Head of Claims, Alternative Markets Division
American Financial Group
Be Here. Be Great. Working for a leader in the insurance industry means opportunity for you. Great American Insurance Group's member companies are subsidiaries of American Financial Group. We combine a "small company" culture where your ideas will be heard with "big company" expertise to help you succeed. With over 30 specialty and property and casualty operations, there are always opportunities here to learn and grow.At Great American, we value and recognize the benefits derived when people with different backgrounds and experiences work together to achieve business results. Our goal is to create a workplace where all employees feel included, empowered, and enabled to perform at their best.Alternative Markets specialized in mono-line and/or multi-line primary programs on either a traditional guaranteed cost (Specialty Programs) or risk-sharing basis (Agency, Association or Group Captives). Alternative Markets focuses on niche programs. Our Alternative Markets Division is looking for a Head of Claims to work out of our downtown Cincinnati, OH office. This person will report to the President of the Alternative Markets Division. The role has primary responsibility for managing the division’s claims group. This position will be a Divisional VP or Divisional SVP role, commensurate with experience.Responsibilities:As the leader of the Alternative Market claims department, this person will be responsible for these core functions, along with other duties as assigned:Overall management of the claims department of 54 claims professionals and support staff, located in our Cincinnati headquarters and in remote locations across the country.Responsible for performance, development and coaching of all claims staff.Provides vision, goals, and direction and shares accountability for claims support staff located both inside and outside the division.Provides input and actively participates in divisional meetings and training sessions.Partners with underwriting teams to provide insights regarding claims trends and developments.Offers support and counsel in connection with new business opportunities.Provides tactical leadership and strategic direction to the department.Monitors and analyzes data to ensure consistency in quality of reserving, strategies, and outcomes.Ensures that claims handling is conducted in compliance with applicable statutes, regulations and other legal requirements, and that all applicable company procedures and policies are followed.Responsible for nurturing and enhancing a unique claims culture and maintaining high levels of employee engagement as well as a high level of customer service.Provides advice on the resolution of claims files with ultimate authority over settlements / reserves within prescribed limits including oversight and strategy for large claims and overall litigation management. Submits recommendations to Corporate Claims on cases exceeding personal authority.Provides vision, goals, and direction for claims process and outcome improvement initiatives through utilization of technology, vendor services, and innovative strategies.Works closely with senior leadership team to help make sure the division meets budget and performance targets.Performs other duties as assigned.Qualifications:Bachelor’s degree is required.10+ years of leadership experience with significant experience in management of casualty and property claims, including experience with strategic planning and employee development.Previous experience working with multi-line claims, with particular focus in Liability, Property and Workers Comp. Significant casualty expertise is required.Must be results oriented and customer service focused.Strong analytical and communication skills with the proven ability of partnering with individuals at all levels.Ability to clearly articulate vision and objectives.Insurance industry awareness and involvement.Must be able to travel up to 35% of the time.Business Unit:Alternative MarketsBenefits: We offer competitive benefits packages for full-time and part-time employees*. Full-time employees have access to medical, dental, and vision coverage, wellness plans, parental leave, adoption assistance, and tuition reimbursement. Full-time and eligible part-time employees also enjoy Paid Time Off and paid holidays, a 401(k) plan with company match, an employee stock purchase plan, and commuter benefits.Compensation varies by role, level, and location and is influenced by skills, experience, and business needs. Your recruiter will provide details about benefits and specific compensation ranges during the hiring process. Learn more at .*Excludes seasonal employees and interns.SummaryLocation: Cincinnati, OH (USA)Type: Full time
$190k - $275k
...focus on specialized solutions for a diverse market.Our team members at Great American Risk... ..., collaboration - among underwriting, claims, and shared services teams - and continuous... ...an accomplished underwriting leader to head our E&S Binding team. As the leader of the...ClaimsFull timePart timeSeasonal workWork at officeLocal areaRemote work- ...sponsorship.Great American entered the Surety market 100 years ago, bringing a history of... ...personal service they receive from the Bond Division. With a highly diverse product line that... ...Public Official bonds.The Surety Bond Claims team is currently in search of an...ClaimsFull timeContract workPart timeSeasonal workWork at office
- ...the need for current or future sponsorship.The P&C Corporate Claims Division consists of over 100 professionals who support Great American... ...alignment with business goals and customer needs. May conduct market research and competitive analysis to identify opportunities...ClaimsFull timePart timeWork experience placementSeasonal workWork at officeRemote work
- ...Cincinnati, United States | Posted on 03/13/2026 Elevate Claims Solutions is founded on the belief that human experience and claim quality... ...work in a culture of continuous improvement. A diverse market of carriers. Clear communication of service and quality expectations...ClaimsFlexible hours
- ...dwellings - and the recreational market, including boats, personal... ...s Global Specialty Insurance division. Our employees receive... ...analysis, and research projects or claims analytical studies. Participate... ...and communicate results and alternatives to actuarial staff and...ClaimsTemporary workLocal areaWork from homeRelocationFlexible hours
- ...Head of AI About the Company Rapidly growing investor-backed software company automating unstructured financial and regulatory... ...business. The successful candidate will take ownership of a market-leading document intelligence platform, lead a talented AI and machine...
