Sign up to access all features of our service.
  • Job search
  • Favorites
  • Create a CV
    New
  • Salaries
  • Subscriptions

Nonprofit Human Services Underwriting Specialist

$90k - $140k
Full-time

The Mutual Group

Department: Field Underwriting

Job Description:

As a Commercial Lines Insurance Nonprofit Human Services Underwriting Specialist, you will be responsible for growing and managing a book of commercial lines business, including responsibility for advising other underwriters and support staff on processes and procedures and consulting at the highest level of technical underwriting authority. You will be analyzing and assessing exposures and acceptable risks for our Nonprofit Human Service Organizations and Education Institutions to determine coverages and premium that are both adequate and competitive. As a Nonprofit Human Services Underwriting Specialist you will build successful relationships with agents to drive increased, positive business flow. You will work under limited supervision and exercises significant independent judgment in performing work. Accounts vary in size, but may include accounts up to $1,000,000 in written premium.

Work Arrangement:

  • Employees who live within 30 miles of the TMG home office are expected to follow a hybrid or in-office schedule. The initial training period may require additional in‑office days.

Accountabilities:

  • Delivers profitable outcomes and growing a portfolio of complex niche business through effective risk selection by:

    • Analyzing, selecting and profitably pricing business with prescriptive terms and conditions of coverage.

    • Examining inspection reports, location, risk, financial and other available tools and reports to identify new or unresolved concerns.

    • Communicating with Risk Control for inspections, follow ups and service needs for insureds.

    • Driving corrective action or remediation strategies on renewal accounts.

    • Underwrite renewals referred by the underwriting assistant as well as renewals over 35K working to achieve required rate changes goals as outlined by management. Discuss and issue nonrenewals as needed.

    • Escalating referrals, in a timely manner, on accounts that need additional review or approval by higher level underwriters.

    • Adhering to service expectations and regulatory compliance by the timely release of renewals, non-renewals and conditional notices.

  • Accountable for achieving key performance indicators of the portfolio including:

    • Developing and furthering successful relationships with distribution partners within the portfolio by:

      • Having regularly scheduled portfolio review calls.

      • Meeting service standards for quality and timeliness.

      • Limited travel to distribution partner offices.

    • Coordinating with distribution team to build pipeline, resolve issues, concerns or conflict and oversee change management.

    • Communicating regularly with portfolio team members on health of assigned agencies and market conditions that could impact the portfolio.

    • Develop and grow agency relationships through daily interactions and in person visits throughout the year; collaborate with the distribution team on cultivating agency relationships and new business opportunities.

  • Cultivate a High Performing Culture

    • Superior customer service and business acumen.

    • Mentoring support staff throughout their career development.

    • Conduct peer audits.

    • Assist in the training of new hires and internal promotions by providing continuous mentoring and feedback to foster successful employee development.

    • Reviewing, mentoring, and approving referrals for lower authority level associates.

    • Perform other related work as assigned.

Qualifications:

  • Bachelors Degree or equivalent work experience.

  • 5+ years underwriting all commercial lines (Commercial Property, General Liability, Professional Liability, Worker's Compensation, Crime, Commercial Auto, Umbrella, etc).

  • Prefer Nonprofit Human Services and Education underwriting experience.

  • Excellent communication skills both in writing and verbal

  • Ability to analyze and make decisions in a timely manner

  • Working to obtain or has already CPCU or other industry equivalent

Pay Range:

Anticipated Hiring Range:

  • $90,000 - $130,000 annual base salary depending on experience, qualifications, and geographic location

  • $99,000 - $140,000 annual base salary depending on experience, qualifications, and geographic location in CA, CT, MA, NJ, NY, and PA

Benefits:

We are proud to offer our full-time regular employees a robust benefits suite that includes:

  • Competitive base salary plus incentive plans for eligible team members

  • 401(K) retirement plan that includes a company match of up to 6% of your eligible salary

  • Free basic life and AD&D, long-term disability and short-term disability insurance

  • Medical, dental and vision plans to meet your unique healthcare needs

  • Wellness incentives

  • Generous time off program that includes personal, holiday and volunteer paid time off

  • Flexible work schedules and hybrid/remote options for eligible positions

  • Educational assistance

Equal Opportunity Employer

The Mutual Group is an Equal Opportunity Employer. It is our policy to recruit, hire, train and promote individuals in all job classifications without regard to race, color, religion, sex, national origin, age, veteran status, disability, sexual orientation, gender identity or any other characteristic protected by law.

