Sign up to access all features of our service.
  • Job search
  • Favorites
  • Create a CV
    New
  • Salaries
  • Subscriptions

Agency Manager

Innovative Staff Solutions

Agency Manager

Location: Mattoon, IL
Employment Type: Full-Time

An Opportunity to Run and Grow Your Own Insurance Agency

ISS Insurance Group is looking for an experienced, entrepreneurial insurance professional to take the lead in managing and growing our independent insurance agency in Mattoon, Illinois.

This is more than a traditional insurance agent position. We are looking for someone who wants the opportunity to operate the agency as their own-taking ownership of sales, client relationships, carrier partnerships, day-to-day operations, and the long-term growth of the business.

You will step into an established agency with an existing book of business, carrier relationships, and infrastructure already in place. From there, you will have the opportunity to build upon that foundation, grow the book, develop new relationships, expand our carrier network, and ultimately build a team around you as the agency grows.

For the right person, this is an opportunity to combine the independence and upside of running an agency with the support and resources of an established organization.

Responsibilities
  • Take ownership of the overall growth and day-to-day operation of ISS Insurance Group.
  • Develop and execute a strategy to grow the agency's book of business.
  • Generate new business through referrals, networking, community involvement, prospecting, and existing relationships.
  • Manage and grow relationships with existing personal, commercial, life, and health insurance clients.
  • Identify opportunities to cross-sell additional products and expand existing accounts.
  • Build and maintain strong relationships with insurance carriers and identify opportunities to add new carrier partnerships.
  • Review client insurance needs and recommend appropriate coverage solutions.
  • Prepare and present competitive insurance options from multiple carriers.
  • Oversee renewals, policy changes, coverage reviews, and overall account management.
  • Ensure clients receive a high level of responsiveness and customer service.
  • Identify opportunities to improve agency processes, technology, marketing, and operations.
  • Recruit, develop, and manage additional insurance professionals as the agency grows.
  • Maintain accurate client and policy information within the agency management system.
  • Stay current on insurance products, underwriting requirements, market conditions, and industry trends.
Qualifications
  • Illinois Property & Casualty License required.
  • Life & Health License preferred.
  • Previous insurance agency, sales, account management, or leadership experience strongly preferred.
  • Existing insurance industry and carrier relationships are a plus.
  • Strong sales and business-development skills.
  • Ability to build and maintain long-term client relationships.
  • Entrepreneurial mindset with a desire to take ownership of a business and its results.
  • Ability to work independently and make decisions.
  • Strong communication, organizational, and leadership skills.
  • Experience with agency management systems and insurance technology preferred.
Who We're Looking For

The ideal candidate is someone who doesn't simply want another insurance job. We're looking for someone who has thought about running their own agency but would rather build on an established foundation than start completely from scratch.

You should be someone who enjoys developing business, building relationships, making decisions, and taking ownership of results. As the agency grows, we want this individual to have the ability to build a team and shape how the agency operates.

We want someone who sees the opportunity to look back several years from now and say, "I helped build this."

Compensation & Benefits

We are prepared to structure a competitive compensation package around the right individual, including:
  • Competitive base salary
  • Significant commission and performance-based earning opportunities
  • Compensation tied directly to agency growth and production
  • Existing book of business and client relationships
  • Established carrier relationships
  • Paid vacation and holidays
  • Support and resources from an established local organization
  • Ability to build and lead an insurance team
  • Long-term growth opportunities as the agency expands

Why ISS Insurance Group?

ISS Insurance Group is a locally owned independent insurance agency serving individuals, families, and businesses throughout Central Illinois.

Unlike starting an agency from the ground up, this opportunity provides an established platform from day one. The Agency Manager will inherit an existing foundation while having significant autonomy to determine how the agency grows from here.

Our goal is to find someone who wants to take ownership of the agency, grow the book of business, expand our capabilities, and build something they can be proud of long term.

