Sign up to access all features of our service.
  • Job search
  • Favorites
  • Create a CV
    New
  • Salaries
  • Subscriptions

Experienced Sales Executive - Employee Benefits

Cottingham & Butler

Job Description

Job Description

We are seeking an experienced Employee Benefits Insurance Broker with at least 3 years' experience of B2B sales in the employee benefits space. This role will be responsible for providing expert advice and guidance to clients in navigating the complex landscape of employee benefits insurance and programs. Individuals who apply should possess:

  • Proven experience and success as an insurance broker, with a focus on employee benefits
  • A strong understanding of employee benefits products
  • Detail-oriented with strong analytical skills, capable of evaluating complex insurance plans and identifying cost-saving opportunities. 
  • Excellent communication and interpersonal skills, with the ability to build rapport and trust with clients.

Join a Winning Team: The individual in this role will joining a team with a solid track record of success in the employee benefits insurance industry. Over the years, our team has experienced significant growth of 18% (driven organically) and a client retention over 90%. This growth is a testament to our team's ability to adapt to changing market dynamics, anticipate client needs, and deliver results.  

Unmatched Sales Support: We surround our sales team with everything they need to be successful, including:

  • Experienced Account Management Teams – Your clients will be in good hands with our account management teams. They are capable and proficient. In addition to having skilled account managers, we intentionally build redundancy into the teams to ensure that clients get the best service possible.
  • In-House Specialists - Our team includes people that specialize in compliance, HR consulting, analytics, client communications, worksite products, stop loss and technology. 
  • Tools & Resources - You will have assessments, checklists, audits, etc. that you can use to tailor custom strategies for each client. You will also have access to partner companies that will provide you with additional resources, such as ThinkHR and Zywave, etc.

Ultimately, we like to win and have a track record of doing it year-over-year. Many of the best brokers in the nation have chosen to call Cottingham & Butler home and have built careers unlike anything in the industry. Here is a link to a highlight video from one of our National Sales Celebration Event.

Pay & Benefits

  • Full salary + bonus
  • Most Benefits start Day 1
    • Medical, Dental, Vision Insurance
    • Flex Spending or HSA
    • 401(k) with company match
    • Profit-Sharing/ Defined Contribution (1-year waiting period)
    • PTO/ Paid Holidays
    • Company-paid ST and LT Disability
    • Maternity Leave/ Parental Leave
    • Subsidized Parking
    • Company-paid Term Life/ Accidental Death Insurance

About Cottingham & Butler:

At Cottingham & Butler, we sell a promise to help our clients through life's toughest moments. To deliver on that promise, we aim to hire, train, and grow the best professionals in the industry. We look for people with an insatiable desire to succeed, are committed to growing, and thrive on challenges. Our culture is guided by the theme of "better every day" constantly pushing ourselves to be better than yesterday – that's who we are and what we believe in.

As an organization, we are tremendously optimistic about the future and have incredibly high expectations for our people and our performance. Our ability to grow as a company, fuels investments in new resources to better serve our clients and provide the amazing career opportunities our employees want and deserve. This is why we are a growth company and why we are committed to being better every day. 

Want to learn more? Follow us on | LinkedIn | Facebook

Vacancy posted 15 days ago
Similar jobs that could be interesting for youBased on the Experienced Sales Executive - Employee Benefits in Appleton, WI vacancy
  •  ...Employee Benefits Consultant At Ansay & Associates, we are a dynamic and growing agency recognized as one of the Nation's Best and Brightest...  ..., warm and cold outreach, and industry events. Consultative Sales Approach – Utilize The Ansay Approach, our proven four-step,... 
    Suggested

    Ansay & Associates

    Appleton, WI
    5 days ago
  • $32 - $34.65 per hour

     ...Job Description Come join a growing team at TForce Freight! Offering pension, 401K, paid time off, excellent wages and benefits and much more! If you have a positive customer-focused attitude and excellent communication skills then come grow your career at TForce... 
    Suggested
    Local area

    TForce Freight

    Appleton, WI
    2 days ago
  •  ...Sales ExecutiveUnlock your potential at R&R Insurance Services. Whether you're experienced in commercial insurance, employee benefits, or personal lines—or ready to break into the industry with the right tools and mentorship—this is your chance to build a successful career... 
    Suggested
    Base plus commission
    Local area

    Wausau Insurance

    Neenah, WI
    2 days ago
  • $69k

     ...Remote Insurance Sales Representative | Flexible Schedule | Commission-Based This...  ...with stock options Comprehensive benefits package including medical, dental, and prescription...  ...Ongoing training and mentorship from experienced managers High-quality leads... 
    Suggested
    Remote work
    Work from home
    Flexible hours

    HMG Careers

    Appleton, WI
    17 hours ago
  •  ...B2B Sales Executive Location: Brookfield, WI | Full-Time | Uncapped Commission Ready to run with the big dogs and make serious money...  ...Konica Minolta, HP, Xerox, DocuWare) Paid training and full benefits (health, dental, vision, 401(k), PTO, and more) We're not... 
    Suggested
    Full time
    Shift work