  • Know Your Rights: Workplace Discrimination is Illegal

  • Your Rights Under USERRA

Applicants requiring a reasonable accommodation due to a disability at any stage of the employment application process should contact View email address on aiapply.co .

Employment Verification

The Mutual Group participates in the E-Verify program and will provide the federal government with your Form I-9 information to confirm that you are authorized to work in the U.S. You are protected from employment discrimination based on your citizenship status and national origin.

E-Verify Program Overview

E-Verify Participation Poster

All offers of employment are contingent upon the successful completion of a background check.

#TMG

Vacancy posted 13 hours ago
Similar jobs that could be interesting for youBased on the Nonprofit Human Services Underwriting Specialist in Indianapolis, IN vacancy
  •  ...profitability, growth, and retention of an assigned book of business.Underwrite and skillfully negotiate complex customer accounts to minimize...  ...program provides access to free professional counseling services, health coaching and other resources to support your daily... 
    Suggested
    Full time
    Local area

    The Travelers Indemnity Company

    Indianapolis, IN
    1 day ago
  • $50.65k - $79.35k

     ...Association, visit our website at  POSITION SUMMARY: The Care Services Manager is responsible for developing professional and...  ...QUALIFICATIONS: Bachelor’s degree in Social Work, Nursing, Human Services, Case Management, or a closely related field required,... 
    Suggested
    Temporary work
    Local area

    The ALS Association

    Indianapolis, IN
    2 days ago
  •  ...Executive Director, Legal & Advocacy Services About the Company Well-established organization providing legal services to individuals...  ...Profit Founded 1977 Employees 11-50 Specialties nonprofit mental disabilities mental health fair housing... 
    Suggested

    Confidential

    Indianapolis, IN
    5 days ago
  •  ...building relationships, and delivering extraordinary customer service while maintaining a strong commitment to diversity and inclusion...  ...the heart of everything we do. We also help small businesses, nonprofits and cities grow, delivering solutions to solve all their... 
    Suggested

    Aumni

    Greenwood, IN
    2 days ago
  •  ...Beech Grove City Schools Student Services Specialist Qualifications: Holds a valid Indiana K-12 Mild Intervention/Equivalent License Commitment to being a part of a team with active participation and continued professional growth. Commitment to improving the quality of... 
    Suggested
    Contract work
    Local area

    ReNEW Schools

    Beech Grove, IN
    3 days ago
  •  ...ZINGAS Blinds Shutters Shades in Indianapolis, Indiana, is seeking a detail-driven Service & Warranty Representative to manage service and warranty requests. The right candidate will handle inquiries by phone, text, and email, ensuring issues are resolved accurately and... 
    Remote work
    Work from home
    Flexible hours

    ZINGAS Blinds Shutters Shades

    Indianapolis, IN
    5 days ago
  • $22.31 - $33.47 per hour

     .... We are incredibly proud of wherewe’ve come and are ready to tackle what’s next. Come join us!Position Summary:The Resident Services Specialist is responsible for handling resident and prospect inquiries along with managing and organizing concierge services, greeting,... 
    Monday to Friday

    BH Management Services, LLC

    Carmel, IN
    6 days ago
  •  ...POSITION TITLE: Card Services Specialist REPORTS TO: Card Services & ITM Operations Manager PAY GRADE: 7 DEPARTMENT: Internal Operations FLSA STATUS: Non-Exempt (Paid Hourly) LOCATION: Hybrid, 7101 East 56th Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46226 PURPOSE: The primary purpose... 
    Hourly pay
    Work at office

