Pre-Litigation Team Lead
Confidential
Senior Leadership Role | Plaintiff‑Side Only
New York, NY (Hybrid)
Full‑Time | Executive‑Level Authority
We are hiring a Team Lead of Pre‑Litigation to own, architect, and command the pre‑suit phase of our plaintiff‑side employment practice.
This role is for a proven plaintiff‑side operator —someone who understands that real value is created before a complaint is filed and who has already demonstrated the ability to build leverage, drive outcomes, and lead strategy at scale .
This is not a lateral step for defense counsel.
This is not a training role.
This is not intake.
Read This Before Applying
- If your background is primarily defense‑side , this role will not be a fit.
- If you rely on discovery rules—rather than pressure, timing, and exposure —this is not your seat.
- If you have not personally driven pre‑suit resolutions at meaningful dollar levels , do not apply.
We are seeking an attorney who already thinks, negotiates, and leads like a plaintiff‑side strategist .
The Role You Will Own
You will design and lead the firm’s pre‑litigation function, including:
- End‑to‑end authority over cases from intake through pre‑suit resolution
- Strategic control of:
- Liability framing
- Evidence development
- Damages modeling
- Narrative and leverage
- Direction of high‑impact demand packages intended to force movement
- Leadership of pre‑suit negotiations and mediations
- Decision‑making authority on when settlement maximizes value vs. when filing increases it
- Delivery of litigation‑ready, pressure‑tested files when escalation is warranted
- Mentorship and strategic direction for pre‑litigation attorneys and staff
Practice Focus
You will lead senior‑level matters involving:
- NYCHRL and NYSHRL
- Title VII, ADA, ADEA, FMLA
- Section 1981
- Equal Pay Act
- New York Labor Law
Who This Is For
This role is designed for an attorney who:
- Has built plaintiff‑side leverage for years—not months
- Understands agency practice as a weapon , not a box‑checking exercise
- Negotiates from document‑backed exposure , not bluster
- Is trusted to make high‑stakes value decisions without oversight
- Can lead lawyers, set standards, and drive results
Requirements (Non‑Negotiable)
- JD and active New York Bar
- 10+ years of plaintiff‑side employment law experience
- Deep, demonstrable ownership of:
- Pre‑suit case strategy
- EEOC / NYSDHR practice from charge to resolution
- High‑value demand drafting and negotiation
- Clear, documented record of meaningful pre‑suit recoveries
- Ability to operate with maximum autonomy and accountability
Defense‑side experience alone will not be considered.
Compensation & Platform
This is a top‑tier leadership role within a plaintiff‑side practice that values outcomes over optics .
- Senior‑level authority
- Performance‑aligned compensation at the top of the market
- Platform built for attorneys who create value—not volume
- Direct impact on firm results and growth
- Eligible for bonus of 10% of net attorney fees on settlement of the first $1M; 15% of net attorney fees on settlement above $1M
Details discussed confidentially with qualified candidates only .
Apply only if your background squarely aligns with senior‑level plaintiff‑side pre‑litigation leadership.
