Sign up to access all features of our service.
  • Job search
  • Favorites
  • Create a CV
    New
  • Salaries
  • Subscriptions

Commercial Casualty Underwriting Leader (Director)

$250k - $350k

Shepherd

Commercial Casualty Underwriting Leader (Director)

Shepherd is launching a Retail Commercial Casualty vertical, as an expansion to its current Primary and Excess Casualty offerings. The Commercial Casualty Underwriting Leader will play a lead role in building and shaping new industry segments from the ground up. This is an opportunity to help define the underwriting strategy, go-to-market, and drive long-term profitable growth for a core pillar of Shepherd's business. We're looking for someone with 10+ years of commercial property underwriting experience, a proven track record of leadership, deep relationships in the retail channel, and an entrepreneurial mindset who is excited to build something new with modern technology and a forward-thinking team.

About You

You are a builder who wants to shape the future of commercial insurance and do the best work of your career. You have deep casualty expertise, a loyal broker network, and the drive to turn a blank page into a profitable book.

You'd be a great fit if you have:

  • 10+ years of commercial casualty underwriting, with deep expertise in retail middle market and large accounts across classes such as real estate, retail, hospitality, manufacturing, and technology.
  • A proven record of profitable growth: originating new business, quoting, binding, and building a casualty book while managing to loss-ratio and combined-ratio targets.
  • Strong technical command of risk selection, exposure and loss analysis, loss development and trends, pricing, and coverage across Commercial General Liability, Commercial Auto, Workers' Compensation and Excess Casualty.
  • Experience structuring both primary and excess casualty programs, including guaranteed-cost and loss-sensitive programs such as large deductibles and self-insured retentions.
  • Sound judgment on contractual risk transfer, additional insured requirements, manuscript endorsements, and emerging exposures.
  • Disciplined portfolio management, including limits, accumulation, and clash exposure.
  • Established retail broker relationships at the regional and national level that can drive submission flow from day one.
  • People leadership experience leading, mentoring, or managing underwriters, including setting authority and running underwriting audits.
  • Executive presence to present strategy and results to leadership, capacity partners, and reinsurers.
  • Comfort with ambiguity: you make sound decisions with incomplete information and adapt quickly as the business evolves.
  • Willingness to travel about 25% to meet brokers, partners, and the team.
  • A bachelor's degree or equivalent experience.

About the Role

Shepherd's underwriting approach is client-centric with a heavy emphasis on an efficient process. Our goal is to leverage our technology and data to make quick, informed underwriting decisions tailored to our clients' specific needs.

In this role, you will:

  • Define the strategy for retail commercial casualty, including target classes, lines of business, limits, attachment points, geographies, appetite, and growth and loss-ratio targets.
  • Support the development of underwriting guidelines, authority framework, referral rules, and rating approach.
  • Partner with Product, Engineering, and Data to design the submission-to-bind workflow, pricing tools, and exposure and loss-trend views.
  • Underwrite new and renewal primary and excess casualty within your authority.
  • Own premium, profit, loss-ratio, retention, and expense results for the vertical.
  • Use your retail broker relationships to drive submission flow in the first year, and serve as Shepherd's senior casualty voice with brokers, clients, and other stakeholders.
  • Hire, coach, and grow a team of casualty underwriters and support staff as the book scales.
  • Work with Corporate Underwriting to help set letters of authority, run underwriting audits, and coach from the results.
  • Work with Claims, Actuarial, Customer Experience and Finance so the business is underwritten, serviced, and reported well.

This is a position based in our New York City, San Francisco, Chicago, Los Angeles, or DallasFort Worth offices.

Compensation

The base salary range for this role is $250,000 $350,000, plus an annual performance bonus and equity in Shepherd. Offers within the range depend on location, experience, and the relationships and market following you bring.

How We Work

Shepherd runs on four values. Here's what each one means in this seat.

  • Think big, build big. We exist to protect progress and the industries that rely on it. You're building a casualty vertical meant to scale nationally, so the guidelines, team, and tools get designed for where the book is going, not just where it starts.
  • Win together. We rise as one. We support each other, raise the bar, and celebrate collective success. As the first leader of this vertical, you set the standard every casualty underwriter after you inherits.
  • Cross the aisle. Collaboration wins. We listen deeply, work across boundaries, and prioritize shared success over individual lanes. The best underwriting tools here come from underwriters who sit with engineers and data scientists, and much of this job is making that partnership work.
  • Go get it. We act with urgency, move with confidence, take smart risks, and push forward with intention. Nobody hands you the appetite, the broker list, or the first submission. You build the plan, make the calls, and bind the first deal.

