Property Claim Supervisor
Western Mutual Insurance Group
Job Description The Western Mutual Insurance Group has been providing excellent customer service to homeowners throughout the Southwestern United States for over 80 years. We are rated A (Excellent) by A.M. Best Company and have been named among the Top 50 Property Casualty Insurers in the country by Ward’s. Our constant endeavor in employee relations is to maintain a well-trained, enthusiastic, and efficient group of employees who work together to make our business successful, thus enhancing the career goals of every employee. We have an immediate opening for an experienced Property Claim Supervisor. Candidate must have excellent leadership and supervisorial skills with the ability to guide and develop a team of adjusters. The candidate must possess excellent writing skills. Must understand and comply with company claim handling procedures as well as applicable department of insurance regulations; and must ensure that direct reports do the same. Will be responsible for effectively handling escalated problem files. The candidate should be able to oversee the triage of all water damage claims to determine which claims need an immediate response to mitigate the company’s exposure. Candidate should be able to review adjuster and vendor estimates and make corrections where appropriate. Candidate must have a minimum of 5 years’ experience adjusting property insurance claims and experience with automated claim systems and a minimum of 3 years of supervisorial experience. Experience with the Xactimate estimating program is preferred. Experience handling first party litigated claims. A bachelor’s degree is preferred. They will be required to work in the San Antonio office. Bilingual - English/Spanish speaking is preferred but not required. We offer a competitive salary and a full benefits package including, 401k Plan, Profit Sharing Plan and Bonus Plan. Please see our Privacy Notice For Job Applicants here: Company Description The Western Mutual Insurance Group has been providing excellent customer service to homeowners throughout the Southwestern United States for over 80 years. We are rated A (Excellent) ) by A.M. Best Company and have been named among the Top 50 Property Casualty Insurers in the country by Ward’s. Our constant endeavor in employee relations is to maintain a well-trained, enthusiastic and efficient group of employees who work together to make our business successful, thus enhancing the career goals of every employee. Please see our Privacy Notice For Job Applicants here: Company Description The Western Mutual Insurance Group has been providing excellent customer service to homeowners throughout the Southwestern United States for over 80 years. We are rated A (Excellent) ) by A.M. Best Company and have been named among the Top 50 Property Casualty Insurers in the country by Ward’s. Our constant endeavor in employee relations is to maintain a well-trained, enthusiastic and efficient group of employees who work together to make our business successful, thus enhancing the career goals of every employee. Please see our Privacy Notice For Job Applicants here: #J-18808-Ljbffr Western Mutual Insurance Group
- Western Mutual Insurance Group is seeking an experienced Property Claim Supervisor to lead a team of adjusters and ensure adherence to company procedures. The role focuses on triaging water damage claims to mitigate exposure and reviewing estimates for accuracy. The ideal...Suggested
- ...and monitors the activities of assigned claims adjusters and other claims personnel. Assists... .... This position will be supervising Property Specialists. Duties and Responsibilities... ...any other duties as requested by their supervisor, or as become evident. Capabilities Customer...SuggestedFull timeTemporary workWork at officeWork from homeHome office
- ...Claims Supervisor Supervises, trains, and monitors the activities of assigned claims adjusters and other claims personnel. Assists the... ...with hybrid flexibility. This position will be supervising Property Specialists. Duties and Responsibilities Manages overall...SuggestedWork at office
$73.35k - $113.25k
...Workers' Compensation Claims SupervisorThe Workers' Compensation Claims Supervisor is responsible for supervising a team of direct reports, ensuring all quality, productivity and customer service criteria are met while adhering to company policies and procedures. The...SuggestedMinimum wageFull timeWork at officeLocal areaRemote workFlexible hoursNight shift$75k - $90k
Ready to lead and make an impact at a Top 50 Property & Casualty Insurance Company whose mission is to serve and protect Wisconsin families, farms, and businesses? As an Auto Claims Supervisor at Rural Mutual Insurance Company, you will provide daily leadership, coaching...SuggestedRemote work- ...A leading insurance firm is seeking an Auto Claims Supervisor to provide leadership and guidance to a team of adjusters in Wausau, Wisconsin. This remote position is perfect for an experienced adjuster dedicated to developing team capabilities and enhancing claim handling...Remote work
- Creative Risk Solutions, a Holmes Murphy line of business, is seeking a Sr. Liability Claims Specialist, Supervisor to lead a high-performing adjuster team and ensure top-tier claims handling from start to finish. You will adjudicate, investigate, negotiate settlements,...
- ...Claims Supervisor At Gallagher Bassett, we're there when it matters most because helping people through challenging moments is more than just our job, it's our purpose. Every day, we help clients navigate complexity, support recovery, and deliver outcomes that make...Local areaRemote work
- Wisconsin Municipal Mutual Insurance Company is seeking a Work Comp Supervisor to oversee complex workers’ compensation claims, guide a team, and ensure high-quality, compliant outcomes. The role requires leadership, deep knowledge of claims practices, and the ability...Remote job
- Job Description Join our growing team as a Sr. Liability Claims Specialist, Supervisor at Creative Risk Solutions, where you'll lead a high-performing... ...CPCU. Licensing: Active state specific Life & Health/Property Casualty Insurance agent’s license required or the...Remote jobFull timeTemporary work
- Solera Holdings, LLC. is seeking a Field Claims Representative to manage pre- and post-loss assessments and inventory for high-value client properties. You will work with vendors on mitigation efforts, compile inventories, photos, and client interviews, and travel frequently...
