Commercial Producer New York

Description A nationally recognized Top 100 insurance brokerage is seeking a driven Commercial Insurance Producer who thrives in a fast-paced, relationship-driven environment and is motivated to drive revenue growth while building a book of business with significant upside potential. This is an opportunity for an entrepreneurial, sales-driven insurance professional seeking more than a traditional producer role - someone interested in building consultative client relationships, developing a sustainable pipeline of residual income, and creating long-term career and financial growth while leveraging technology, resources, capital, and infrastructure of an established organization to win business. What Makes This Opportunity Different Strong capital backing and investment in growth Highly entrepreneurial culture with autonomy to build Sales model designed to support producers as they scale Access to operational infrastructure, carrier relationships, and back-office support Aggressive commission structure with increasing payout percentages as your book grows Equity participation opportunity for high-performing producers Focus on long-term organic growth and business creation Responsibilities Develop and grow a profitable book of commercial insurance business Build and maintain strong relationships with clients, prospects, and referral partners Identify new business opportunities and drive organic revenue growth Collaborate with leadership to expand niche and specialty market opportunities Deliver strategic risk management and insurance solutions to clients Participate in the long-term growth and development of the organization Ideal Background Proven sales ability and business development mindset Experience in commercial insurance brokerage, specialty lines, or middle-market accounts Entrepreneurial mentality with interest in building a long-term business Strong relationship-building and communication skills Self-starter who thrives with autonomy and accountability Compensation & Opportunity Competitive base while validating, commission splits that increase with production Equity opportunity tied to growth and performance Full operational, marketing, and administrative support platform This role is ideal for a producer who wants the upside of growing a book while leveraging the strength, capital, and resources of a nationally established brokerage platform. About Criterion Executive Search, Inc. For 45 years Criterion Executive Search has been recognized as one of the nation's leading executive staffing and recruiting firms. As one of Tampa, FL first recruiting & staffing agencies we have been privileged to work with leading companies throughout the state of Florida. Those same strategic partnerships have allowed us to perfect our personalized, life-cycle approach to placing the ideal candidates with their ideal companies. Our innovative individualized placement strategies allow us to match Insurance professionals with companies throughout the country, and beyond. Each of our job placement specialists has a minimum of two years in the recruiting industry and an average of nearly 15 years of experience. Each recruiter has their own, personal, and direct experiences within their specialization. You may expect complete confidentiality at all times during the hiring process; a key element to the success of our business. In today's age we understand that our client's privacy is of the utmost importance. Contact the Criterion Executive Search office to speak with a recruiter about this job now or find out more about other job placement opportunities. All applicants applying for U.S. job openings must be authorized to work in the United States. All applicants applying for Canadian job openings must be authorized to work in Canada. ©2026 Criterion Executive Search. An Equal Opportunity Employer. Veteran Owned. Criterion Executive Search