    James Imaging Systems

    Neenah, WI
    1 day ago
  • $100k

     ...At TDS Telecom , our Residential Sales Representatives are more than sellers—they...  ...Marketing team, educating neighbors about the benefits of TDS Extra Benefits That Set Us...  ...) ~ Adoption & Surrogacy Assistance ~ Employee Assistance & Wellness Programs Associates... 
    Full time
    Temporary work
    Local area
    Immediate start
    Work from home
    Flexible hours

    TDS Telecom

    Appleton, WI
    a month ago
  •  ...Alro Steel is currently seeking an Inside Sales Representative to join our team in...  ...Whether you are a recent graduate or an experienced professional, Alro offers rewarding and...  ...well as a competitive compensation and benefits package. We work hard to provide our teammates... 
    Immediate start
    Flexible hours

    Alro Steel Corp

    Kimberly, WI
    16 hours ago
  • $80k - $100k

     ...Senior Residential Sales Representative Ready to take your door...  ...Why this role is perfect for experienced sales pros: Unlimited...  ...residential services. Extra benefits that set us apart: Day-one...  ...Adoption & surrogacy assistance ~ Employee assistance & wellness... 
    Temporary work
    Local area
    Immediate start
    Work from home

    TDS Telecom

    Appleton, WI
    2 days ago
  • $2,500 per week

     ...commercial account with at least 250 employees, every two weeks. $2,500 First Week Training...  ...the globe. We are currently HIRING experienced Sales Professionals nationwide with a...  ...offer a highly lucrative earnings and benefits package with top salespeople earning between... 
    Currently hiring
    Immediate start
    Day shift

    GHA Technologies, Inc

    Appleton, WI
    2 days ago
  •  ...handle the paperwork. We are looking for 1-2 experienced, professional, customer oriented people...  ...5 time Ford President Award Winner for sales and customer service. Our managers have...  ...— your hard work pays off! Full benefits package including health, dental, and 40... 
    Full time
    Immediate start

    Les Stumpf Ford

    Appleton, WI
    more than 2 months ago
  •  ...Job Description Job Description B2B Sales ExecutiveLocation: Brookfield, WI | Full-Time | Uncapped CommissionReady to run with...  ...partners (Konica Minolta, HP, Xerox, DocuWare)Paid training and full benefits (health, dental, vision, 401(k), PTO, and more) We're not just... 
    Full time

    James Imaging Systems

    Neenah, WI
    9 days ago
  • $21 per hour

     ...Sales Support Specialist SGS is the global leader...  .... With over 97,000 employees in 130 countries and operating...  ...Coordinate execution of SGS testing and other...  ...qualifications. Our Benefits We care about your...  ...for individuals who are experiencing difficulty applying... 
    Hourly pay
    Fixed term contract
    Work at office
    Local area
    Immediate start

    SGS

    Appleton, WI
    2 days ago
  • $100k

     ...Roofing Service Sales RepresentativeCentiMark Corporation has an...  ...and follow-up skillsPremier Benefits:2 Health Insurance Plans:No Cost...  ...MatchEmployer Provided Employee Stock Ownership Program (ESOP...  ...roof safety accessories. Our experienced project managers and crews work... 
    Full time
    For contractors
    Work at office
    Local area

    CentiMark

    Appleton, WI
    2 days ago
  • $100k - $250k

     ...5,000 - $250,000 Annually Are you looking for a proven sales process, career growth, and unlimited earning potential? At Erie...  ...for our unique, high-demand roofing solutions ~ W-2 Employee Benefits: medical, dental, vision, life insurance, & 401k with company... 
    Weekly pay
    Full time
    Weekend work
    Afternoon shift

    Erie Home

    Neenah, WI
    4 days ago
  • $50k - $100k

     ...Field Sales Representative with Leaf Filter Job Summary Are you financially happy in your current role? Does your current position...  ...customers with your expertise and educate them on the benefits of LeafFilter gutter protection and gutter replacement. Through... 
    Full time
    Weekend work
    Afternoon shift

    LeafHome

    Appleton, WI
    1 day ago
  • $75k - $85k

     ...this role will have experience in outside sales/business development in the healthcare...  ...five free counseling sessions through the Employee Assistance program. 401(k) with a company...  ...mileage reimbursement. And more. *Benefit eligibility can vary by position and... 
    Temporary work
    Shift work

    Amedisys

    Appleton, WI
    2 days ago
  • $75k

     ...products and systems are your roadmap to becoming a top earner in sales. If you’re prepared to unlock your full potential, let us show...  ...recruiting, back-office support, and customer service. You’ll also benefit from generous bonuses , annual renewal income , and luxury... 
    Flexible hours
    Night shift

    Platinum Supplemental Insurance

    Combined Locks, WI
    3 days ago
  • $53.89k - $64k

     ...Route Sales Representative Route Sales Representatives are critical to our success at FritoLay! Our Route Sales Representatives...  ...time team member, you will be eligible to receive full company benefits. You can learn more about our benefits on our career site, but... 
    Full time
    Local area
    Shift work
    Weekend work

