Principal Recruiter - Insurance
$200kTalently
Job Title: Principal Recruiter - Insurance
Location: Remote (US-Based)
Compensation: Base Salary + Commissions + Bonus | OTE $200K–$500K+
About Talently Talently is a fully remote recruitment agency built for high-performing full-desk recruiters with deep vertical expertise and a proven ability to grow strategic client relationships . We provide the tools, tech, and BD support so you can focus on what matters most: winning accounts, delivering for your clients, and growing your book of business.
About the Role We’re looking for an experienced Principal Recruiter - Insurance to help us build teams across carriers, brokerages, and MGAs nationwide.. The ideal candidate will be our strategic partner in leading sales and growing our Insurance practice.
- Target Roles: Producers, Account Managers, Underwriters, Claims, CSRs, Sales Leadership, Commercial Lines, Personal Lines
What Makes Talently Different?
We eliminate the typical friction that slows down great recruiters:
- Warm Leads Weekly: We generate warm leads in your vertical every week through targeted outbound campaigns. No cold prospecting grind!
- AI-Powered ATS: Our AI-powered ATS streamlines your workflow and eliminates time-consuming tasks.
- Candidate Sourcing Stack: LinkedIn Recruiter, job ads, candidate databases, and multi-channel outreach help you connect with the right talent fast.
- Account Ownership: We stay lean on purpose so you have access to high-quality jobs, protected accounts, and minimal internal overlap.
What You’ll Do
- Own your Vertical: win searches, fill roles, and build key client accounts
- Expand accounts and become a trusted partner in your niche
- Build candidate pipelines and deliver a world-class experience
- Take on team leadership or mentorship responsibilities as we grow
What We’re Looking For
Must-Haves
- 3+ years of proven success in full-desk/360 agency recruiting
- A consistent track record of high billings ($400K+ preferred)
- Strong account management and candidate delivery skills
- High integrity, reliability, and team-first mindset
- Coachable, curious, and driven to grow
Nice-to-Haves
- Leadership experience or aspirations
- LI Recruiter & Boolean skills
If you’re a top-performing full-desk recruiter tired of building everything from scratch, Talently gives you the support, tools, and leads to win bigger & faster.
Vacancy posted 5 days ago
Similar jobs that could be interesting for youBased on the Principal Recruiter - Insurance in Cleveland, OH vacancy
$72k - $81k
...and business consulting firm serving middle-market businesses, insurance carriers, law firms, and other organizations across the United... ...line, while also assisting with support services searches and recruiting needs across other departments as needed. This role will...SuggestedWork at officeFlexible hours$27 - $32 per hour
...and business consulting firm serving middle-market businesses, insurance carriers, law firms, and other organizations across the United... ..., customers, and shareholders. Opportunity: The Recruiting Coordinator is primarily responsible for supporting the recruiting...SuggestedInternshipWork at officeFlexible hoursMEADEN & MOORE MANAGEMENT
Cleveland, OHa month ago- ...well connected in the space. \n \n We set ambitious goals, and work collaboratively to accomplish them. This isn't your dad's recruiting firm. We have a better way. \n \n A successful hire will be comfortable making cold calls in an effort to meet new people...SuggestedWork from home
Sandella Sova Search Partners
Cleveland, OH28 days ago - ...High technical autonomy Influence safety strategy on cutting-edge robotics programmes Flexible schedule + strong benefits package If you’re a senior robotics safety professional ready to lead at principal level, I’d welcome a confidential conversation....PrincipalRemote workFlexible hours
Akkar
Cleveland, OH23 hours ago - ...Job Description Job Description Description: Recruiting Manage full-cycle recruiting for attorneys, paralegals, legal assistants, client service representatives, and administrative staff Create and post job advertisements on recruitment platforms Source...SuggestedWork at office
Kaman & Cusimano LLC
Cleveland, OH16 days ago - ...Strategic Accounts, and field operations collaborate under the company’s One Team philosophy. About the Role The Sr Direct Hire Recruiter is responsible for identifying, attracting, interviewing, and placing top talent into permanent career opportunities across a...Permanent employmentLocal areaRemote work
Jobrapido
Cleveland, OH1 day ago - ...Wertz & Associates is hiring a Tax Principal to lead our Real Estate & Construction Tax practice. The role combines strategic tax advisory, leadership, and business development to grow client relationships and expand services for real estate developers, investors, and...Principal
Wertz & Associates
Cleveland, OH1 day ago - ...AMS is seeking a Senior Recruiter to lead full-cycle recruitment for our pharmaceutical organization. You will partner with hiring managers and leadership to attract, assess, and hire top talent across R&D and related functions. This role requires strong sourcing, market...
