Payroll Supervisor - Long Island
Insite US
The Opportunity
I am partnering with a Top 100 CPA firm . They are rapidly expanding their footprint and looking for an experienced Payroll Supervisor to join their finance team on Long Island.
Reporting directly to the Controller , you will step into a highly visible role managing a complex, multi-entity payroll architecture with robust resources and clear paths for upward career mobility.
The Role & Scope
- Direct Report: Controller
- Scale: Managing payroll operations for 500+ employees
- Entities: Overseeing 4 distinct entities covering a diverse workforce (Interns, Managers, Senior Managers, Directors, and Partners)
- Schedules: Navigating multi-tiered pay frequencies, including Bi-weekly and Monthly schedules
Key Qualifications
- Experience: Minimum of 3+ years of dedicated payroll processing experience. (Note: Experience inside a CPA firm is not required—corporate backgrounds are highly welcome!)
- Systems: Hands-on, proficient experience with Workday is a strict requirement. (Bonus points if you also have experience with ADP!)
- Compliance: Strong, practical knowledge of payroll tax laws and multi-entity configurations.
Why Apply?
- High Growth Environment: Enjoy the stability of an established firm.
- Work-Life Balance: Strong focus on cultural flexibility, including a hybrid work structure for Long Island residents.
- Comprehensive Rewards: Highly competitive base salary, annual discretionary bonuses, open PTO, and excellent retirement matching.
Vacancy posted 7 days ago
Similar jobs that could be interesting for youBased on the Payroll Supervisor - Long Island in Melville, NY vacancy
- Darwin Recruitment on Long Island is seeking a detail‑oriented Production Specialist to support payroll production and packaging for business clients. This on‑site role with hybrid flexibility focuses on accurate preparation, quality checks and timely distribution of payroll...Suggested
$100k
DescriptionKforce's client, a rapidly growing CPA firm (60+ staff) in the Woodbury Long Island, NY area, is seeking a Tax Manager/Senior Manager who is looking to be on the partner track. This company has outstanding, competitive compensation commensurate with experience...SuggestedWork at officeLocal areaKforce
Woodbury, NY4 days ago$85k - $100k
...Job DescriptionJob DescriptionAssistant Project Manager (APM) – Commercial Construction Location: Long Island, NY (Future opportunities throughout the NYC Five Boroughs)Salary: $85,000–$100,000 (Based on Experience)Employment Type: Full-Time About the OpportunityNorthPoint...SuggestedFull timeContract workFor contractorsFor subcontractorWork at officeLocal areaNorthPoint Staffing
Hauppauge, NY3 days ago- ...Long Island CPA firm is seeking a Tax Supervisor due to recent growth! In this role, you will be responsible for providing tax and accounting services to a variety of small businesses and individuals throughout the NY Metro area. Key Responsibilities Ensure accurate...SuggestedWork at office
Tiger Search Group
Melville, NY23 hours ago $140k - $175k
...175K + Bonus + Profit Sharing Jericho, NY Gpac has partnered with a well-established, highly respected public accounting firm on Long Island seekinga Tax Manager to join their close-knit team. With over 35 years in business, this firm is known for its low turnover, supportive...SuggestedWork at officeRemote workFlexible hoursgpac
Plainview, NY3 days ago$170k - $250k
DescriptionKforce's client in Babylon, NY, a long standing, well respected Long Island based CPA firm with Nassau and Suffolk County, is seeking and Tax Director.Summary:The Tax Director will be responsible for leading and participating on a diverse array of tax assignments...Kforce
West Babylon, NY4 days ago- ...Tax Manager | Suffolk County Long Island, NY Tired of Big 4 hours and bureaucracy? Looking for a firm where people genuinely enjoy coming to work? Our client is seeking a Tax Supervisor/strong Sr. to join an outstanding team known for its collaborative culture, strong...