    FRITO LAY

    Appleton, WI
    3 days ago
  • $100k

     ...Join an elite group of sales professionals bringing customized,...  ...Representative or Field Sales Executive – Home Solutions, this career...  ...comes with amazing perks and benefits: 401(k) plan Paid Time off and...  ...some exceptions, bargained employees qualify for one week of PTO after... 
    Temporary work
    Local area
    Afternoon shift

    AT&T

    Appleton, WI
    17 hours ago
  • $100k

     ...ambition into action.   At TDS Telecom , our Residential Sales Representatives are more than sellers—they’re trusted advisors...  ...alongside our Marketing team, educating neighbors about the benefits of TDS Extra Benefits That Set Us Apart ~ Day-one benefits... 
    Local area
    Immediate start
    Work from home
    Flexible hours

    TDS Telecom

    Appleton, WI
    2 days ago
  •  ...Route Sales Representative Join Chicago Baking Company and...  .... That's why we invest in employees who share our commitment to quality...  ...their business needs. Execute promotions, seasonal displays...  ...shifts as needed. Benefits Competitive benefits package... 
    Contract work
    Seasonal work
    Shift work
    Weekend work
    Early shift

    Lewis Bakeries

    Appleton, WI
    4 days ago
  • $75k

     ...products and systems are your roadmap to becoming a top earner in sales. If you’re prepared to unlock your full potential, let us show...  ...recruiting, back-office support, and customer service. You’ll also benefit from generous bonuses , annual renewal income , and luxury... 
    Flexible hours
    Night shift

    Platinum Supplemental Insurance

    Menasha, WI
    1 day ago
  •  ...sustainable, and agile. With more than 28,000 employees who make the world better every day, we...  ...!Job DescriptionEDGE Program, Technical Sales and ConsultingRockwell Automation's...  ...your personal life.To learn more about our benefits package, please visit at are committed... 
    Full time
    Internship
    Work at office
    Visa sponsorship
    Work visa
    Flexible hours

    Rockwell Automation

    Appleton, WI
    2 days ago
  •  ...Inside Sales Representative Come for the job-stay for the career...  ...competitive pay and all the benefits you'd expect from an industry...  ...match, insurance, time off, employee assistance, tuition...  ...Salesman in soliciting business, executing order transactions and maintaining... 
    Permanent employment
    Full time
    Local area

    Applied Industrial Technologies

    Appleton, WI
    4 days ago
  • $55k - $70k

     ...Sales Representative - In Office | Neenah, WI Date: Jul 7, 2026 Location: Neenah,...  ...an in-office, team-driven environment. Benefits ~ Health, dental, and vision insurance...  ...Employer and does not discriminate against any employee or applicant for employment because of... 
    Hourly pay
    Full time
    Work at office
    Local area
    Home office

    J. J. Keller & Associates

    Neenah, WI
    1 day ago
  •  ...Outside Sales Professional Join a forward-thinking company dedicated to your growth...  ...and capture your full potential. Key Benefits: 100% Investment in Your Growth: We prioritize...  ...worth building opportunities through our Employee Ownership Stock program, 401(k) match,... 
    Seasonal work
    Work at office

    Tom James Company

    Appleton, WI
    1 day ago
  • $41.26k - $80.46k

     ...strategies to procure referrals and other self-generated leads to meet sales and event targets through active participation in community...  ...in the lives of others. Molina Healthcare offers a competitive benefits and compensation package. Molina Healthcare is an Equal... 
    Full time
    Work experience placement
    Work at office
    Local area

    Molina Healthcare

    Appleton, WI
    3 days ago
  •  ...Comprehensive paid training Hourly wages plus uncapped incentives Full benefits package for full-time employees Supportive team culture Advancement opportunities Customer service, sales, hospitality, bartending, retail, or promotional experience is highly... 
    Hourly pay
    Full time
    Relocation package

    Renewal by Andersen® Greater Wisconsin

    Appleton, WI
    11 days ago
  • $45k

     ...Inside Sales Representative Apply Today Training Classes Begins September and October...  ...training opportunities Comprehensive benefits Flexible work arrangements Strong...  ...competitive labor market value for all employees in these positions across the national market... 
    Remote job
    Work experience placement
    Currently hiring
    Work at office
    Local area
    Work from home
    Flexible hours
    Shift work
    Weekend work
    Day shift
    Weekday work

    Liberty Mutual Insurance Group

    Appleton, WI
    3 days ago
  • $55k - $60k

     ...four core functions--customer service, driving, general labor and sales. In this role, you will: Be responsible for customer's...  ...required in working with our internal and external customers. Our benefits include: Medical, Dental and Vision Insurance 401(k) with... 
    Work at office
    Local area
    Monday to Friday
    Shift work
    Night shift
    Day shift

    American Signal Corporation

    Neenah, WI
    1 day ago

Do you want to receive more vacancies?

Subscribe and receive similar vacancies to Experienced Sales Executive - Employee Benefits. Be the first to apply!