Benefits

Premium Healthcare 100% contribution to top-tier health, dental, and vision

Fertility Benefits & Family Building Support

Unlimited PTO Flexibility to take the time off, recharge, and perform

Daily Lunches, Dinners & Snacks We work together, and enjoy meals together too

SF, NYC, DallasFort Worth, Chicago & LA Offices

Professional Development Access to premium coaching, including leadership development

Competitive 401(k) Plan

Dog-Friendly Office Plenty of dogs to play with and make friends with in the SF office

Shepherd
Vacancy posted 1 day ago
Similar jobs that could be interesting for youBased on the Commercial Casualty Underwriting Leader (Director) in Chicago, IL vacancy
  • $110.3k - $238.7k

     ...Executive Underwriter Or AVP Underwriting Director - E&S Excess Casualty Zurich is currently looking to hire an experienced...  ...to make Zurich a market leader in E&S as measured by gross written...  ...Degree or equivalent years of E&S Commercial Insurance industry experience... 
    Commercial
    Apprenticeship
    Currently hiring
    Local area
    Flexible hours

    Zurich Insurance Company

    Chicago, IL
    1 day ago
  • $100k - $215k

     ...Executive Underwriter OR AVP Underwriting Director - E&S Primary Casualty Zurich E&S is currently looking to hire an experienced...  ...to make Zurich a market leader in E&S as measured by gross written...  ...or equivalent years of E&S Commercial Insurance industry experience... 
    Commercial
    Apprenticeship
    Currently hiring
    Local area
    Flexible hours

    Zurich Insurance Company

    Chicago, IL
    14 hours ago
  • $110.2k - $238.7k

    Zurich is seeking an Executive Underwriter or AVP Underwriting Director, Umbrella Excess Casualty for our National Accounts...  ...or more years of experience in commercial underwriting or brokerage or market...  .... Zurich North America is a leader in risk management, with over... 
    Commercial
    Temporary work
    Apprenticeship
    Work at office
    Local area
    Flexible hours
    3 days per week

    Zurich Insurance Group

    Chicago, IL
    2 days ago
  • $131.2k - $223k

     ...Executive Underwriter, Team Leader Chubb Global Casualty (CGC) Domestic is looking for an applicant to fill the position of Executive Underwriter, Team...  ...insurance. With operations in 54 countries, Chubb provides commercial and personal property and casualty insurance,... 
    Commercial
    Work at office
    Local area

    Chubb

    Chicago, IL
    3 days ago
  • $130k - $170k

     ...and their customers, bringing specific expertise in excess casualty as well as a variety of targeted primary and excess programs...  ...Custom Insurance Managers Responsibilities The Director, Underwriting - Excess Casualty is responsible for analyses of potential... 
    Suggested
    Work at office
    Remote work
    Flexible hours
    Night shift

    BXM Insurance Services

    Chicago, IL
    1 day ago
  •  ...Vice President, Excess Casualty / Transportation Underwriter About the Company Employee-owned wholesale broker and MGA with an exclusive excess...  ..., broker collaboration, and the ability to balance commercial opportunities with disciplined risk selection. Functions... 
    Commercial

    Confidential

    Chicago, IL
    1 day ago
  • $115k - $235k

    Zurich E&S is currently looking to hire an experienced Primary Casualty Underwriting Manager to support our Primary E&S Casualty production...  ...product and technology strategy designed to make Zurich a market leader in E&S as measured by gross written premium, profitability,... 
    Currently hiring
    Work at office
    Local area

    Zurich Insurance Group

    Chicago, IL
    3 days ago
  • Excess Casualty Underwriter (Multiple Levels) Excess Casualty Underwriter (Hiring at Multiple Levels, up to VP | Remote - IL, CA) My client...  ...accounts, including complex risks such as habitational, commercial contractors, hospitality, and miscellaneous casualty. Handle... 
    Commercial
    Full time
    For contractors
    Remote work

    Selby Jennings

    Chicago, IL
    1 day ago
  •  ...Associate Vice President, Underwriting Manager, Construction General Liability About the Company Well-established provider of commercial lines insurance products Industry Insurance Type Public Company Founded 1822 Employees 1001-5000 Categories... 
    Commercial