EEO Statement:
Innovative Staff Solutions is an Equal Opportunity Employer. All employment decisions are based on qualifications, merit, and need.
Vacancy posted 5 days ago
Similar jobs that could be interesting for youBased on the Agency Manager in Mattoon, IL vacancy
  • $2,454 per week

     ...Registered Nurse (RN) | Case Manager Location: Mattoon, IL Agency: Lancesoft Inc Pay: $2,454 per week Shift Information: Days - 4 days x 10 hours Contract Duration: 13 Weeks Start Date: 11/30/2026 About the Position TravelNurseSource... 
    Suggested
    Long term contract
    Permanent employment
    Full time
    Contract work
    Temporary work
    Work at office
    Shift work

    TravelNurseSource

    Mattoon, IL
    1 day ago
  • $2,401 - $2,554 per week

     ...Registered Nurse (RN) | Case Manager Location: Mattoon, IL Agency: Host Healthcare Pay: $2,401 to $2,554 per week Shift Information: Days Contract Duration: 13 Weeks Start Date: 11/30/2026 About the Position Host Healthcare is an... 
    Suggested
    Full time
    Contract work
    Immediate start
    Shift work

    Host Healthcare

    Mattoon, IL
    1 day ago
  • $2,401 - $2,554 per week

     ...Registered Nurse (RN) | Case Manager Location: Mattoon, IL Agency: Host Healthcare Pay: $2,401 to $2,554 per week Shift Information: Days Contract Duration: 13 Weeks Start Date: 11/30/2026 About the Position TravelNurseSource is working... 
    Suggested
    Full time
    Contract work
    Local area
    Immediate start
    Shift work

    TravelNurseSource

    Mattoon, IL
    1 day ago
  • $2,381 per week

     ...Registered Nurse (RN) | Case Manager Location: Mattoon, IL Agency: OneStaff Medical Pay: $2,381 per week Shift Information: Rotating - 4 days x 10 hours Contract Duration: 13 Weeks Start Date: 11/30/2026 About the Position TravelNurseSource... 
    Suggested
    Hourly pay
    Weekly pay
    Full time
    Contract work
    Work experience placement
    Work at office
    Flexible hours
    Shift work

    TravelNurseSource

    Mattoon, IL
    1 day ago
  • $2,264 - $2,510 per week

     ...Registered Nurse (RN) | Case Manager Location: Mattoon, IL Agency: LRS Healthcare Pay: $2,264 to $2,510 per week Shift Information: Days Contract Duration: 13 Weeks Start Date: 11/30/2026 About the Position TravelNurseSource is working... 
    Suggested
    Full time
    Contract work
    Immediate start
    Flexible hours
    Shift work

    TravelNurseSource

    Mattoon, IL
    1 day ago
  • $2,772 per week

     ...Registered Nurse (RN) | Case Manager Location: Mattoon, IL Agency: AHS Staffing Pay: $2,772 per week Contract Duration: 13 Weeks Start Date: ASAP About the Position Registered Nurse - Case Management - Travel | Mattoon, Illinois Estimated... 
    Hourly pay
    Weekly pay
    Daily paid
    Full time
    Contract work
    Immediate start
    Flexible hours
    Shift work

    AHS Staffing

    Mattoon, IL
    1 day ago
  • $2,264 - $2,510 per week

     ...Registered Nurse (RN) | Case Manager Location: Mattoon, IL Agency: LRS Healthcare Pay: $2,264 to $2,510 per week Shift Information: Days Contract Duration: 13 Weeks Start Date: 11/30/2026 About the Position Ready to start your next... 
    Full time
    Contract work
    Immediate start
    Shift work

    LRS Healthcare

    Mattoon, IL
    1 day ago
  • $2,772 per week

     ...Registered Nurse (RN) | Case Manager Location: Mattoon, IL Agency: AHS Staffing Pay: $2,772 per week Contract Duration: 13 Weeks Start Date: ASAP About the Position TravelNurseSource is working with AHS Staffing to find a qualified Case... 
    Hourly pay
    Weekly pay
    Daily paid
    Permanent employment
    Full time
    Contract work
    Temporary work
    Immediate start
    Flexible hours
    Shift work

    TravelNurseSource

    Mattoon, IL
    1 day ago
  • $2,454 per week

     ...Registered Nurse (RN) | Case Manager Location: Mattoon, IL Agency: Lancesoft Inc Pay: $2,454 per week Shift Information: Days - 4 days x 10 hours Contract Duration: 13 Weeks Start Date: 11/30/2026 About the Position We are currently... 
    Full time
    Contract work
    Shift work

