School Principal - Full Time

About Mount Mercy Academy
Mount Mercy Academy is a Catholic college-preparatory school for young women, sponsored by the Buffalo Regional Community of the Sisters of Mercy and dedicated to carrying out its educational mission in the spirit of Catherine McAuley. Founded in 1904 and nestled in a residential area of South Buffalo, the Academy has educated more than thousands of graduates over its 120-year history.
Mount Mercy affirms the uniqueness and dignity of individuals and fosters faith with a commitment to the challenges of building a just society. The board of trustees, faculty, and staff, alongside a dedicated community of families and alumnae, seek to maintain a nurturing atmosphere where Mercy students are called to be women of faith, knowledge, integrity, and compassion.
The Academy serves students in grades 9-12 and offers a broad academic program including Advanced Placement courses, dual enrollment opportunities, and specialty academies in areas such as Science & Healthcare, Leadership, and the Social Sciences. Over 85% of students participate in after-school athletics or activities, and every student completes at least 100 hours of community service during their four years.
Mount Mercy is now at an important inflection point that calls for focused, forward-facing leadership to strengthen financial sustainability, grow enrollment, and ensure the Academy continues to fulfill its mission for the next generation of young women in Western New York.
Mount Mercy Academy is conducting a national search for its next Head of School. The community is seeking a mission-driven leader who will serve as the chief executive of the institution and its primary ambassador to the broader community.
The next Head of School will inherit a community deeply devoted to its mission with a faculty and staff who have dedicated careers here, alumnae who credit the school with shaping their sense of possibility, and parents who describe the school as feeling like a family. They will also pursue opportunities to grow enrollment, ensure financial sustainability, and strengthen culture and communication across all stakeholder groups.
This is a compelling role for a leader who brings operational discipline and a genuine commitment to Catholic education and the development of young women.
Provide broad oversight of all day-to-day operations, including curriculum, schedules, attendance, admissions, cafeteria services, maintenance, extracurricular activities, and grading system
Create and nurture the appropriate organizational structure to achieve strategic goals
Support coordination of communication among parents, students, faculty, staff, and Trustees
Collaborate closely with the Director of Operations and Management on the business functions of the school
Partner on fundraising efforts, including major gifts, annual giving, and corporate and foundation partnerships
Expand and diversify revenue through individual, corporate, and community giving
Champion enrollment marketing efforts and serve as a persuasive advocate for the Academy's mission to prospective families
Implement decisions, directives, and policies established by the Board of Trustees
Balance growth with program quality, ensuring Mount Mercy continues to deliver strong academic and co-curricular outcomes
Ensure that the philosophy, Mission, and Values of the Sisters of Mercy are realized and advanced across every dimension of Academy life
Represent the Academy within the broader context of the Diocese of Buffalo, the Sisters of Mercy of the Americas, the Mercy Secondary Education Association, Mercy Sponsorship Network, and the National Catholic Education Association
Represent the Academy at school, social, civic, and religious functions
Financial & Operational Stewardship
Deliver financial strategies in conjunction with the Board of Trustees, including preparation and presentation of the final capital and operating budget
Ensure financial decisions align with long-term sustainability and program impact
Strengthen internal systems, policies, and infrastructure to support efficient operations
Maintain a strong, trust-based partnership with the Board of Trustees, ensuring alignment on strategy and fiduciary responsibilities
Significant leadership experience in education, administration, or a comparable mission-driven organization
Demonstrated financial acumen, including budget management, fiscal oversight, and resource allocation
Experience leading, developing, and coaching others with a track record of building high-performing teams and positive organizational culture
Experience in or meaningful exposure to fundraising, community engagement, and external relationship development
Understanding of Catholic education and alignment with the Mission and Values of the Sisters of Mercy
Bachelor's degree in a relevant field
Master's degree in School Administration, Educational Leadership, or a related field strongly preferred
Experience as a school principal, president, or senior administrator in a Catholic or independent school setting
Familiarity with enrollment management strategies and marketing for independent or faith-based schools
Experience with strategic planning and organizational change management
Connections within the Western New York community a plus, but not required
This is a full-time, on-site leadership role based at Mount Mercy Academy in Buffalo, New York. The Head of School is expected to maintain a consistent and visible presence in the building and the broader community, with regular evening and occasional weekend commitments for school events, donor cultivation, community functions, and Board engagement.
A comprehensive benefits package is offered as well as possible tuition reimbursement.
Application and More Information
Additional information regarding the application process, search timeline, and candidate submission instructions will be shared as the search moves forward.