Sign up to access all features of our service.
  • Job search
  • Favorites
  • Create a CV
    New
  • Salaries
  • Subscriptions

Customer Service Supervisor

GEICO Insurance Agent

Customer Service Supervisor

At GEICO, we offer a rewarding career where your ambitions are met with endless possibilities. Every day we honor our iconic brand by offering quality coverage to millions of customers and being there when they need us most. We thrive through relentless innovation to exceed our customers' expectations while making a real impact for our company through our shared purpose.

When you join our company, we want you to feel valued, supported and proud to work here. That's why we offer The GEICO Pledge: Great Company, Great Culture, Great Rewards and Great Careers.

Customer Service Supervisors for our Indianapolis office who are motivated, solution-oriented, and have a passion for excellent customer service. We're seeking outstanding associates who want to kickstart a fulfilling career with one of the fastest-growing auto insurers in the U.S.

As a Customer Service Supervisor, you'll mentor, coach, and develop a team of 10-15 Customer Service Representatives. You'll play a vital role in the company's success by helping your team provide expert insurance advice to our customers, handling escalated calls in order to work towards resolution, and completing regular audits to ensure your team is providing excellent service and meeting performance goals. Our supervisors use enthusiasm and attention to detail to provide support for their team and exceed the expectations of our customers.

This job is a great fit for people who are continuous life learners, as Customer Service Supervisors are constantly challenged to stay up-to-date with changes in the insurance industry and educate their team on these updates. Plus, GEICO encourages a promote-from-within culture, so there is plenty of room to grow your career and be rewarded for your hard work and determination.

Qualifications & Skills:

  • One year of prior supervisory experience required, preferably in a high-volume call center or within the financial services or insurance industries
  • Experience successfully managing remote associates preferred
  • Outstanding customer service skills and/or experience
  • Solid computer, grammar and multi-tasking skills
  • Highly effective communication and presentation skills
  • Active P&C or Property Lines License preferred

At this time, GEICO will not sponsor a new applicant for employment authorization for this position.

The GEICO Pledge:

Great Company: At GEICO, we help our customers through life's twists and turns. Our mission is to protect people when they need it most and we're constantly evolving to stay ahead of their needs.

We're an iconic brand that thrives on innovation, exceeding our customers' expectations and enabling our collective success. From day one, you'll take on exciting challenges that help you grow and collaborate with dynamic teams who want to make a positive impact on people's lives.

Great Careers: We offer a career where you can learn, grow, and thrive through personalized development programs, created with your career and your potential in mind. You'll have access to industry leading training, certification assistance, career mentorship and coaching with supportive leaders at all levels.

Great Culture: We foster an inclusive culture of shared success, rooted in integrity, a bias for action and a winning mindset. Grounded by our core values, we have an established culture of caring, inclusion, and belonging, that values different perspectives. Our teams are led by dynamic, multi-faceted teams led by supportive leaders, driven by performance excellence and unified under a shared purpose.

As part of our culture, we also offer employee engagement and recognition programs that reward the positive impact our work makes on the lives of our customers.

Great Rewards: We offer compensation and benefits built to enhance your physical well-being, mental and emotional health and financial future.

  • Comprehensive Total Rewards program that offers personalized coverage tailor-made for you and your family's overall well-being.
  • Financial benefits including market-competitive compensation; a 401K savings plan vested from day one that offers a 6% match; performance and recognition-based incentives; and tuition assistance.
  • Access to additional benefits like mental healthcare as well as fertility and adoption assistance.
  • Supports flexibility- We provide workplace flexibility as well as our GEICO Flex program, which offers the ability to work from anywhere in the US for up to four weeks per year.

The equal employment opportunity policy of the GEICO Companies provides for a fair and equal employment opportunity for all associates and job applicants regardless of race, color, religious creed, national origin, ancestry, age, gender, pregnancy, sexual orientation, gender identity, marital status, familial status, disability or genetic information, in compliance with applicable federal, state and local law. GEICO hires and promotes individuals solely on the basis of their qualifications for the job to be filled.

GEICO reasonably accommodates qualified individuals with disabilities to enable them to receive equal employment opportunity and/or perform the essential functions of the job, unless the accommodation would impose an undue hardship to the Company. This applies to all applicants and associates. GEICO also provides a work environment in which each associate is able to be productive and work to the best of their ability. We do not condone or tolerate an atmosphere of intimidation or harassment. We expect and require the cooperation of all associates in maintaining an atmosphere free from discrimination and harassment with mutual respect by and for all associates and applicants.

