Senior Insurance Defense Attorney | Trial Litigation | NYC | Hybrid

Senior Insurance Defense Attorney – New York, NY Join a growing boutique litigation firm in New York City, recognized for its expertise in high-stakes insurance defense cases. This is an exceptional opportunity for seasoned litigators seeking meaningful courtroom experience, direct mentorship, true autonomy over their files, and long-term career advancement in a collaborative, supportive culture. Senior Insurance Defense Attorney Benefits & Compensation Base salary of $175,000–$220,000+ Performance bonuses beginning at 1,950 billable hours Additional bonuses linked to successful verdicts and settlements Hybrid work schedule for work-life balance 401(k) and financial planning resources Generous PTO, team events, and celebrations Supportive partners dedicated to attorney well-being and professional growth Direct access to partners and genuine mentorship Full ownership of litigation caseload Senior Insurance Defense Attorney Requirements & Qualifications Active New York Bar admission Juris Doctor (J.D.) 6+ years of litigation experience Significant insurance defense background Proven deposition (taking and defending) and motion practice experience Demonstrated courtroom and hearing expertise, including managing cases independently Strong legal writing skills Experience with insurance carrier reporting and billing systems Senior Insurance Defense Attorney Preferred Background & Skills First-chair or significant second-chair trial experience Experience with New York Labor Law (200, 240, 241) Catastrophic injury, construction accident, and premises liability litigation experience Familiarity with Microsoft Office, legal billing, time entry, and carrier reporting software Exposure to iManage, NetDocuments, Westlaw, or LexisNexis is a plus Senior Insurance Defense Attorney Day-to-Day Responsibilities Independently manage a docket of complex insurance defense litigation from inception through resolution or trial Defend catastrophic injury, premises liability, construction accident, and Labor Law claims Conduct and defend plaintiff, expert, and fact witness depositions Draft pleadings, discovery, motions, and summary judgment motions Appear in court for hearings, arguments, mediations, arbitrations, and trials Evaluate liability, damages, and litigation strategy for each matter Prepare witnesses, experts, and clients for trial Mentor junior attorneys and contribute to a collaborative team culture Build trusted relationships with insurance carriers and clients If you're ready to take ownership of sophisticated litigation, achieve real courtroom experience, and grow with a firm where attorneys are truly valued, we encourage you to apply. New Day Executive Search