    Finance Center Federal Credit Union

    Indianapolis, IN
    5 days ago
  •  ...Schahet Hotels LLC's Homewood Suites Indianapolis Carmel is seeking a Guest Service Representative to join our team. This part-time front desk role requires weekend availability, with hours 3pm-11pm, and a friendly, service-oriented approach to guests. As the first in-... 
    Part time
    Weekend work

    Schahet Hotels

    Carmel, IN
    4 days ago
  •  ...Majestic Care is looking for a Clinical Education Specialist to join our teams’ mission and believe in our core values! Our mission: Through...  ...consistency, and governance of the respiratory care services needs of the patient and resident population and the enhancement... 
    Work at office
    Immediate start

    Bh Services

    Carmel, IN
    5 days ago
  •  ...Patient Service Specialist Location US-IN-Fishers Job ID 350840 Pos. Category Medical Center - Front Office Pos. Type Per Diem Recruiter : Full Name: First Last Kayla Quick Overview Are you ready to take... 
    Daily paid
    Work at office
    Local area

    Concentra

    Fishers, IN
    2 days ago
  •  ...TeamGlobal Partners is seeking a detail-oriented and service-minded Donor Services Specialist to support our donors and help advance the mission of...  ...similar donor management software.Experience working in a nonprofit, ministry, church, or donor-centered environment.... 
    Work at office
    Flexible hours

    The Wesleyan Church

    Fishers, IN
    5 days ago
  • $45.76k - $47.84k

     ...FHA Resource Center in Indianapolis, IN. Our Leidos Customer Service team supports the US Department of Housing and Urban...  ...use your mortgage background as a Loan Processor, Loan Officer, Underwriter, or other loan origination professional to help make a difference... 
    Hourly pay
    Minimum wage
    Full time
    Contract work
    Work at office
    Immediate start
    Monday to Friday

    Leidos

    Indianapolis, IN
    3 days ago
  •  ...Team Spirit • Demonstrate Integrity and Authenticity • Be Nice and Have Fun Position Overview: The Neighborhood Service Specialists plays a critical role in supporting Redwood Neighborhoods by providing hands-on maintenance expertise, operational support, and... 
    For contractors
    Work experience placement
    Work at office
    Local area

    Redwood Living Inc

    Indianapolis, IN
    3 days ago
  •  ...Installer Service SpecialistThe Installer Service Specialist is an experienced and technical parts specialist who services the needs of professional customers through the store's installer counter. This position will oversee and direct the daily activity of the delivery... 
    Local area
    Flexible hours

    O'Reilly Auto Parts

    Indianapolis, IN
    5 days ago
  • Community Health Network in Indianapolis is seeking a Patient Service Representative to provide exceptional administrative support to patients. Duties include checking patients in, collecting payments, scheduling appointments, and verifying insurance eligibility. The ideal... 

    Community Health Network

    Indianapolis, IN
    3 days ago
  •  ...Indiana and Ohio through providing low-cost, reliable, and environmentally responsible electricity, as well as a variety of other services to help in the overall success of each town or city. Our team is seeking an individual who will help maintain relationships with our... 
    Full time
    Local area
    Night shift

    Indiana Municipal Power Agency

    Carmel, IN
    5 days ago
  • $157.64k - $210.91k

     ...About Salesforce - Salesforce is the #1 AI CRM. Salesforce is focused on human agents driving customer success, combining technology, trust, and innovation. Role Overview The Agentforce Field Service Consultant is a primary strategic driver for complex deal execution.... 

