GUEST SERVICE SUPERVISOR (EVENING SHIFT)
Wally s Operating Company LLC
Job Description
Job Description
Guest Service Supervisor
Front-End Leadership Role at Wally’s | Full Benefits | Growth Opportunity
Wally’s is seeking a dependable and service-focused Guest Service Supervisor to support front-end operations and help lead our Guest Service Team. This role blends hands-on cashier responsibilities with leadership accountability, ensuring transactions are accurate, guests feel welcomed, and daily operations run smoothly.
Guest Service Leads set the tone for hospitality and professionalism on the front end. If you enjoy mentoring others, staying organized in a fast-paced environment, and taking ownership of guest experience standards, this is an excellent opportunity to grow within Wally’s.
Benefits at Wally’s401(k) with 5% company match
Company-paid medical option
Dental & Vision coverage
Company-paid Life Insurance
PTO
Short-Term & Long-Term Disability
AD&D coverage
Health Savings Account (HSA)
Flexible Spending Account (FSA)
Guest Service Leads work directly alongside cashiers to ensure accuracy, efficiency, and hospitality standards are consistently upheld. You will support drawer counts, register balancing, transaction accuracy, and front-end organization while serving as a resource for newer team members.
You will provide real-time coaching, reinforce service expectations, and step in to resolve guest concerns using Wally’s BLAST de-escalation approach. Strong Leads maintain awareness of front-end performance, help correct issues before they escalate, and communicate effectively with Guest Service Managers when support is needed.
This role requires strong attention to detail, accountability, and the ability to lead by example in both service and compliance. Guest Service Leads also assist with training, mentoring, and reinforcing company standards across the team.
What We’re Looking ForWe are seeking candidates with prior guest service or cashier experience who are ready to take on leadership responsibility.
Ideal candidates demonstrate:
Strong cash handling and basic math skills
Confidence guiding and mentoring small teams
Professional communication and reliability
Ability to stay calm and solution-focused during busy periods
Comfort working in a high-volume retail environment
Flexibility is required, including availability for nights, weekends, and holidays.
Physical RequirementsExtended periods of standing and walking
Frequent use of hands and arms
Ability to lift up to 10 lbs regularly and up to 25 lbs occasionally
Ability to bend, reach, and move throughout the front-end area
The front end defines the guest’s first and last impression. Strong Guest Service Leads protect accuracy, speed, and hospitality standards while helping build a dependable and high-performing team.
If you are ready to step into leadership, strengthen your supervisory skills, and contribute to Wally’s continued growth, we encourage you to apply.
2PM - 10 PM40 HOURS/WEEK
- ...Shift Manager As part of the Subway team, you will focus on six main things: Providing an excellent guest experience Ensuring that great food is prepared & served Keeping our... ...responsibilities. Full Time/Part Time and Day/Evening/Weekend shift positions vary by...Afternoon shiftFull timePart timeShift workWeekend workDay shift
$26.5 per hour
...Job Description Job Description Production Supervisor We are seeking a motivated and experienced Bilingual (English, Spanish) Production Supervisor for second shift to lead daily warehouse and production operations. The ideal candidate will be a hands-on leader...Afternoon shiftShift work- ...and be part of a company where excellence, customer satisfaction, and our core values are at the heart of everything we do. The Supervisor will have various responsibilities, including: Supervise assigned personnel. Supervise direct reports in training &...Afternoon shift
$24.04 per hour
...the timely, accurate and quality delivery of customer goods and service. This role manages employee relations at the client site -... ...through superior customer service and develops relationships with supervisors and associates. This role anticipates staffing requirements...Afternoon shiftHourly payWork at officeLocal areaImmediate startWeekend work$17 - $21 per hour