LinkedIn
West Babylon, NY23 hours ago $180k - $265k
...sized public accounting and advisory firm with over 50 years of experience serving a diverse client base. With offices in NYC and Long Island, we provide comprehensive tax, assurance, and consulting services to high-net-worth individuals, privately held businesses, and...Work at officeLocal area$31.75 - $34 per hour
...Care Manager - Long Island (Bilingual in Bengali) Hauppauge Hub - Hauppauge, NY 11788; Lake Success Hub - Lake Success, NY 11040; Riverhead Hub - Riverhead, NY 11901 Overview Salary Range $31.75 - $34.00 Hourly Position Type Full Time Education Level 4 Year Degree...Hourly payFull timeWork at officeLocal areaImmediate startFlexible hours$140.25k - $189.75k
...one of the most progressive, innovative National CPA firms, is seeking a Senior Tax Manager and Tax Manager for their expanding Long Island, NY office. Duties Include: * Interact with clients and firm team members to provide innovative and proactive individual and business...Temporary workWork at officeFlexible hoursKforce
Woodbury, NY1 day ago$140k - $210k
...sized public accounting and advisory firm with over 50 years of experience serving a diverse client base. With offices in NYC and Long Island, we provide comprehensive tax, assurance, and consulting services to high-net-worth individuals, privately held businesses, and...Work at officeLocal areaRemote work- ...consideration of numerous factors including but not limited to the candidate’s qualifications, experience, skills, and geography.NYC/Long Island/Westchester Range: $180,000 - $225,000New Jersey Range: $155,000 - $200,000About the companyAt BDO, how we show up matters. We...Work at office
BDO International
Melville, NY1 day ago $115k - $140k
Our client is a Long Island architectural stone company working at the luxury end of the market. They fabricate and install cut-to-size natural stone — roughly 80% of it luxury retail, the balance high-end commercial and residential work. Projects run nationwide and the...Full timeFor contractorsFor subcontractor$115k - $197.1k
...benefits package designed to support the well-being, growth, and long-term success of our people. We are committed to recognizing... ...professionally.Salary Range: For individuals hired to work in Long Island, the expected salary range for this role is $115,000 to $197,100...Full timeWork experience placementH1bLocal areaWork visaAndersen Tax
Melville, NY1 day ago- ...About the Opportunity A highly respected, rapidly growing Long Island-based boutique CPA firm is seeking an experienced Tax professional with a strong background in pass-through taxation, including partnerships and fiduciary taxation, to join its leadership team. This...Local area
Abacus Group, LLC
Woodbury, NY8 days ago $75k - $90k
Our client is a Long Island architectural stone company working at the luxury end of the market. They fabricate and install cut-to-size natural stone — roughly 80% of it luxury retail, the balance high-end commercial and residential work. Projects run nationwide and the...Full timeFor contractorsFor subcontractor- ...Benefits: Health insurance, Life insurance, 401K We are looking for an ocean export coordinator to join our team based on Long Island. Knowledge of export compliance operations responsibilities is a requirement of this position to defend the practices of an export...Full timeWork experience placementOverseasMonday to Friday
$22.25 per hour
...JOE can become a place to build skills, friendships, and a career that can take you across cities, countries, and roles. WOODBURY, LONG ISLAND - NASSAU COUNTY, NY ABOUT JOE & THE JUICE Our vision is to become the first truly global people-centric food & beverage brand by...Hourly payCasual workLocal areaWorldwideShift work- ...candidate’s qualifications, experience, skills, and geography.National Range: $94,500 - $189,000Maryland Range: $94,500 - $189,000NYC/Long Island/Westchester Range: $94,500 - $189,000Washington DC Range: $94,500 - $189,000About the companyAt BDO, how we show up matters. We...Work at office
