monitors production and quality of assigned producers.* Drives profitable sale of... 
    Suggested
    Work at office
    Local area
    Remote work
    Home office

    ICW Group

    Indianapolis, IN
    5 days ago
  •  ...The Hanover Insurance Group is seeking an Underwriter to join Hanover Specialty Insurance in Indianapolis. The role focuses on underwriting renewal Specialty accounts, driving profitable growth, and aligning with appetite and mix goals. The incumbent will apply advanced... 

    The Hanover Insurance Group

    Indianapolis, IN
    7 hours ago
  • $600 per month

     ...Compensation Disclosure This position is a commission-only based sales position. The average commission on a mortgage protection product is approximately $600 per family you protect. Our expectation is that a full-time agent will sell 5 to 10 mortgage protection plans... 
    Full time
    Part time
    Remote work
    Flexible hours
    2 days per week

    Spieldenner Financial Group

    Indianapolis, IN
    1 day ago
  •  ...Commercial UnderwriterThe Commercial Underwriter provides accurate, timely, and succinct credit underwriting to support the company's portfolio management and new business development efforts. This role focuses on CRE loans.Duties & ResponsibilitiesFinancial statement... 
    Work at office

    Busey

    Carmel, IN
    1 day ago
  • $57k - $113k

     ...Description Summary: The Business Banking Underwriter II - Practice Finance is responsible for underwriting Business Banking loans...  ...Duties and Responsibilities: Supports Business Banking production by maintaining an individual pipeline of work. Reviews all... 
    Full time
    H1b
    Work at office
    Remote work
    Work from home
    Flexible hours

    Huntington National Bank

    Indianapolis, IN
    5 days ago
  • $91.39k - $140.74k

     ...company for you!We are currently seeking an experienced Senior Underwriter for our Surplus Lines division.In this role, the underwriter...  ...wording appropriate to the risk.Achieves team/individual production and loss ratio goals with assigned agents / brokers through sound... 
    Contract work
    Work at office
    Local area
    Remote work
    Flexible hours

    FCCI Insurance Group

    Carmel, IN
    7 hours ago
  •  ...Centier Bank in Carmel, IN is seeking an Underwriter 3 to prepare written loan analyses for new and existing commercial loans from $1,000,000 up to the bank's lending limit. You will monitor loans through financial reviews and covenant testing. Experience with moderately... 

    Centier Bank

    Carmel, IN
    5 days ago
  •  ...WorldTrips is seeking a Senior Underwriter in Accident & Health to work in Carmel, Indiana. This hybrid position involves analyzing and reviewing underwriting data for international medical and travel insurance. The role requires a Bachelor's degree and at least five years... 

    WorldTrips

    Carmel, IN
    5 days ago
  •  ...Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance is seeking an underwriting professional in Indianapolis to evaluate insurance applications for acceptability and pricing. The role requires analyzing risks according to guidelines and experience, recommending risk improvement measures, and... 
    Work at office

    Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance

    Indianapolis, IN
    5 days ago
  • Walker is a full-service Experience Management firm based in Indianapolis offering on-site, hybrid, and remote opportunities across the continental U.S. The Director of Contracts & Commercial Risk will own contract lifecycle, negotiate high-value terms with enterprise ...
    Contract work
    Remote work

    Walker

    Indianapolis, IN
    7 hours ago
  •  ...will assist in training less experienced analysts on occasion and will organize department projects when necessary. Job Summary An Underwriter 3 will prepare written loan analyses for new and existing loans for commercial relationships ranging from $1,000,000 up to the... 
    For contractors
    Work at office

    Centier Bank

    Carmel, IN
    5 days ago
  • Senior Underwriter, Accident & Health page is loaded## Senior Underwriter, Accident & Healthlocations: Indiana - Carmeltime type: Full timeposted...  ...executes strategic underwriting and portfolio plans, across product development, distribution, fulfillment, and overall portfolio... 
    Work at office
    Local area

    WorldTrips

    Carmel, IN
    5 days ago
  • $45k - $100k

     ...relationships with 30,000+ Groups nationwide with millions of members needing our services Conventions and incentive trips Production awards Advancement based on performance Weekly advance and bonuses Lifetime renewals Benefits (Health Insurance, Life... 
    Weekly pay
    Contract work
    Remote work
    Work from home
    Flexible hours

    Millennium Recruiting, Inc.

    Indianapolis, IN
    4 days ago
  •  ...Associate Vice President, Life Sciences Underwriter About the Company A growing specialty E&S insurance carrier Industry Insurance Type Privately Held About the Role The Company is seeking an Associate Vice President, Life Sciences Underwriter to... 