GEICO
Vacancy posted 1 day ago
Similar jobs that could be interesting for youBased on the Customer Service Supervisor in Indianapolis, IN vacancy
  • $90k

     ...and scalable.Why This Role ExistsWe're growing fast and need a Customer Success Manager who treats their book of business like a mini startup...  ...-timeJob functionJob functionGeneral BusinessIndustriesIT Services and IT ConsultingReferrals increase your chances of... 
    Suggested
    Local area
    Flexible hours

    GaggleAMP

    Indianapolis, IN
    3 days ago
  • $100k

     ...motivated, strategically minded individual who thrives in a complex, fast-paced environment and is passionate about helping Enterprise customers achieve their environmental compliance goals. The ideal candidate is comfortable leveraging AI tools and modern technology to work... 
    Suggested
    Remote work
    Flexible hours

    Encamp

    Indianapolis, IN
    2 days ago
  • Job Address: 8275 Allison Pointe Trail Suite 370Indianapolis, IN 46250 CommuniCare Advantage is currently recruiting a Partner Success Manager for our Medicare Advantage health plan. Key responsibilities: Foster trusted and productive relationships...
    Suggested
    Night shift

    CommuniCare Family of Companies

    Indianapolis, IN
    4 days ago
  • $56.1k - $77.2k

     ...A leading education technology organization is seeking a Customer Success Manager II to enhance customer satisfaction and retention in the K12 education sector. The ideal candidate will manage a portfolio, develop proactive strategies, and collaborate with cross-functional... 
    Suggested
    Remote work

    Renaissance Inc.

    Indianapolis, IN
    1 day ago
  •  ...Senior Director of Customer Success About the Company Rapidly advancing B2B SaaS organization based in NY Industry Internet Type Privately Held About the Role The Senior Director of Customer Success will be responsible for driving value to customers... 
    Suggested

    Confidential

    Indianapolis, IN
    2 days ago
  •  ...internal systems and support tools ◾Represent the values of Service Over Sales, putting clients’ well-being first ◾Participate in...  ...with an interest in finance, education, or social impact ◾Experience in leadership, customer service, or peer mentoring is a plus... 
    Full time

    Globe Life: Moore Organizations

    Indianapolis, IN
    4 days ago
  •  ...difference. Our environment is positive, casual, and comprised of people dedicated to delivering world-class solutions and exceptional customer service. Come join our team for happier workdays. About the Position Clinical Architecture is seeking a Client Success Manager in the... 
    Full time
    Temporary work
    Casual work
    Work at office

    Clinical Architecture

    Indianapolis, IN
    4 days ago
  • $50k - $60k

     ...Manager to oversee client relationships and deliver high-quality service. The role involves managing multiple projects, maintaining...  ...communication. The ideal candidate should have a strong background in customer service, problem-solving skills, and the ability to navigate... 

    A Hiring Company

    Indianapolis, IN
    4 days ago
  • Endress+Hauser Flowtec AG is seeking a Service Value & Success Manager to drive customer value through measurable success journeys. The role involves partnering with customers to align on business objectives, facilitating workshops, and ensuring value realization throughout... 

    Endress+Hauser Flowtec AG

    Greenwood, IN
    1 day ago
  • $78.8k - $145.13k

     ...important healthcare questions. Through our products, education, and services, MedInsight is making an impact on healthcare by helping to...  ...perform other related or unrelated duties as assigned by your supervisors, or as may be required to meet project team goals and... 
    Full time
    Temporary work
    Work experience placement
    Remote work
    Flexible hours

    Milliman, Inc

    Indianapolis, IN
    4 days ago
  • $85k - $100k

     ...integrated software, curated and customizable content, and expert services - embedded into existing learning, HR, and work systems - to...  ...expand their human+AI potential and thrive through change. Our Customer Success Managers (CSM's) are trusted advisors to our customers... 
    Remote work

    OpenSesame

    Indianapolis, IN
    3 days ago
  •  ...lead streamlined, effective internal teams to support clients and customers. Essential Job Functions Performance Monitoring Oversee daily...  ...Identify opportunities with CSMs to expand the client’s use of service Participate in creating of goals, and track progress... 
    Temporary work
    Work experience placement

    Sharecare

    Indianapolis, IN
    2 days ago
  •  ...understanding clients' business needs, collaborating with the Sales team for renewals, and delivering exceptional service. Applicants need 4+ years in customer relationship management, effective communication skills, and familiarity with healthcare technology. Benefits... 

    Clinical Architecture

    Indianapolis, IN
    4 days ago
  • Customer Success Manager - Remote - Zionsville, IN NexGen Solutions is looking for a Customer Success Manager who will be integral in retaining...  ...Meetings - Within 30 days after the sale of a new product or service, the CS team will contact the customer to ensure proper... 
    Remote job
    Contract work

    NexGenCAM, LLC

    Zionsville, IN
    4 days ago
  •  ...Excellent medical, dental, vision benefits 401(k) match + company‑paid life insurance Three weeks PTO, seven paid holidays, two paid service days Fast‑paced, growth‑focused environment Casual dress code + pet‑friendly office Hybrid or remote flexibility What We’re... 
    Casual work
    Work at office
    Remote work
    Shift work

    Love Serve Lead, Inc.