- ...pricing models and help guide the creation of new model solutions for a variety of Great American divisions. The role partners closely with business units, underwriting, claims, actuarial, data science, IT, and other shared services to understand business needs, translate...ClaimsFull timePart timeSeasonal work
- ...things change, one thing never will: Great American's AgriBusiness Division's commitment to keeping farmers and ranchers strong with... ...care custody or control to umbrella and auto.We are looking for a Claims Supervisor to join our AgriBusiness division in our Cincinnati,...ClaimsFull timePart timeWork at office
- ...with a dedicated Property & Inland Marine Division and, in the industry segments it covers,... ...second to none. From the underwriters to claims representatives, the focus is strictly on... ...profitable business.Interprets, explains, and markets products and services.Develops...ClaimsFull timePart timeFor contractors
- ...focus on specialized solutions for a diverse market.Our team members at Great American Risk... ..., collaboration - among underwriting, claims, and shared services teams - and continuous... ...success.Great American Risk Solutions Division is currently looking for a Production Underwriter...ClaimsFull timePart timeSeasonal workWork at officeRemote work
- ...United States without the need for current or future sponsorship.Alternative Markets specialized in mono-line and/or multi-line primary programs... ...niche programs. Alternative Markets is looking for a Senior Claims Specialist/Claims Technical Director to join their team....ClaimsFull timePart timeSeasonal workWork at officeRemote work
$46.76 per hour
...manages complex and large exposure medical malpractice claims, including hospital and employed physician claims... ...policies and the Captive. While working with market and group senior leaders explain the risks and alternatives regarding various claim options. Works closely...ClaimsTemporary work- ...-facing role or as part of our brokerage division, our benefits and HR consulting division,... ...with minimum 1+ years client service and/or claims management experience OR- High School... ...limited to previous experience, education, pay market/geography, complexity or scope,...ClaimsFull timeLive outWork at officeLocal areaFlexible hoursShift work
$90k - $150k
...Great American’s Specialty Human Services Division has provided insurance solutions to the... ...existing products.Conducts comprehensive market research to identify trends, opportunities... ...Collaborates with underwriting, actuarial, and claims teams to design innovative insurance...ClaimsFull timePart timeSeasonal workWork at officeLocal areaRemote work- ...Assists clients with the reporting of claims, maintain contact during the settlement... ...new/existing accounts, risk management, marketing support, order entry etc. Ensures that... ...competitive insurance program providing various alternatives for client consideration. Invoice all...ClaimsFull timeWork at office
$80k - $120k
...on a specialized solution for a diverse market.Our team members at Great American Risk Solutions... ..., collaboration - among underwriting, claims, and shared services teams - and... ...through select MGAs for the Binding Authority Division. This individual will underwrite non-admitted...ClaimsFull timeContract workPart timeSeasonal workWork at officeRemote work$100.4k - $197.9k
...changes, network changes, or other detailed claims analytics Use strategic thinking to... ...of health insurers, including pricing, market entry, network design, and cost of care... ...of experience with health plan design, alternative delivery systems, or health care reform...ClaimsWork at officeLocal areaVisa sponsorship$200k - $225k
...ResponsibilitiesProvide strategic leadership and oversight of Global Trade Support Operations across Equity, Fixed Income, and Options markets, ensuring operational excellence and regulatory compliance.Direct and manage all daily, weekly, monthly, and special Options...Full timeLocal area- ...streamlined business office workflows, reduced claim denial rates, and accelerated and... ...fortification of two successful decades in market as a leading player in the specialty healthcare... ..., and manage the People roadmap and the division of ownership will be clear. Once the plan...ClaimsFull timeFor contractorsInternshipWork at office