    Confidential

    Indianapolis, IN
    1 day ago
  • $148.5k - $257.4k

    Job ID: R-109584Company: LillyLocation: Indianapolis, Indiana, United States of AmericaJob Type: Full TimeCategory: Manufacturing/QualityPosted Date: 2026-08-21At Lilly, the work is demanding because patients are waiting. We unite caring with discovery to help make life...
    Flexible hours

    Eli Lilly and Company

    Indianapolis, IN
    1 day ago
  •  ...Your ability to independently assess complex risk and sell our products in challenging markets will contribute to the profitability...  ...profitability, growth, and retention of an assigned book of business.Underwrite and skillfully negotiate complex customer accounts to minimize... 
    Full time
    Work at office
    Local area
    Work from home

    The Travelers Indemnity Company

    Indianapolis, IN
    3 days ago
  • Shepherd Insurance LLC in Carmel, Indiana is seeking a Licensed Agent for its Medicare Insurance Division. This role involves providing high-level Medicare insurance consultation and customer service. Qualifications include at least two years of related experience, the ...
    Work at office

    Shepherd Insurance LLC

    Carmel, IN
    1 day ago
  • $10,000 per month

     ...teachers and public employees with retirement planning , including tax-efficient retirement and financial protection strategies using products such as Indexed Universal Life (IUL) insurance and annuities . Our goal is simple: help agents spend more time having... 
    Remote job
    Hourly pay
    Full time
    For contractors
    Flexible hours

    MeridianLight

    Indianapolis, IN
    24 days ago
  • $72k - $141k

     ...Reporting RelationshipTypically Director or aboveSkills, Knowledge & AbilitiesThorough knowledge of the commercial insurance industry, products, policy language, coverage, and claim practices.Strong communication and presentation skills both verbal and written, including... 
    Full time
    Work experience placement
    Work at office
    Local area
    Remote work
    Shift work

    CNA Financial

    Indianapolis, IN
    1 day ago
  •  ...Carmel, Indiana. This position provides autonomy and flexibility while helping clients protect their assets with various insurance products. New hires will receive comprehensive training, benefit from a supportive team culture, and gain access to significant earning... 
    Flexible hours

    Comparion Insurance Agency

    Carmel, IN
    1 day ago
  • The Griffin Agency is seeking motivated individuals to join our team as insurance sales professionals. You will consult with clients, determine coverage needs, and present life, health, and retirement solutions. Training is provided, and licensing assistance is offered ...
    Remote job
    Flexible hours

    The Griffin Agency

    Carmel, IN
    5 days ago
  • Rehab Medical LLC in Indianapolis, IN is seeking an Insurance Collector to join our team. The Insurance Collector coordinates and processes patient and insurance billing, with a focus on securing payment from Medicare, Medicaid, and private insurers. Qualifications include...
    Work at office

    Rehab Medical LLC

    Indianapolis, IN
    3 days ago
  • $60k - $100k

    Job Location: We are hiring Licensed/Certified Appraisers in the following areas: Indianapolis Fort Wayne Evansville South Bend Bloomington Lafayette Gary About Us Banks Valuation is a growing appraisal firm, founded and led by experienced appraisers who understand the...
    For contractors

    Banks Appraisal Group

    Indianapolis, IN
    2 days ago
  •  ...valuation techniques and methodologies Exhibit an ability to pay attention to detail in order to provide a higher‑quality valuation product for the client Exercise the ability to effectively manage daily activities in order to efficiently establish a reasonable capacity... 
    Full time
    Traineeship
    Remote work
    Long distance

    True Footage

    Indianapolis, IN
    2 days ago
  •  ...flexibility you have today. As a part of the Velox Staff Appraiser Team, you'll set your own schedules, choose assignments, and set your production goals. You'll also benefit from one-on-one support and best practice knowledge sharing within our team. Description Velox... 
    Bi-weekly pay
    Full time
    Traineeship
    Work at office
    Local area

    Velox Valuations LLC

    Greenwood, IN
    7 hours ago
  •  ...forms to develop foundational knowledge on Company insurance products Learn and comply with Company claim handling procedures...  ..., and maintain a driving record consistent with the Company's underwriting guidelines for coverage Continually develop product knowledge... 
    Traineeship
    Local area
    Remote work
    Work from home

    Auto-Owners Insurance

    Indianapolis, IN
    2 days ago

Do you want to receive more vacancies?

Subscribe and receive similar vacancies to Production Underwriter. Be the first to apply!