Insurance Defense Attorney OH/IN/IL/WI/KY/MN

Insurance Defense Attorney

CURE Auto Insurance is a leading direct writer of auto insurance in New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and Michigan. CURE offers a great working environment, competitive salary, and a comprehensive benefits package which includes health and dental coverage, life and disability insurance, 401k with a generous company match, and much more! We are seeking experienced Insurance Defense Attorneys with 5–10 years of relevant litigation experience to join our growing legal team. This role offers the opportunity to manage a diverse caseload, represent clients in complex insurance defense matters, and contribute to a collaborative, high-performing environment. The ideal candidate is licensed in Ohio, Indiana, Illinois, Kentucky, Minnesota, or Wisconsin with the ability and willingness to obtain Michigan bar admission. Relocation bonus will be paid after the candidate has relocated within 40 miles of our Southfield, Michigan office.

Essential Job Functions:

• Work as internal counsel in conjunction with claims to strategize, implement, and manage representation of CURE in PIP and Coverage litigation cases in both Forthright and the Superior Court, from inception to conclusion, by trial or dispositive hearing
• Evaluating and providing detailed analysis of assigned cases in accordance with CURE's staff counsel policies and procedures, including trial and expense control
• Collaborate with CURE's Claims Department to establish, communicate, and implement team litigation objectives and obtain prompt resolution of claims
• Preparing and responding to arbitration demands and/or pleadings and discovery
• Preparing and handling arbitration submissions and Rule 35 applications for dismissal in Forthright matters
• Planning, taking, and defending Examinations Under Oath (EUO) and depositions
• Attending Forthright arbitrations, motion hearings, arbitration hearings, and all other pre-trial matters
• Ability to prepare for and try cases
• Ability to draft and argue post-arbitration/trial motions and appeals in both Forthright and the Superior Court
• Negotiating high-level settlement agreements

Experience/Qualifications:

• Juris Doctor (JD) from an ABA-accredited law school
• Active bar admission in Ohio, Indiana, or Illinois
• 5–10 years of insurance defense litigation experience
• Ability to obtain Michigan bar admission within a reasonable timeframe
• Strong litigation, analytical, and negotiation skills
• Excellent written and verbal communication skills
• Ability to manage multiple priorities in a fast-paced environment
• Ability to think critically, analyze complex information, and problem solve with expedience
• Highly collaborative working style with demonstrated commitment to meeting individual and team goals
• Must be adaptable and computer savvy with an ability to navigate multiple systems

Compensation & Incentives:

Starting Salary Range: $130,000 – $150,000 annually, based on experience and qualifications

Sign-On & Relocation Bonus:

$20,000 total sign-on/relocation bonus

$10,000 paid after 30 days of employment and relocation to the Southfield, Michigan office vicinity (within 40 miles)

$10,000 paid upon successful admission to the Michigan Bar

Performance Bonus and Flexible Schedule Incentive Opportunity

We believe in rewarding results. This role offers performance-based remote flexibility, allowing you to earn additional work-from-home opportunities, as well as a quarterly bonus potential tied to measurable success.

Benefits:

Comprehensive health benefits, including medical, dental, and vision coverage

Generous paid time off (PTO days, sick days, and holidays)

Flexible spending options with FSA & HSA plans

Life and AD&D insurance

401(k) with company match

Voluntary benefits such as legal services, pet insurance, and identity & fraud protection

24/7 Employee Assistance Program (EAP) for employees and their families

Fun, engaging in-office events that support our culture

Physical Actions/Environment: Required job duties consist of prompt and regular attendance, ability to frequently move about the office to coordinate work with others; standing, sitting, and typing for extended periods; and lifting and/or carrying up to 5 lbs. Ability to frequently communicate with others in-person, on the phone/virtually, and in writing. Ability to read, understand, process, and evaluate large amounts of technical information and make related, informed decisions.

Standard Schedule: We offer flexible work hours between 8:00 AM and 5:00 PM, with options like 8–4, 8:30–4:30, or 9–5. We do our best to support individual preferences, though schedules may be adjusted as needed to ensure strong coverage and teamwork.

We also offer a hybrid schedule: team members work onsite four days a week and can work remotely one day a week. At the conclusion of the employee's 90-day orientation period, they will be eligible for additional performance-based incentives that include additional remote flexibility and a bonus structure.

Location: Southfield, MI

We recruit, hire, employ, train, promote, and compensate individuals based on job-related qualifications and abilities. We respect the dignity and worth of each individual and are committed to an employment environment that is free from all forms of employment discrimination. CURE Auto Insurance provides equal employment opportunities to all employees and applicants for employment and prohibits discrimination and harassment of any type without regard to race, color, religion, age, sex, national origin, disability status, genetics, protected veteran status, sexual orientation, pregnancy, gender identity or expression, or any other characteristic protected by federal, state or local laws. This policy applies to all terms and conditions of employment, including recruiting, hiring, placement, promotion, termination, layoff, recall, transfer, leaves of absence, compensation, and training.

Disclaimer: This job description reflects management's assignment of essential functions; it does not prescribe or restrict the tasks that may be assigned. This job description may be subject to change at any time. Applicants must be authorized to work for ANY employer in the U.S. We are unable to sponsor or take over sponsorship of an employment Visa at this time.