$71.14k - $134.78k
...promoting a dynamic and adaptable workplace. Alternate locations may be considered if candidates... ...and forecasting. Calculates monthly claims liability reserves, develops merit rating... ...depending on the above factors as well as market/business considerations. No amount is considered...ClaimsTemporary workWork experience placementWork at officeLocal area2 days per week1 day per week- ...A leading claims management company is seeking a Cash Claims Processor in Cincinnati, Ohio. The role requires a high school degree and at least 1+ years of experience in cash claims processing. Candidates should demonstrate a strong work ethic, proficiency in Microsoft...Claims
- ...works closely under the guidance of the marketing department leadership personnel. The BDR... ...Act (18 U.S.C. § 220) • False Claims Act (31 U.S.C. §§ 3729–3733) •... ...of modalities and settings through our divisions: BAART Community HealthCare, Health Care...ClaimsFull timeLocal areaNight shift
$169.79k - $286.65k
...support HDR’s strategic direction and emerging markets. Primary Responsibilities The primary... ...business class strategies Engage alternate delivery projects to provide deep foundation... ...foundation construction and construction claim mitigation Master of Science or higher in...ClaimsFull timeTemporary workPart time- ...Disability Case Associate Location: Cincinnati, OH (Hybrid/Remote) Duration: 6 months Manage end-to-end short term disability claims process Act as mayor Evaluate medical and claim documentation for eligibility decisions Ensure timely adjudication and...ClaimsTemporary workRemote work
- A leading insurance training provider in Fort Campbell North, KY is seeking Independent Insurance Claims Adjusters to join their team. This role allows individuals to help others recover from disasters while providing comprehensive training for new adjusters. Whether you...ClaimsFlexible hours
- A leading claims adjusting firm in Kentucky is seeking a Licensed Insurance Claims Adjuster to join their team. This role involves helping clients recover from disasters while enjoying flexibility and competitive pay. Candidates should have handled at least 100 claims...ClaimsFlexible hours
- ...visa sponsorship. Applicants must be authorized to work in the United States without the need for current or future sponsorship.The Claims Director provides leadership and strategic oversight for Mid‑Continent Group’s most complex and highest exposure casualty claims....ClaimsFull timePart time
- ...employer to ask for an accommodation or an alternative application process. Sr. HR Generalist... ...deductions, and resolve eligibility, claims, and billing discrepancies on behalf of... ...administration, including pay practice consistency, market benchmarking research, and coordination...ClaimsTemporary workApprenticeshipWork at officeLocal areaAll shiftsMonday to FridayShift work
- ...but will equip you with valuable skills for the healthcare job market. Looking to start a rewarding career path in the healthcare industry... ...billing and coding specialist processes and codes healthcare claims to ensure accurate billing and insurance reimbursement,...Claims
- ...this possible by supporting our providers at every step. From marketing and insurance to billing and technology, we take care of the administrative... ...Admin Done for You ~ We handle credentialing, billing, claims, EHR, and tech support-so you can focus your time and energy on...ClaimsPart timeLive inWork at officeRemote work
Do you want to receive more vacancies?
Subscribe and receive similar vacancies to Head of Claims, Alternative Markets Division. Be the first to apply!
- medical claims auditor Cincinnati, OH
- healthcare claims Cincinnati, OH
- veterans claims Cincinnati, OH
- claims processing Cincinnati, OH
- unemployment claims Cincinnati, OH
- claims intake Cincinnati, OH
- claims associate Cincinnati, OH
- property claims Cincinnati, OH
- claims attorney Cincinnati, OH
- head of growth marketing