- ...Leadership Role | Plaintiff‑Side Only New York, NY (Hybrid) Full‑Time | Executive‑Level Authority We are hiring a Team Lead of Pre‑Litigation to own, architect, and command the pre‑suit phase of our plaintiff‑side employment practice. This role is for a proven...LitigationFull time
- Rubenstein Law in New York is seeking a Pre-Litigation Attorney to manage all aspects of personal injury cases before filing complaints. Key responsibilities include supervising staff, evaluating case merits, and negotiating settlements. The ideal candidate must be licensed...Litigation
- Rubenstein Law is seeking a Case Manager in New York to handle pre-litigation cases while maintaining communication with clients, providers, and internal teams. You will oversee case progress, manage correspondence, and supervise pre-litigation assistants. The ideal candidate...Litigation
- ...experience required. Position Overview We are looking for a Demands Team Lead to manage our growing Demand Department. You will supervise... .... Prior experience writing or supervising demand letters in pre-litigation PI. Strong knowledge of California PI case flow (or similar...LitigationFull timeRemote workMonday to Friday
- ...Wyman Legal Solutions is looking for an experienced Florida construction litigation attorney to manage fast-paced pre-suit matters for homeowners facing challenging renovations. This role values strategy, negotiation, and problem-solving skills over billable hours. If...Litigation
$100k - $200k
...A prominent law firm is seeking a Pre-Litigation Associate Attorney with 2-8 years of experience to join their consumer finance practice. This entry-level role offers remote work flexibility while focusing on negotiating settlements and managing your own docket of matters...LitigationRemote work$55k - $75k
TopDog Law LLC in Georgia is seeking a case manager for Personal Injury pre-litigation support. The role requires 2-6 years of experience in personal injury cases, strong organizational and communication skills, and the ability to handle a high-volume caseload. You’ll...LitigationRemote job- ...Inkelaar Law, a compassionate firm dedicated to giving voice to the unheard, seeks a Remote Pre-Litigation Case Manager. You will manage pre-litigation auto accident cases and must have at least 5 years of experience in personal injury law. Fluency in both Spanish and...LitigationRemote work
- Rubenstein Law is seeking a Case Manager to handle cases primarily in the Pre-Litigation phase. Key responsibilities include daily client interactions, ensuring timely updates of case information, monitoring deadlines, and supervising pre-litigation assistants. The ideal...LitigationWork at office
$50k - $80k
...A growing tech firm is seeking a Pre-Litigation Associate to manage case progress in personal injury claims. This remote role involves opening... ...tracking medical records, and liaising with clients and legal teams. Candidates should have over 5 years of experience in legal...LitigationRemote workFlexible hours$60k - $85k
A legal technology company in New York is seeking a Case Manager to ensure efficient progression of pre-litigation cases. The role focuses on opening claims, managing medical records, and resolving lien issues to support attorneys. Ideal candidates will have over 5 years...LitigationFlexible hours- ...Day to day handling of medical records Oversee formation of demand packages and provide evaluation of medical records Manage a team of multiple case managers Manage a caseload of personal injury cases Strong communication with clients regarding case updates,...Litigation
$70.5k - $87.5k
...Steno Agency, Inc. is seeking an experienced leader to manage its Litigation Support Team. This role involves accountability for team results, coaching specialists, and optimizing processes. Candidates should have over 5 years of experience in high-volume service of process...LitigationRemote work- ...including 20 Partners, 12 board-certified litigators, and over 400 supporting professionals.... ...Summary The Case manager handles cases in the Pre-Litigation phase while maintaining an... ...with clients, providers, and inter office teams. In charge of reviewing, analyzing, and...LitigationWork at office
- ...Remote Pre-Litigation Case Manager (Auto Accident Focus) – Tampa. Are you a skilled Pre-Litigation Case Manager with 5+ years of experience... ...the experience, dedication, and integrity, we want you on our team. What You’ll Do: Manage a full caseload of pre-litigation auto...LitigationHourly payFull timeTemporary workRemote workMonday to Friday
- ...medical malpractice, and mass tort litigation. Rubenstein Law is committed... ...manager handles cases in the Pre-Litigation phase while... ..., providers, and inter office teams. In charge of reviewing, analyzing... ...years in a supervisory or team lead role. ~ Excellent customer service...LitigationWork at office