ams
Cleveland, OH1 day ago - Description Position Summary: The purpose of this position is to assist the Human Resources Manager with specialization in recruiting exempt and non-exempt positions. Duties and Responsibilities: This list is not comprehensive but meant to represent the most common or...
$800 per month
...pharmacy, long and short-term disability, vision, dental and other insurance solutions. What makes us unique is that we can surround our... ...Artificial Intelligence [AI] technologies to enhance our recruitment process. This includes using AI to filter candidates based on...Full timeTemporary workLocal areaOneDigital
Cleveland, OH2 days ago- ...Launch Your Career in Executive Recruiting! Ready to turn your communication and people skills, curiosity, and drive into a rewarding career? Starfish Partners is looking for motivated individuals to join our growing family of executive search firms. No recruiting...Base plus commissionFull timePart timeInternshipWork at office
Direct Recruiters, Inc.
Cleveland, OH4 days ago - ...Recruiter - November Start Date Who We Are Brooksource is a workforce solutions and consulting firm that connects leading organizations with top technology and engineering talent and project solutions. As part of Eight Eleven Group, we partner with Fortune 500 companies...Full timeInternshipLocal area
Brooksource
Cleveland, OH3 days ago - ...Fifth Third Bank is seeking an Investment Banking Principal/VP in Cleveland, OH, to lead and strategize the pitching and execution of complex M&A transactions, supervise Associates and Analysts, and deliver high‑quality analyses and presentations. You’ll guide junior team...Principal
Fifth Third
Cleveland, OH3 days ago - ...Sherwin-Williams seeks a Principal Practice Enterprise Architect, Data who sets enterprise data standards and roadmaps, guiding data platform choices and governance. You will work with data, analytics, security and privacy leaders as a peer to shape data products and AI...PrincipalRemote work
Sherwin-Williams
Cleveland, OH3 days ago $71k - $91k
...redefining the world of talent. Interested? Then we would like to talk to you! This is a 5-month Fixed-Term Contract opportunity. As a Recruiter, you will assist Hiring Managers in filling open positions by offering expert guidance and ensuring quality throughout the...For contractorsFixed term contractRemote work- ...Barnes Wendling CPAs in Cleveland-Sheffield Village is seeking a highly motivated Tax Principal to enhance its tax practice. In this key role, you will manage client relationships, mentor staff, and perform tax planning for high-net-worth clients. You will also review...Principal
Barnes Wendling Cpas
Cleveland, OH4 days ago $36 - $40 per hour
...Job Title: Recruiter Location (city, state): Arizona (specific location to be determined) Compensation: $36–$40 per hour Benefits: This position is eligible for medical, dental, vision, and 401(k). Qualifications: Minimum of 3 years of full-cycle recruiting...Hourly payPermanent employmentContract workCasual workWork at officeLocal areaImmediate startRemote workMonday to FridayFlexible hoursJobrapido
Cleveland, OH1 day ago- ...School District/Employer: District Category/Employer: , Position: Assistant Principal, Assignment Level: Level ~ High School Job Title: High School Assistant...PrincipalFull timeCleveland, OH7 days ago
- ...Executive Recruiter - Labels Direct Recruiters, Inc. (DRI) is looking for a driven, relationship-focused professional to join our Labels practice within our industrial recruiting group. This is a great opportunity for someone with a sales, recruiting, or business development...Work at officeFlexible hours
Direct Recruiters, Inc.