    Confidential

    Chicago, IL
    3 days ago
  • $100k - $200k

     ...Job Description Job Description This job is posted on behalf of Lost Dutchman Search by Top Echelon. Senior Commercial Excess Casualty Underwriter - Chicago A rated, specialty E&S carrier has immediate opportunities for experienced commercial Excess Casualty... 
    Commercial
    Work at office
    Immediate start

    Lost Dutchman Search

    Chicago, IL
    7 days ago
  •  ...Senior Executive Underwriter, Excess Casualty page is loaded## Senior Executive Underwriter, Excess Casualtylocations...  ...'s strong foundation as the market leader in this area has evolved through its...  ...guidance.What you'll need to succeed:Commercial Insurance Company, Agency or... 
    Commercial
    Work at office
    Flexible hours

    AIG

    Chicago, IL
    14 hours ago
  • $114.6k - $194.8k

     ...Executive Underwriter Contribute to the achievement of the Chubb Global Casualty business plan. The Executive Underwriter is responsible...  ...filled. Chubb is a world leader in insurance. With operations...  ...54 countries, Chubb provides commercial and personal property and... 
    Commercial
    Local area

    Chubb

    Chicago, IL
    14 hours ago
  • $114.7k - $170k

     ...Executive Underwriter Our Specialty Casualty underwriting department is seeking an Executive Underwriter to join our growing team. The Specialty...  ...related Insurance Designation(s) preferred ~ Knowledge of commercial Excess and Surplus lines risk, classification, pricing... 
    Commercial
    Contract work
    Flexible hours

    AmTrust Financial Services

    Chicago, IL
    2 days ago
  •  ...Join Starr a global leader in commercial insurance with over a century of expertise. We empower our employees to innovate make impactful decisions...  ...progress. Position Overview The Chicago Regional Underwriting Manager will lead Starrs Middle Market underwriting... 
    Commercial
    Full time
    Worldwide

    Starr Insurance

    Chicago, IL
    2 days ago
  • $55k - $75k

     ...Underwriting Assistant Excess Casualty At IFG, you're building more than a career. You're helping build a better future. Since 1985, we've succeeded...  ...Preferred: Minimum of 2-5 years' experience in a U.S. commercial casualty insurance company or equivalent experience.... 
    Commercial
    Temporary work
    Work experience placement
    Work at office
    Flexible hours
    3 days per week

    IFG Companies

    Chicago, IL
    2 days ago
  • $125k - $165k

     ...Description Job Description POSITION SUMMARY The Senior Underwriter, Primary Casualty ("SUPC") is responsible for developing, managing and...  .... KNOWLEDGE, SKILLS AND ABILITIES Knowledge of commercial primary casualty lines business, classifications, pricing... 
    Commercial
    Temporary work
    Work at office
    Flexible hours
    3 days per week

    IFG Companies

    Chicago, IL
    18 days ago
  • Join Starr, a global leader in commercial insurance with over a century of expertise. We empower...  ...an accomplished and dynamic Regional Underwriting Manager to lead our Midwest...  ...mentoring a team underwriting a primary casualty portfolio with a strategic focus on risks... 
    Commercial
    Full time
    Work at office
    Worldwide

    Starr Companies

    Chicago, IL
    14 hours ago
  • $125k - $225k

     ...experience in cyber insurance broking, underwriting, or related financial lines disciplines...  ...fast-paced environment. ~ Property & Casualty Insurance License or ability to obtain...  ...the cyber, financial lines, or broader commercial insurance marketplace. What Success... 
    Commercial
    Temporary work
    Local area
    Visa sponsorship
    Work visa
    Flexible hours

    Willis Towers Watson Plc

    Chicago, IL
    2 days ago
  •  ...Division Broking Leader The Division Broking Leader is a strategic and influential...  ...expertise in insurance coverages, carrier underwriting guidelines, alternative funding strategies...  ...account segments All property and casualty products Excess and Surplus Lines marketplace... 
    Commercial
    Work experience placement
    Work at office

    World Insurance

    Chicago, IL
    3 days ago
  • $106.7k - $165.2k

     ...65,200Category: Claims & UnderwritingCompany: Munich ReE&S Casualty Underwriter, AVPWe are adding to our diverse team of experts and are looking...  ...(e.g. CPCU) preferredAdvanced working knowledge of Commercial P&C / E&S products and insurance concepts, UW processes and... 
    Commercial
    Temporary work