- ...including 20 Partners, 12 board-certified litigators, and over 400 supporting professionals.... ...reputation and success. Job Summary Our Pre-Litigation Attorneys are responsible for... ...Responsibilities Supervise and provide direction to a team of staff members Evaluate the merits of...Litigation
$55k - $75k
...negotiations Serve as a primary point of contact for clients during the pre-litigation phase, providing updates, requesting documentation, explaining... ...decisive recommendations, and communicating clearly across teams Supports scale by following and improving litigation...LitigationRemote work$120k - $165k
A leading law firm in New York is seeking a Senior Paralegal to provide advanced legal support in complex litigation and investigations. The role involves overseeing junior paralegals, managing case workflows, and ensuring compliance with court rules. Candidates must have...LitigationWork at office- A dynamic law firm in New York is seeking a strong litigator with 2-3 years of litigation and drafting experience, who is barred in NY.... ...supporting clients in their legal journeys. Join a mission-driven team making a direct impact on financial freedom for Americans. #J-1...Litigation
$75k
Clickback Inc. is seeking a Litigation Paralegal Coordinator in New York, NY. This role involves managing the paralegal team, overseeing recruiting, training, and performance assessments. The Coordinator will liaise between paralegals and attorneys, ensuring effective...Litigation- ...Our client, a well-regarded regional defense litigation firm is seeking a Team Lead to join their Cherry Hill, NJ team. The ideal candidate will have 10+ years of general liability or insurance defense related experience as well as experience leading/training other attorneys...LitigationWork at officeRemote work3 days per week
$220k - $250k
...The successful candidate will lead our engagement with clients, with... ...a focus on legal counsel and litigation funders. # Managing and... ...professional development of existing team members and identifying skills... ...is not used as a tool to pre-screen candidates. For more information...LitigationWork at officeRemote workFlexible hours- ...REQUIREMENTS: 1+ years PRIOR PRE-LITIGATION PERSONAL INJURY LEGAL EXPERIENCE REQUIRED (PLEASE DO NOT APPLY IF 1+ YEARS REQUIREMENT IS NOT... ...one year experience in pre-litigation personal injury. Join our team of professionals and work in a dynamic environment with a great...Litigation
$125k - $130k
...Doctor degree, admission to the NYS Bar, and at least 5 years of legal experience. This position requires excellent communication and litigation skills, as well as a strong commitment to public interest work. The salary ranges from $125,000 to $130,000 annually. #J-18808-...Litigation$325k
....00/yr Our client, an Am Law 100 firm, is seeking a Lead eDiscovery Attorney to join their team. While preference is for candidates based in the New... ...preservation, processing, review, and production. Guide pre-litigation information governance , deposition/witness...LitigationFull time- ...Solutions is seeking a strategic and entrepreneurial Senior Manager & Team Lead, Intelligence & Investigations, to build and lead a premier... ...with deep expertise in OSINT and HUMINT methodologies, litigation support, reputational due diligence, and complex investigative...LitigationFull timeContract workTemporary workFor subcontractorCasual workWork at officeFlexible hours
- We are a rapidly growing Charleston-based Personal Injury Law Firm expanding to Columbia. We have a fast-paced team environment working with injured clients and their legal concerns. Why you should apply (at a glance) Voted one of the Best Law Firms to Work For 2023...Litigation
$91.19k - $155.27k
...also supports the COO and Risk Management team efforts to promote the SCA goals of... ...implements alternate means of resolution. TPA / Litigation Management Supports the development and... ...depositions, mediations, arbitrations, pre‑trials, trials and all other legal proceedings...LitigationFor contractorsWork experience placementFor subcontractorWork at officeLocal area$140k
...As a Pre-Sales Solutions Architect on Everlaw's commercial team, you will partner closely with Account Executives and Customer... ...in the room, running discovery, leading demos and technical deep-dives,... ..., and translating real-world litigation and investigations workflows into...LitigationFull timeWork at officeLocal areaRemote workWork from homeFlexible hours
Do you want to receive more vacancies?
Subscribe and receive similar vacancies to Pre-Litigation Team Lead. Be the first to apply!
- underwriting team lead New York, NY
- group finance manager New York, NY
- office team lead New York, NY
- clinical team lead New York, NY
- team leader New York, NY
- training team lead New York, NY
- team manager warehouse New York, NY
- team lead data science New York, NY
- disability team leader New York, NY
- group operations director New York, NY