Cleveland, OH-37 $41.25k - $82.5k
...opportunity to contribute to the company's success. As a Campus Recruiter within PNC's Campus Recruiting organization, you will be based... ...), dental and vision options; employee and spouse/child life insurance; short and long-term disability protection; 401(k) with PNC...Full timeTemporary workPart timeWork at officePNC
Cleveland, OH4 days ago- ...Oriana House Inc. in Cleveland, OH is seeking an HR Office Assistant to support recruitment and general HR functions. Schedule is Monday–Friday, 9am–5pm, with comprehensive benefits and a collaborative team environment. The role requires a Bachelor's degree preferred or...Full timeWork at officeMonday to Friday
ORI1005ORIH
Cleveland, OH12 hours ago - ...Job Title: Contract Manufacturing Recruiter Location: HYBRID in Cleveland, Ohio Employment Type: Contract with potential for long-term or permanent placement Job Description: Own full-cycle recruiting for manufacturing roles, including production operators, skilled trades...Hourly payPermanent employmentContract workWork from home2 days per week
Storm Search
Cleveland, OH23 hours ago - ...Recruiter - November Start Date Who We Are Brooksource is a workforce solutions and consulting firm that connects leading organizations with top technology and engineering talent and project solutions. As part of Eight Eleven Group, we partner with Fortune 500 companies...InternshipLocal area
Brooksource
Cleveland, OH-37 - ...Talent Acquisition Recruiter, Facilities Management & Skilled Trades External Description Str : ABM is seeking a highly motivated Talent Acquisition Recruiter, Facilities Management & Skilled Trades to join our dynamic team and assist in attracting and retaining top...Work at office
The Aerozone
Cleveland, OH4 days ago - ...Commercial Recruiter OpportunityConnect great people with great opportunity. Looking for a job that keeps you moving? Where no two days are the same, but every day is a chance to make an impact? As a Commercial Recruiter with Nesco, you'll work daily to bridge the gap...Contract workWork at officeLocal area
NESCO Inc
Cleveland, OH2 days ago - Taylor Oswald in Cleveland is seeking a results-driven sales professional to generate new business opportunities, coordinate with internal teams, and build a plan to meet annual production goals. You will cross-sell multiple lines, source leads, identify decision-makers...
Taylor Oswald
Cleveland, OH3 days ago - ...ThinkingAhead Executive Search is assisting a well-established Ohio law firm in recruiting a Senior Insurance Defense Attorney. This succession-planning opportunity lets the selected candidate gradually transition key client relationships while preparing for a leadership...
ThinkingAhead Executive Search
Cleveland, OH4 days ago - ...Corporate Recruiter Job in Cleveland, OH: Below covers everything you need to know about what this opportunity entails, as well... ...paid benefits include short-term disability (STD) and basic life insurance, with additional voluntary options for life insurance and long...Full timeContract workTemporary workWork at office
NESCO Inc
Cleveland, OH4 days ago - ...Average of 10 hours per week; may vary based on project volume Compensation: Hourly rate commensurate with experience Ideal for: Recruiting professionals seeking project-based work, supplemental income, or consultants who would like to expand their portfolio About SilverLine...Hourly payExtra incomeContract workPart timeRemote work10 hours per weekFlexible hours
SilverLine Consulting
Cleveland, OH4 days ago - ...potential. Put your financial expertise, business insight, and ability to recognize exceptional talent to work building an independent recruiting business. No recruiting experience required. You bring the accounting or finance expertise, professional relationships, and...For contractorsWork from home
Goodwin Recruiting
Cleveland, OH4 days ago
Do you want to receive more vacancies?
Subscribe and receive similar vacancies to Principal Recruiter - Insurance. Be the first to apply!
Related searches
- principal Cleveland, OH
- senior principal cloud computing engineer Cleveland, OH
- senior principal scientist Cleveland, OH
- insurance controller Cleveland, OH
- part time insurance Cleveland, OH
- insurance and financial services position Cleveland, OH
- insurance sales trainee Cleveland, OH
- insurance verification jobs Cleveland, OH
- insurance surveyor Cleveland, OH
- general insurance Cleveland, OH