    Munich Re

    Chicago, IL
    14 hours ago
  • $166.37k - $207.96k

     ...Director Of Underwriting Independence American Insurance Company (IAIC), the insurance carrier for...  ...organization and effectively influence executive leaders, carrier partners, regulators, and...  ...~10+ years of progressive Property & Casualty insurance experience, ideally... 
    Temporary work
    Work at office
    Flexible hours

    Figo Pet Insurance

    Chicago, IL
    3 days ago
  • $100k - $125k

    Position SummaryThe Property & Casualty Underwriter is responsible for underwriting and managing a portfolio of new and renewal business within...  ...& Casualty underwriting experience.Experience underwriting commercial P&C business and evaluating complex or specialized risks.... 
    Commercial
    Full time
    Work experience placement
    Remote work

    Ryan Specialty Group

    Chicago, IL
    1 day ago
  • $145k - $175k

     ...manage risk. Join us as a Senior Executive Underwriter to play your part in that...  ...including Financial Lines, Property, Casualty, Specialty Lines, Cyber, Multinational...  ...International Group, Inc. (AIG) is a global leader in commercial and personal insurance solutions; we are... 
    Commercial
    Full time
    Work at office

    American International Group (AIG)

    Chicago, IL
    3 days ago
  •  ...Insurance (BHSI), provides a broad range of commercial property, casualty and specialty insurance coverages...  ...’s retail broker strategy. The leader will serve as both the architect of...  ...cross-functional partner to marketing, underwriting, and claims leadership to ensure a... 
    Commercial
    Temporary work
    Flexible hours
    Shift work

    Berkshire Hathaway Specialty Insurance

    Chicago, IL
    25 days ago
  • $163.2k - $244.8k

     ...shape the future. The Director, Architecture serves as...  ...a senior architecture leader responsible for...  ...discipline.Property & Casualty insurance experience,...  ...preferably within Specialty, Commercial, E&S, or Reinsurance businesses...  ...Experience supporting underwriting, policy administration... 
    Commercial
    Full time
    Temporary work
    Work at office
    Remote work
    3 days per week

    The Hartford Financial Services Group

    Chicago, IL
    14 hours ago
  • $90k - $120k

    Title:Manager, Underwriting Services-Wholesale CasualtyCompany:Everest...  ...:Everest is a global leader in risk management, rooted in...  ...Underwriting Services - Wholesale Casualty to lead a team of...  ...experience.Prior experience with commercial automobile insurance is preferred... 
    Commercial
    Full time
    Work at office

    Everest Re Group

    Chicago, IL
    4 days ago
  • $151k - $219k

     ...America National Opportunity Geography Leader Chubb Personal Risk Services (...  ...Partner with Digital, Marketing, Underwriting, Risk Consulting, Product, Claims,...  ...in 54 countries, Chubb provides commercial and personal property and casualty insurance, personal accident and... 
    Commercial
    Full time
    Temporary work
    Local area

    Chubb

    Chicago, IL
    4 days ago
  • $136.62k - $199.12k

     ...validation of our reputation as an excellent underwriting company.Principal Duties &...  ...and bad faith litigation arising under commercial general liability and/or first party property...  ...initiatives led by the American Property Casualty Insurance Association that aim to... 
    Commercial
    Full time
    Work at office
    Local area

    RLI Corp

    Chicago, IL
    2 days ago
  •  ...clients under the J.P. Morgan and Chase brands. Our history spans over 200 years and today we are a leader in investment banking, consumer and small business banking, commercial banking, financial transaction processing and asset management. We offer a competitive total... 
    Commercial

    Hackajob

    Chicago, IL
    4 days ago
  • $100k - $220k

     ...Customer Shared Services As a Director, Private Credit Special...  ...within BMO's Corporate & US Commercial Portfolio. Working closely with...  ...to apply your credit, underwriting, negotiation, and relationship...  ...Makes recommendations to senior leaders on strategy and new... 
    Commercial
    Full time
    Contract work
    Part time
    Bank staff
    Local area
    Shift work

    Bank of Montreal

    Chicago, IL
    9 days ago

Do you want to receive more vacancies?

Subscribe and receive similar vacancies to Commercial Casualty Underwriting Leader (Director). Be the first to apply!