...Shift Leader The Torchy’s legacy began in Austin, Texas in 200... ...a Damn Good experience to our guests. You will balance hands-on involvement... ...of food safety, guest service, and restaurant operations.... ...work varying shifts, including evenings, weekends, and holidays. Ability...Afternoon shiftHourly payFull timeFlexible hoursShift work- Subway - 72622-0 in Whitestown, Indiana, is seeking a Shift Manager to ensure an excellent guest experience and supervise staff operations. This role includes... ...-time positions are available, with flexible shifts including evenings and weekends. #J-18808-Ljbffr Subway - 72622-0Afternoon shiftFull timePart timeFlexible hoursShift work
$15 - $18 per hour
...Now Hiring: Shift Leader (Hourly) Department: Operations Reports... ...staff, ensuring an excellent guest experience, maintaining food... ...real time to improve speed, service, and execution. Ensure restaurant... ...things done the right way, even in high-pressure moments....Afternoon shiftHourly payFull timeContract workLocal areaImmediate startShift workWeekend work- JobRx, Inc. is seeking a Staff Pharmacist Manager for second shift operations in Whitestown, Indiana. This role oversees manual dispensing in a high-volume, automated pharmacy environment, leading a team of licensed pharmacists and pharmacy technicians. The ideal candidate...Afternoon shift
- ...Inc (MGI). On Site Performance Manager (OSPM) will effectively service the client by streamlining the Human Resource (HR) process and strive... ...a light. High School and Higher Education preferred Shift: Every Friday, Saturday & Sunday 5pm - 5am Morales Group Benefits...Afternoon shiftTemporary workWork at officeLocal areaImmediate startShift workWeekend work
$21 per hour
...Wage $21 / Hour ~3PM-11PM Wednesday - Sunday Shift Available. ~ Paid Orientation And Training!... ...For Full Time Employees! Allied Universal Services is currently searching for a Professional Security Shift Supervisor . The Shift Security Supervisor will supervise...Afternoon shiftFull timeLocal areaShift work$100k - $115k
...Manager, directly training and leading Supervisors and employees and leveraging your system... ...daily performance. The current second-shift schedule is planned for 3:00 p.m. to 11:... ...filling errors, late deliveries and overall service levels. Evaluates employees’...Afternoon shiftWork at officeShift workWeekend work- ...ICQA Supervisor - 2nd Shift Logistics at full potential. At GXO, we're constantly looking for talented individuals at all levels who can deliver the caliber of service our company requires. You know that a positive work environment creates happy employees, which boosts...Afternoon shiftWork experience placementWork at officeFlexible hours
- ...all levels who can deliver the caliber of service our company requires. You know that a... ...build a career you can be proud of. 2nd Shift, Tuesday - Friday, 4:30pm - 3:00am... ...procedures are followed. As the Quality Supervisor, you will establish, implement and maintain...Afternoon shiftWork experience placementWork at officeLocal areaFlexible hours
$100k - $115k
HarperCollins Publishers in Brownsburg, Indiana, is seeking a Warehouse Manager to lead operations. This role involves both pre-operations readiness and managing daily activities post-launch, ensuring efficient utilization of resources, coaching staff, and fostering a positive...Afternoon shift- ...Requisition ID: 253243 Locations: Indianapolis Schedule: 2nd Shift Click here to experience a Day in the Life of our Teammates... ...daily work activities that drive quality, efficiency, safety, service, and cost performance in a manufacturing plant. This role is responsible...Afternoon shiftHourly payWork experience placementWork at officeImmediate startShift work
$13 per hour
...JAVA HOUSE SHIFT MANAGER - CARMEL AREA At Java House, we're... ...atmosphere, and excellent customer service. We're looking for individuals... ...resolution - handling guest feedback in a productive and positive... ...may include early mornings, evenings, weekends, nights and/or holidays...Afternoon shiftFull timePart timeInternshipFlexible hoursShift workNight shiftEarly shift- Broughton Group is seeking a Warehouse Area Manager for the PM Shift in Whitestown, IN. This pivotal role involves overseeing daily warehouse operations, managing staff productivity, and ensuring customer satisfaction. The ideal candidate should have extensive experience...Afternoon shiftShift work
- JobRx, Inc. is seeking a Quality Supervisor in Whitestown, Indiana to lead daily quality operations in the Raw Material Warehouse. The role involves managing a team of Quality Associates to ensure compliance with GMP standards and internal procedures while safeguarding...Afternoon shift
