Service Advisor Manager | $150K OTE - 2105

Automotive Service Advisor Manager

All Tire & Service –

Staten Island, NY

Most shops say they want leadership. What they really want is someone to hold the place together.

We’re looking for an  experienced Service Advisor Manager who can actually lead a high-volume service drive, train advisors, improve customer experience, and drive performance.

All Tire & Service is a growing multi-location operation with busy shops, strong car counts, and ownership actively investing in improving operations. Our Page Ave location needs a strong front-of-house leader who can bring structure, accountability, and consistency to the service team.

If you know how to build trust with customers, increase ARO ethically, and create a smooth workflow between advisors and technicians, this is a high-income opportunity with real upside.

What You’ll Get

• $80,000–$90,000 base salary
• Commission plan with $150,000+ OTE potential
• High-volume location with strong traffic flow
• Established multi-shop operation with growth opportunity
• Ownership support and direct communication
• Medical, dental, and vision contribution ($450/month)
• PTO
• 401(k)
• Paid training and certification reimbursement
• Company vehicle available for managers
• Stable team environment with long-term opportunity

How to Apply (Important)

We move fast and so should you.

Step 1: Apply
Step 2: Complete a quick phone interview with our AI assistant “Paige” (takes about 10 minutes)

After you apply, you’ll receive an automated text message with a phone number you can call at your convenience to complete the interview. Candidates who complete the Paige interview get priority.

About the Shop

All Tire & Service operates multiple high-volume locations across Staten Island and New Jersey. The Page Ave location services approximately 850 vehicles monthly and has a strong existing customer base.

The opportunity here is massive!

The location currently handles heavy inspection volume, but leadership wants to improve consistency, advisor performance, customer flow, and overall ARO. They’re investing in stronger leadership and operational structure to make it happen.

Vehicle mix includes:

• Domestic
• Asian
• European

Shop systems include:

• Tire Shop / Freedom SMS
• Steer CRM
• AutoOps

What We’re Looking For

• 5+ years of Service Advisor experience
• 2+ years of leadership or management experience
• Proven ability to increase sales and improve customer retention
• Strong communication and team leadership skills
• Ability to coach and train advisors
• Organized, process-driven mindset
• Comfortable working in a fast-paced, high-volume environment
• Automotive industry experience required

Shop Information

All Tire & Service – Page Ave
115 Page Ave.
Staten Island, NY 10309

Hours:

• Monday–Friday: 7:30 AM – 6:00 PM
• Saturday: 8:00 AM – 4:00 PM

If you’re ready to lead a busy shop, build a stronger team, and get paid for performance — we want to talk to you.