    Salesforce

    Indianapolis, IN
    3 days ago
  • $17.5 - $18 per hour

     ...Patient Services & Imaging Specialist Cranial Technologies is the only company in the world completely dedicated to researching and treating plagiocephaly (commonly called flat head syndrome). With over 500,000 babies successfully treated, we are the plagiocephaly experts... 
    Hourly pay
    Full time
    Temporary work
    Work at office
    Work visa

    Cranial Technologies

    Indianapolis, IN
    4 days ago
  •  ...Mobile Service Parts Specialist Pace Transportation Services is looking for a Mobile Service Parts Specialist to support our growing Mobile Service team. In this role, you'll work alongside experienced diesel technicians to identify parts, manage inventory, source... 
    Work at office
    Immediate start

    Hinton Transportation Investments

    Indianapolis, IN
    4 days ago
  • POSITION TITLE: People Services Specialist DEPARTMENT: People Services POSITION REPORTS TO: AVP, People Services POSITIONS SUPERVISED: None...  ...employee lifecycle. The People Services Specialist serves as a human resources generalist responsible for supporting the full... 
    Full time
    Work at office
    Local area

    Financial Center

    Indianapolis, IN
    4 days ago
  •  ...Patient Access Services Specialist (Inpatient; 6p-6a) Date: Aug 24, 2026 Location: Indianapolis, IN, US, 46202 Organization: HHC Division: Eskenazi Health Schedule: Full Time Shift: Varied (Evenings/Nights) Eskenazi Health serves as the public hospital division... 
    Full time
    Work experience placement
    Local area
    Shift work
    Night shift
    Afternoon shift

    Health & Hospital Corporation

    Indianapolis, IN
    1 day ago
  • $85.28k - $104k

     ...and make an impact.Learn about the Danaher Business System which makes everything possible.The Senior Inside Sales Representative, Service is responsible for supporting the delivery of annual service contract orders, revenue, and renewal targets within an assigned territory... 
    Full time
    Contract work
    Remote work
    Work from home
    Flexible hours
    Night shift

    Danaher Corporation

    Indianapolis, IN
    5 days ago
  •  ...Key Responsibilities Provide professional customer service via phone and email to mortgage industry professionals and the public regarding...  ..., such as: Loan Originator Loan Processor Loan Officer Junior Underwriter Similar mortgage lending or origination role Minimum of one (1... 

    Beacon Hill

    Indianapolis, IN
    4 days ago
  •  ...calls you take, these types of calls should be easy for you! Job Description ACD Direct is currently seeking experienced customer service professionals for our 2015 Winter Campaign Project. This project is projected to begin the last week of November and continue... 
    For contractors
    Work from home

    ACD Direct

    Fishers, IN
    2 days ago
  •  ...Remote Travel Services SpecialistAs a Remote Travel Specialist, you will be an essential part of our team, guiding clients through every stage of their journey—from the moment they plan their trip to their safe return home. Your role is to ensure a seamless, stress-free... 
    Remote work

    Getaway Travel Agency

    Indianapolis, IN
    5 days ago
  •  ...Job Title: Client Services Specialist Department: Shared Services Reports To: Shared Services Manager Location: Any Selerix location Job Summary The Client Services Specialist is the foundational role in the Shared Services function — responsible for executing routine,... 

    Selerix

    Indianapolis, IN
    4 days ago
  • $28 per hour

     ...Bachelor's degree in business, finance, accounting, or supply chain SAP and Salesforce experience Advanced skills in data entry, Google Apps and Drives, MS Office Soft Skills Customer service focused Positive attitude Empathetic Agile learner... 
    Hourly pay
    Monday to Friday
    Shift work

    MindSource

    Indianapolis, IN
    5 days ago
  •  ...transfers with timely communication regarding status updates to advisory team Main point of contact with custodian and firm's technology service teams Interact with other departments, including Alternative Investments, as back office support Coordinate with clients' other... 
    Permanent employment
    Temporary work
    Work at office
    Flexible hours

    Corient Capital Partners

    Indianapolis, IN
    4 days ago
  •  ...The Retail Service Specialist will support the Store Manager and Assistant Managers in areas of sales, customer service, store appearance, and store operations. This position will also assume shift management responsibilities in the absence of Assistant or Store Manager... 
    Local area
    Flexible hours
    Shift work
    Night shift

    O'Reilly Auto Parts

    Greenwood, IN
    4 days ago

Do you want to receive more vacancies?

Subscribe and receive similar vacancies to Nonprofit Human Services Underwriting Specialist. Be the first to apply!