- A popular bagel franchise is seeking a Shift Leader in Carmel, Indiana. The role includes motivating the team, providing feedback, and ensuring a great guest experience. Benefits include a competitive pay structure with tips, flexible scheduling, and a 401K plan with company...Afternoon shiftFlexible hoursShift workDay shift
- ...We are currently looking for passionate Shift Leaders to join our team! We are hiring for... ...quality food and drink and good customer service. Benefits of working at Firehouse Subs... ...MORE! REQUIREMENTS Weekend and evening availability required Past leadership...Afternoon shiftFull timePart timeCasual workFlexible hoursShift workWeekend work
- ...concert. Join our team! We are looking for a Shift Leader! Our Shift Leaders are like... ...motivate the team to deliver a great guest experience. We empower Shift Leaders to take... ...past 5PM (Yep, you read that right! NO EVENINGS & NO NIGHTS!) ~ Competitive pay, plus cash...Afternoon shiftLocal areaFlexible hoursShift workWeekend workDay shift
- ...management systems, and pet care products/ services is desirable. ? Excellent problem-... .... ? Flexibility to work variable shifts, including weekends and holidays, based... ...? Flexible work schedule to include evenings, weekends, and holidays. ? Ability to...Afternoon shiftHourly payFull timeFlexible hoursShift work
- ...Description Job Description Kitchen Supervisor (Food Service Supervisor) Wally’s | Full-Time |... ...performance, and deliver an outstanding guest experience. This role is responsible for... ...lbs occasionally 6 AM - 2 PM First Shift 2 pm - 10 pm 2nd Shift 40 hours/weekAfternoon shiftFull timeTemporary workFlexible hoursNight shiftDay shift
$70k
...an asset-based dedicated fleet, warehousing and distribution services, and nationwide multi-modal freight brokerage. Founded in 1999... ...preferred, but not required. Four + years of experience as a Supervisor or Manager in Warehousing, Logistics or Supply Chain...Immediate startFlexible hours$13 - $15 per hour
...Description Job Description Now Hiring: Shift Supervisor | Part-Time About the Job: As... ...customer concerns and ensuring every guest leaves satisfied. Your leadership will... ...~ Flexible schedules- day, night and evening shifts ~ Vacation pay and additional...Afternoon shiftHourly payPart timeImmediate startFlexible hoursShift workNight shiftDay shift- ...looking for someone to work weekends at Camp Bow Wow, a Premier Dog Day and Overnight Camp. Candidate can work the morning or evening shift only, or both shifts on the weekends (we have split shifts on weekends). You will also have the option of working during the...Afternoon shiftFlexible hoursShift workNight shiftWeekend workDay shift
- ...ability to be flexible. Hours of operation may include on call, evenings, and weekends, mainly Monday-Friday 1:00pm-9:30pm. Essential... ...read and interpret prescriptions. Strong focus on customer service, quality and accuracy. Ability to manage timelines and meet...Afternoon shiftLocal areaWork from homeMonday to FridayFlexible hoursWeekend work
- ...Warehouse Supervisor Position Summary: We are looking for a qualified Warehouse Supervisor to manage our team and provide effective guidance. You will be responsible for supervising, managing and motivating team members daily. As a team leader, you will be the contact...Temporary workWork experience placementFlexible hours
$65k - $68.83k
...Supervisor DC Warehouse Whitestown, IN, US, 46075 Locations: Whitestown Pay Range: $65,000 - $68,833.33, depending on experience Schedule: (Monday-Friday, 5:00p-3:00a, based on business needs) Uncap Your Potential at America's Largest Coca-Cola Bottler — Pour Your...Hourly paySummer workWork at officeMonday to Friday- ...Más every day while providing excellent service and training to ensure operational excellence... ...Excellence: Maintain a high-quality guest experience that keeps customers coming back... ...Paid Vacation. ~ Free Meals with Every Shift. ~401(k) with company match. ~...Shift work
Do you want to receive more vacancies?
Subscribe and receive similar vacancies to GUEST SERVICE SUPERVISOR (EVENING SHIFT). Be the first to apply!
- kfc shift supervisor Whitestown, IN
- shift managers Whitestown, IN
- 2nd shift production supervisor Whitestown, IN
- evening shift manager Whitestown, IN
- shift supervisor Whitestown, IN
- warehouse 2nd shift Whitestown, IN
- full time 2nd shift Whitestown, IN
- part time evening shift Whitestown, IN
- part-time 2nd shift Whitestown, IN
- evening shift Whitestown, IN