    Indianapolis, IN
    2 days ago
  • $99.4k - $186.3k

     ...months to ensure you are not duplicating efforts. Job Category Customer Success Job Details About Salesforce Salesforce is the #1 AI CRM...  ...challenges. Increase customer engagement with products and services and identify major political barriers to customer success. Partner... 
    Work at office
    Flexible hours
    3 days per week

    Centaur Labs

    Indianapolis, IN
    13 hours ago
  • $70k

     ...cross-functional processes to support program design, standardizing where possible while customizing for client needs as required. Lead daily status meetings, ensuring all service activities and outcomes are tracked, monitored and updated for accurate status reporting... 
    Daily paid
    Full time
    Local area

    BCforward

    Indianapolis, IN
    4 days ago
  • Customer Success Manager Summary A Customer Success Manager (CSM) is the primary point of contact for our dealer accounts, ensuring their...  ...maintain customer confidence and provide exceptional customer service. Strong verbal and written communication skills. 30% travel... 
    Work at office

    EmergencyMD

    Indianapolis, IN
    23 hours ago
  • $80k - $85k

     ...with key stakeholders. Driving retention, organic growth within existing relationships/programs (new users/new locations/ancillary services), and high-quality cross-sell opportunity identification of new carriers to partner with Field Sales. What You Will Do Client... 
    Work at office

    Datavant

    Indianapolis, IN
    4 days ago
  •  ...OverviewCustomer Success Manager, Digital Touch | Customer Success | North America | RemoteRLDatix (RLD) is on a mission to help raise...  ...within digital workflows and create documentation to streamline service delivery and operational efficiencySupport automated campaigns,... 

    RLDatix North America

    Carmel, IN
    2 days ago
  • A leading health care organization in Indianapolis is seeking a Partner Success Manager to strengthen relationships with partners and enhance engagement strategies. The ideal candidate should have experience in the senior living industry and be comfortable in client-facing...
    Remote job
    Full time

    CommuniCare Health

    Indianapolis, IN
    23 hours ago
  • Love Serve Lead, Inc. is looking for a Client Success Manager in Indianapolis, IN, to drive the success of our clients through strategic partnership. You will manage client relationships, lead initiatives, and deliver integrated marketing campaigns to ensure goals are met...
    Remote job
    Flexible hours

    Love Serve Lead, Inc.

    Indianapolis, IN
    2 days ago
  • What is the role about? The Service Value & Success Manager is responsible for driving measurable customer value through high-touch Success Journeys (primary KPI for measuring realized customer value via Salesforce CRM) by partnering with customers to understand their... 

    Endress+Hauser Flowtec AG

    Greenwood, IN
    1 day ago
  • The Customer Success Manager is responsible for ensuring long‑term operational success, system reliability, and business value realization...  ...Intelligrated’s material handling automation and lifecycle services portfolio. This role serves as the strategic partner for distribution... 
    Contract work
    Temporary work
    Work experience placement
    Remote work
    Flexible hours

    Honeywell International, Inc.

    Indianapolis, IN
    23 hours ago
  • Shaw Industries Group, Inc. is seeking an Account Manager in Indianapolis, Indiana. The successful candidate will be responsible for growing sales revenue and nurturing business relationships within assigned accounts. This role requires at least 2 years of sales experience...

    Shawfloorscareers

    Indianapolis, IN
    4 days ago
  • $81.7k - $166.1k

     ...Job Description Job Title: Customer Engagement Manager, IC3 – Oracle Health Job Summary: The Customer Engagement Manager is responsible...  ...life-saving care. And with AI embedded across our products and services, we help customers turn that promise into a better future for... 
    Contract work
    Temporary work
    Flexible hours

    Oracle

    Indianapolis, IN
    1 day ago
  • $15 - $18.69 per hour

     ...Client Service Coordinator The Client Service Coordinator ("CSC") drives the flow of clients and pets through the hospital, maximizes...  ...Hiring Qualifications / Competencies: Leadership Customer Focus Peer Relationships Integrity & Trust Action Oriented... 
    Hourly pay
    Minimum wage
    Full time
    Temporary work
    Part time
    Flexible hours
    Shift work

    Banfield

    Greenwood, IN
    19 days ago
  • $55k - $70k

     ...management and retirement challenges through custom solutions and a people-first approach....  ...working relationships with co-workers, supervisors, and carrier representatives. Assist...  ...of directly related industry sales and service experience Certificates, Licenses,... 
    Full time
    Remote work

    NFP

    Indianapolis, IN
    3 days ago
  • $160k - $190k

     ...We enable our clients to achieve key business outcomes that reshape how our world runs. As an expert technology adviser and managed service provider with cross-platform certifications, Ensono empowers our clients to keep up with continuous change and embrace innovation.... 
    Full time
    Temporary work
    Work experience placement
    Remote work
    Flexible hours

    Ensono

    Indianapolis, IN
    2 days ago
  • City Bloomington, Green Bay, Indianapolis, Kansas City, Madison, Milwaukee State/Province Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Missouri, Wisconsin Country United States Date Thursday, April 23, 2026 Working time...
    Full time

    Xerox

    Indianapolis, IN
    4 days ago

Do you want to receive more vacancies?

Subscribe and receive similar vacancies to Customer Service Supervisor. Be the first to apply!