    Lancesoft Inc

    Mattoon, IL
    1 day ago
  • $2,587 per week

     ...Registered Nurse (RN) | Case Manager Location: Mattoon, IL Agency: Cynet Health Pay: $2,587 per week Shift Information: Days - 5 days x 8 hours Contract Duration: 13 Weeks Start Date: 11/23/2026 About the Position TravelNurseSource... 
    Full time
    Contract work
    Monday to Friday
    Shift work
    Weekend work

    TravelNurseSource

    Mattoon, IL
    1 day ago
  • $2,587 per week

     ...Registered Nurse (RN) | Case Manager Location: Mattoon, IL Agency: Cynet Health Pay: $2,587 per week Shift Information: Days - 5 days x 8 hours Contract Duration: 13 Weeks Start Date: 11/23/2026 About the Position Job Title: RN Case... 
    Full time
    Contract work
    Monday to Friday
    Shift work
    Weekend work

    Cynet Health

    Mattoon, IL
    1 day ago
  • $22.5 - $35.75 per hour

     ...technician personnel. Leads training, coaching, and performance management of pharmacy technicians. Makes decisions regarding performance...  ...and records required by the company and various government agencies. Manages core pharmacy workflow and drives excellence in pharmacy... 
    Hourly pay
    Full time
    Work experience placement
    Local area
    Flexible hours
    Afternoon shift

    Walgreens

    Mattoon, IL
    5 days ago
  •  ...company processes and service standards Qualifications Excellent written and verbal communication skills Strong organization and time-management abilities Self-motivated and comfortable working remotely Detail-oriented and customer-focused mindset Customer service,... 
    Full time
    Part time
    Remote work
    Flexible hours

    Enchanted Horizons Travel

    Mattoon, IL
    3 days ago
  • $160k - $190k

     ...General Manager Opportunity in Clark County, IL A confidential, industry-leading manufacturer is seeking an experienced General Manager in Clark County, IL area to lead a high-performing sheet metal manufacturing operation in the Agriculture Industry. This executive... 

    gpac

    Mattoon, IL
    5 days ago
  •  ...safety isn't just a priority-it's our passion. The Contribution You'll bring to this Role: We are looking for a Quality Manager that is experienced, detail-oriented to join our growing team at Mattoon, IL. This position will play a key role in overall success... 
    Permanent employment
    Temporary work
    Work at office
    Flexible hours

    Justrite Mfg.

    Mattoon, IL
    4 days ago
  • $100k

     ...and monthly bonuses; Our top performers make well over a 6-figure income. To ensure your success, you will have a dedicated sales manager & support team, continued results-driven training, WHAT THE COMPENSATION PACKAGE OFFERS: UNCAPPED EARNING POTENTIAL AGGRESSIVE COMMISSIONS... 
    Local area

    Slice Merchant Services

    Mattoon, IL
    2 hours ago
  • General Manager Full-time, Salaried Are you enthusiastic about providing exquisite customer service and working in a dynamic team environment? Do you have a passion for leading small teams, problem solving, and learning about all aspects of the Movie Theater Industry? Join... 
    Full time
    Work at office
    Weekend work
    Afternoon shift

    GQT Movies

    Mattoon, IL
    1 day ago
  • $49k - $70k

     ...doing tomorrow. Are you ready to be a Roadie?Pay: $49,000.00 - $70,000.00 annuallyTexas Roadhouse is looking for a legendary Service Manager to oversee all Front of House daily operations, manage all Front of House employees, and make sure Legendary Food and Legendary... 
    Hourly pay
    Flexible hours
    Night shift

    Texas Roadhouse

    Mattoon, IL
    3 days ago
  •  ...Steak N Shake Manager Opportunity Steak N Shake is hiring managers looking to make a difference! We have exciting times ahead! What we sell is an experience. We are looking for passionate people with a fun-loving attitude who provide a hospitable service. You:... 
    Shift work

