Attorney - Health Plan Recovery

Job Description

Job Description

Attorney – Health Plan Recovery 

About the Role

Own high-stakes health plan recovery outcomes for some of the largest health plans in the country.

In this role, you and Intellivo act on behalf of the health plan to pursue and resolve complex subrogation matters across ERISA, Non-ERISA, and fully insured plans. You will lead negotiation strategy and drive financial outcomes by representing the health plan in recovery efforts against plaintiff attorneys, insurance carriers, and adjusters.

You will handle matters involving motor vehicle accidents, slip and fall claims, medical malpractice, and workers’ compensation cases, ensuring the health plan’s reimbursement interests are protected and maximized.

This is not a traditional legal role. Your work directly translates into measurable financial results for your clients, and your compensation is directly tied to the recoveries you generate, with uncapped earning potential.

What You’ll Own

• A high-value portfolio of health plan reimbursement and subrogation cases
• End-to-end negotiation strategy—from case positioning through final settlement
• Financial outcomesdirectly tied to recoveries for the health plans you represent
• Key decision-making authority, including escalation strategy, legal positioning, and settlement approach

How You’ll Operate

• Serve as a direct representative of the health plan, leading negotiations with plaintiff attorneys, carriers, and adjusters
• Apply legal and strategic expertise to maximize recovery value across ERISA, Non-ERISA, and fully insured plans
• Own case progression and drive matters efficiently from intake through resolution
• Leverage a dedicated legal assistant to handle administrative aspects of your cases, allowing you to focus on strategy, negotiation, and outcomes
• Maintain a focus on execution, leverage, and results—not administrative work

What Success Looks Like

• Deliver consistent, high-value recovery outcomes across a high-volume portfolio
• Meet or exceed monthly settlement and recovery targets
• Make strong, timely decisions on case strategy, escalation, and settlement
• Increase impact over time by expanding portfolio capacity and leveraging additional legal assistant support

Compensation

• Base Salary:$100,000 – $120,000 (based on experience)
• Performance Incentive: Uncapped commission tied directly to individual recovery outcomes on cases
• Total Earnings:Uncapped and performance-driven

Why This Role Stands Out

• No billable hours– success is measured by case outcomes
• Direct representation– you advocate on behalf of major health plans in meaningful recovery matters
• Dedicated support model– legal assistant support allows full focus on negotiation and strategy
• True ownership– accountability for results across your portfolio
• Uncapped earning potential– compensation scales directly with performance
• Growth trajectory– expand your portfolio, increase complexity, and build team leverage over time

What You Bring

• Licensed attorney in at least one U.S. jurisdiction (active and in good standing)
• 0–2 years of experience with a strong desire to accelerate growth in a performance-driven role
• High level of drive, competitiveness, and ownership mindset
• Demonstrated ability—or strong readiness—to manage a high-volume case portfolio
• Comfort operating in a fast-paced, performance-driven environment
• Strong negotiation, communication, and critical thinking skills
• Ability to prioritize, make decisions with speed, and move cases forward efficiently
• Collaborative, results-oriented approach with a focus on outcomes over process

Who is Intellivo?

As an industry market leader in subrogation, Intellivo empowers health plans and insurers to maximize financial outcomes by identifying and pursuing more reimbursement opportunities from alternative third-party liability (TPL) payers. Through innovative technology, Intellivo accelerates the identification of reimbursement opportunities while completely eliminating the need to fill information gaps through ineffective and burdensome outreach to plan members. With a 26-year history of excellence, Intellivo proudly represents more than 200 of the country’s largest health plans. 

Why work for Intellivo?

Imagine a place where your talent is valued, and performance is rewarded. We are a collaborative team focused on solving complex challenges on the financial side of healthcare.

• A team that values partnership, accountability, and results
• Medical Insurance
• Dental & Vision Insurance
• Industry-leading health & wellness benefits
• 401(k) retirement plan
• Paid Time Off
• And more!

#LI-DS1

This is an on site role in our St. Louis, MO office.