Insurance Specialist Paralegal

Insurance Specialist Paralegal

We are seeking a highly skilled Insurance Specialist Paralegal to support a private trust company. This role is ideal for a professional with strong personal lines insurance expertise, sound judgment, and the ability to manage multiple priorities while working with senior stakeholders.

Partnering closely with the General Counsel, you will play a key role in personal lines property & casualty insurance program management, risk mitigation, and legal support across corporate, trust, and real estate matters.

Key Responsibilities

Personal Insurance (Primary Focus)

• Manage and optimize personal lines property & casualty insurance programs (property, liability, auto, marine, valuable articles)
• Lead renewals, claims, and policy administration
• Analyze coverage, identify gaps, and provide clear recommendations to clients and advisors
• Oversee risk mitigation and compliance with carrier requirements
• Coordinate directly with brokers, carriers, and vendors, supporting negotiations and claims resolution
• Review premiums and manage invoice/payment coordination

Paralegal Support

• Support the General Counsel across contracts, governance, trusts, and real estate matters
• Draft and manage vendor agreements and legal documentation
• Track multiple matters, deadlines, and workflows across stakeholders
• Maintain corporate records for LLCs, foundations, and trusts
• Coordinate with clients, advisors, and outside counsel to execute and manage legal processes
• Ensure accurate, confidential records management

Qualifications

• 5+ years of paralegal experience in (personal lines) insurance, corporate, real estate, trusts, or family office environments
• Strong insurance knowledge with the ability to assess coverage and manage claims end-to-end
• Proven ability to multitask, prioritize, and deliver under pressure
• Excellent communication and negotiation skills across all levels of stakeholders
• High attention to detail, discretion, and integrity
• Proficiency with Microsoft Office and legal/administrative systems

Crosby Company of New Hampshire is an equal opportunity employer committed to fostering an inclusive and collaborative environment.