- ...Job Description Claims Manager Location: Wisconsin Job Type: Full-Time Work Arrangement: Hybrid A well-established insurance organization is seeking an experienced Claims Manager to oversee day-to-day claims operations and support a...Full time
$130k - $150k
...REQUIREMENTS: Bachelor’s degree in Business, Insurance, or a related field (or equivalent work experience). Minimum of 5 years of claims handling and management experience. Minimum of 2 years of supervisory experience within a Claims role Strong knowledge of insurance...Full timeWork experience placement- ...Society Insurance is seeking an experienced Claims Manager-Workers' Compensation to lead a team of claims professionals and ensure high-quality, compliant handling for policyholders and injured workers. The role emphasizes coaching, process improvement, and collaboration...
- ...Job Information Job Title Claims Manager (Workers' Compensation) Home Department: Claims Employment Status: Exempt; Full-time Schedule: Flexible Scheduling Opportunities Position Location: Remote/Hybrid Worker (States include...Full timeLocal areaRemote workFlexible hours
- ...American Family Insurance is seeking a leader to guide a liability-focused claim adjusting team, directing investigations, and coordinating liability determinations. The role may be field-based or centralized, with 80% remote work and occasional office travel. The position...Work at officeRemote workRelocation package
$112k - $136k
...description: This role can be located in Reston, VA or Cambridge, MAFull Relocation providedHybrid and 9/80 work weekThe Government Property Supervisor serves as an integral member of the Supply Chain organization.Responsibilities include the maintenance of a compliant...Contract workFor subcontractorWork at officeRelocation3 days per week$99k - $266k
Industry/SectorNot ApplicableSpecialismInternational Tax ServicesManagement LevelManagerJob Description & SummaryAt PwC, our people in tax services focus on providing advice and guidance to clients on tax planning, compliance, and strategy. These individuals help businesses...Full timeH1b- Job Description Claims Manager - Personal Injury Law Firm El Paso, TX | Full-Time | In-Office Position (No Remote Work) Position Summary We are seeking an experienced Claims Manager to oversee the handling of personal injury claims from intake through settlement. This...Full timeWork at officeRemote workMonday to Friday
- Technology Strategy | Enterprise Architecture Senior ManagerFS / Insurance IndustryWe Are: We are Advisory. Our vision is to become the world’s leading advisors in harnessing technology and innovation as a force to reinvent and improve every business. Our mission is to ...Full timeLive inWork at officeLocal area
$89.8k - $170.5k
...engagement teams and prepare end-of-engagement evaluations for staff Understand skillsets and capabilities of Senior Associates and Supervisors and monitor and review work product that they prepare and report on performance while articulating coaching notes throughout the...Full timeWork experience placementInternshipLocal area- ...The Annex Group in Milwaukee, Wisconsin is seeking a Maintenance Supervisor to oversee maintenance operations and ensure high-quality living environments for residents. The role requires 3-5 years in maintenance supervision, strong communication, and the ability to manage...
- Job Opportunity At The International Autos Group The International Autos Group is a family owned and operated group of dealerships serving customers in the Milwaukee, Sheboygan, Chicago, Northwest Indiana markets and Minnesota. The owner of the organization is Ralph...
- F&I Manager We are looking for an F&I (Finance and Insurance) Manager to join our growing team! The right candidate will have a deep knowledge of dealership finance and insurance procedures and the ability to assist customers and close deals on additional product offerings...Local areaFlexible hours
$80k
Finance Manager Opportunity Start your career in finance at the Boucher Automotive Group! We are expanding in the West Bend area and are looking for passionate and motivated people to join our team! We encourage all applicants with sales, finance, or customer service...Temporary workLocal areaFlexible hours- ...care comefirst About the role If you have passion for maintaining properties & believe thatplaces provide pleasant experiences to people, we have an excitingopportunity for you! The Property Supervisor is a unique role,providing hands-on leadership to Grounds and Maintenance...
$25 - $30 per hour
Property Supervisor Riversbend Owner Association Germantown, WI About the Role Riversbend Owner Association is seeking an experienced and hands‑on Property Supervisor to oversee the daily operations, maintenance, and overall appearance of our 38‑acre property‑community...Hourly payFor contractorsWork at officeLocal area- About Heiser: For more than 100 years, Heiser has been a family owned, premier automotive dealer group in Wisconsin. In December 2025, we were proud to expand into Door County with three new Heiser dealerships and a collision center. Heiser now has stores in Sturgeon Bay...Immediate startFlexible hours
- About Us All of us at Palmen Motors live and work in the community. We are your friends, neighbors, and customers. Every one of us promises to treat you like family, whether you are servicing your vehicle or purchasing a new one. Any business is only as good as its people...Local area
- F&I Manager The Finance and Insurance (F&I) Manager is responsible for helping customers finance their vehicle purchase by working with lending agencies. They also must have a deep understanding of aftermarket options and warranties that can be purchased with the vehicle...Local areaMonday to Friday2 days per week
Do you want to receive more vacancies?
Subscribe and receive similar vacancies to Property Claim Supervisor. Be the first to apply!
- remote property manager Wisconsin
- government property manager Wisconsin
- director of property management Wisconsin
- airbnb property manager Wisconsin
- property director Wisconsin
- senior property manager Wisconsin
- property manager Wisconsin
- property accounting manager Wisconsin
- temporary property manager Wisconsin
- healthcare claims Wisconsin