    Steak 'n Shake

    Mattoon, IL
    2 days ago
  • $46.92k

     ...development so they can reach their full potential. Responsibilities include: * Providing daily supervision and mentorship * Managing household routines and student schedules * Administering medications and ensuring student wellness * Driving students to... 
    Full time
    Work from home
    Relocation
    Relocation package
    Flexible hours
    Weekday work

    Milton Hershey School

    Mattoon, IL
    1 day ago
  • $1,000 per month

     ...Travel RN Case Manager Mattoon, Illinois Get all the details (no obligation). Facility TotalMed Offers ~ Sick Leave Accrual in All 50 States ~ Mental Health Support ~ Health Benefits Available on Day One ~401(k) Available ~ Expert Support on All Aspects... 
    Temporary work
    Immediate start

    Total Med

    Mattoon, IL
    5 days ago
  • $51k

     ...closing responsibilities. Driving sales through customer service and report analysis. Qualifications Must have 5 years of RETAIL management experience. Strong organizational and leadership skills and interpersonal/communication skills; as well as problem solving... 

    Dunham's Sports

    Mattoon, IL
    26 days ago
  •  ...Assistant Store Manager Customer ExperiencePetSmart does Anything for Pets – JOIN OUR TEAM!Our associates are the heart of Team PetSmart. Together, we're building the best team in retail through our values-based culture, connection, and teamwork. Our goal is to create... 
    Minimum wage
    Full time
    Local area
    Immediate start
    Home office
    Weekend work
    Afternoon shift

    PetSmart

    Mattoon, IL
    4 days ago
  • $74.9k - $97.4k

     ...possess strong organizational, planning, communication, and leadership skills. They will have the ability to effectively coordinate and manage operational activities, ensuring efficient workflows, clear communication channels, and successful execution of tasks and projects.... 
    All shifts
    Flexible hours
    Shift work
    Night shift

    Bimbo Bakeries

    Mattoon, IL
    4 days ago
  • Deli/Bakery Team Supervisor WM Supercenter #481 101 Dettro Dr Mattoon, IL 61938-9044 CP-481-9014 $20.00 - $33.00/hr* Full time Shifts may vary Role Summary The main priority of Deli / Bakery associates is to prepare quality products for customers. They engage ...
    Hourly pay
    Minimum wage
    Full time
    Temporary work
    Part time
    Shift work

    Walmart

    Mattoon, IL
    4 days ago
  •  ...Drive regional revenue growth by identifying high-value commercial accounts, negotiating multi-year service agreements, and managing the full sales cycle from proposal to close. Requires strong consultative pitching skills, pipeline forecasting experience, and the ability... 
    Local area

    JobsTry

    Mattoon, IL
    3 days ago
  • $18 - $20 per hour

     ...Environmental Services Manager In Training Join Healthcare Services Group (HCSG) as an Environmental Services Manager in Training, where you will learn to manage your own account and oversee housekeeping, laundry, and floor care operations at a long-term care facility... 
    Local area

    Healthcare Services Group

    Mattoon, IL
    4 days ago
  •  ...fast, friendly service at all times. Our golden rule: "The customer is the most important person in all our stores."The Assistant manager is responsible for the proper and efficient operation of their shift, within company policy, in such a manner as to ensure that the... 
    Local area
    Immediate start
    Relocation
    All shifts
    Shift work
    Afternoon shift

    Hucks

    Mattoon, IL
    5 days ago
  • $70.16k - $108.74k

     ...office and collaborate with hospital-based care coordinators, case managers, and skilled nursing facilities to provide a model of care that...  ...in acute care situations., Collaborates with community agencies/resources to provide timely services including quality outcomes... 
    Full time
    Work at office
    Day shift

    Sarah Bush Lincoln

    Mattoon, IL
    3 days ago
  • Rural King seeks a Paid Search Manager to lead paid digital advertising strategy, execution, and optimization across Google Ads, Meta Ads, and CTV/OTT. You’ll manage budgets, target audiences, and deliver data-driven recommendations to support Rural King and its affiliated... 

    Rural King

    Mattoon, IL
    4 days ago

Do you want to receive more vacancies?

Subscribe and receive similar vacancies to Agency Manager. Be the first to apply!