BDO International
Melville, NY3 days ago - ...Range: $120,000 - $127,000Minnesota Range: $90,000 - $120,000New Jersey Range: $115,000 - $140,000Ohio Range: $105,000 - $150,000NYC/Long Island/Westchester Range: $125,000 - $150,000Washington Range: $110,000 - $125,000Washington DC Range: $120,000 - $140,000About the...Private practiceWork at office
BDO International
Melville, NY1 day ago - ...findingsInteracts directly with clients and their advisors Communicates with supervisors, engagement team and clients the status of projectsAssists... ...: $152,000 - $188,000New Jersey Range: $155,000-$200,000NYC/Long Island/Westchester Range: $180,000-$225,000Washington Range: $150,00...Work at office
BDO International
Melville, NY3 days ago $145k - $248.2k
...benefits package designed to support the well-being, growth, and long-term success of our people. We are committed to recognizing... ...professionally.Salary Range: For individuals hired to work in Long Island, the expected salary range for this role is $145,000 to $248,200...Full timeWork experience placementInternshipPrivate practiceH1bLocal areaWork visaAndersen Tax
Melville, NY23 hours ago- ...Job Description ADP Payroll Specialist A fantastic Long Island healthcare provider is hiring a Payroll Specialist to run payroll for its clinical and office staff. The role is hybrid! What you’ll do Process payroll in ADP Workforce Now, chase missing information...Work at office
Elios Healthcare
Malverne, NY2 days ago $157.5k - $420k
...candidate’s qualifications, experience, skills, and geography.National Range: $157,500 - $420,000Maryland Range: $157,500 - $420,000NYC/Long Island/Westchester Range: $157,500 - $420,000About the companyAt BDO, how we show up matters. We build strong relationships by...BDO International
Melville, NY15 hours ago$55k - $95k
...Associate Account Executive We are searching for the best talent for an Associate Account Executive supporting Brooklyn, Queens & Long Island, NY. Fueled by innovation at the intersection of biology and technology, we're developing the next generation of smarter, less...Temporary workLocal areaImmediate startRelocationNight shiftWeekend work$110k - $145k
...creates accounting records such as bill payments, client invoices, payroll, and others; identifies and records adjustments; produces... ...Range: $110,000 - $145,000 Maryland Range: $110,000 - $145,000NYC/Long Island/Westchester Range: $110,000 - $145,000About the companyAt BDO,...Work at officeBDO International
Melville, NY1 day ago- ...: $215,000 - $300,000Minnesota Range: $170,000 - $250,000New Jersey Range: $190,000 - $350,000Ohio Range: $150,000 - $300,000NYC/Long Island/Westchester Range: $230,000 - $350,000Washington Range: $180,000 - $240,000Washington DC Range: $190,000 - $300,000About the companyAt...Private practiceWork at office
BDO International
Melville, NY2 days ago - ...0 - $180,000Massachusetts Range: $150,000 - $206,000Minnesota Range: $130,000 - $190,000New Jersey Range: $155,000 - $200,000NYC/Long Island/Westchester Range: $180,000 - $225,000Washington Range: $150,000 - $200,000Washington DC Range: $162,000 - $190,000About the companyAt...Work at office
BDO International
Melville, NY15 hours ago - ...Position: Payroll/Benefits Coordinator Company: NAPCO Security Technologies, Inc. Location: Amityville, NY The Company: NAPCO... ...Security Technologies, Inc., headquartered in Amityville, Long Island NY, is a world-wide leader in the manufacturing of electronic...Full timePart timeFlexible hours
Napco Security
Amityville, NY4 days ago $85k - $170k
Business Account Executive (Healthcare) - Long Island, NY Full-time Compensation: USD 85,000 - USD 170,000 - yearly At Quadient , we support businesses of all sizes in their digital transformation and growth journey, unlocking operational efficiency with reliable, secure...Full timeContract workWork at officeLocal areaRemote workFlexible hours
Do you want to receive more vacancies?
Subscribe and receive similar vacancies to Payroll Supervisor - Long Island. Be the first to apply!
