Insurance Defense Paralegal
$60k - $65kgpac
Full-Time Insurance Defense Paralegal
Location: Columbus, OH
Job Type: Full-Time
Schedule: In office | Monday to Friday
Salary: $60,000 – $65,000 / year
About the Role
A growing civil defense firm in the Columbus area is seeking a highly motivated, detail-oriented Full-Time Paralegal to join a friendly, fast-paced team. This position offers a supportive environment where you can manage a wide variety of litigation tasks and work closely with attorneys and clients.
Key Responsibilities
- Case Assessment & Research: Conduct initial case assessments and gather relevant information from diverse sources.
- Document Drafting & Filing: Draft pleadings, motions, and appellate documents; perform electronic filing with state and federal courts.
- Discovery Management: Assist attorneys with interrogatories, maintain discovery files, and manage pleadings.
- Medical Record Review: Review, analyze, synthesize, and summarize medical and other case records.
- Trial Preparation: Organize exhibits, evidence, documents, briefs, and appendices.
- Administrative Support: Maintain case calendars (hearings, deadlines), organize case files, and handle trial logistics.
Qualifications & Skills
- Education: Associate or Bachelor's degree in Paralegal Studies (Preferred).
- Certifications: Paralegal Certificate (Preferred)
- Experience: Minimum 2 years of litigation paralegal experience (Required).
- Technical Knowledge: Strong understanding of legal motions, discovery, evidence, litigation documentation, and court rules/procedures.
- Software Proficiency: Hands-on experience with Microsoft Excel, Adobe Acrobat, Dropbox, and common office technology.
- Core Skills: Exceptional written and verbal communication, strong organizational abilities to handle competing deadlines, direct client interaction skills, and high attention to detail.
Benefits
- Health Insurance & Health Savings Account (HSA)
- Dental Insurance & Vision Insurance
- 401(k) with Matching
- Paid Time Off (PTO)
- Free Parking
How to Apply
To apply for this opportunity, please submit your resume and cover letter directly to:
Nykki McAdoo
$60k - $65k
...Full-Time Insurance Defense Paralegal Location: Columbus, OH Job Type: Full-Time Schedule: In office | Monday to Friday Salary: $60,000 – $65,000 / year About the Role A growing civil defense firm in the Columbus area is seeking a highly motivated, detail...SuggestedFull timeWork at officeMonday to Friday- ...Company Description Arnold Todaro Welch & Foliano is a highly respected medical malpractice and insurance defense firm representing Ohio’s top hospital systems and healthcare providers. We are seeking a candidate to fill a litigation associate attorney position. The ideal...SuggestedFull timeLocal area
- The Cincinnati Insurance Companies in Columbus, OH is seeking a legal assistant for our Legal Litigation office (Worthington). You will support attorneys by typing legal documents, maintaining files and calendars, and answering calls. The role offers an hourly pay range...SuggestedHourly payWork at officeLocal area
- ...Billing Company Description Maurice Wutscher provides superlative defense and unmatched dedication to our clients in key cities... ...and foreclosures, data privacy and security law and compliance, insurance recovery and advisory services, intellectual property litigation...Suggested
$26 - $38 per hour
The Cincinnati Insurance Companies in Columbus, OH (Worthington) is seeking a legal assistant to support attorneys by typing documents,... ...requires 5+ years of civil litigation experience and insurance defense experience is preferred; strong organizational, typing, and Microsoft...SuggestedHourly payWork at office- ...is seeking a dynamic Executive Legal Assistant for their Columbus, Ohio office. The ideal candidate will have a background in insurance defense and experience in transcription, along with exceptional multitasking and organizational skills. This role provides a competitive...Remote jobWork at office
- ...Assistant - Columbus, OhioExciting F/T opportunity available in our Columbus office for a legal secretary with a background in insurance defense. Ideal candidate will have transcription experience as well as the ability to multitask with other secretarial duties. This...Work at officeRemote work
- ...documentation. Assist with collecting documents for corporate insurance renewal. Discreetly handle confidential information and maintain... ...Legal department. Qualifications Bachelor's Degree required. Paralegal Degree or experience working as a paralegal in a large law...Contract workCurrently hiringWork at officeLocal areaRemote work
- ...Litigation AssociatePerez Morris is a women-owned business defense law firm headquartered in Columbus, Ohio, with offices in Cleveland... ...full benefits, including paid holidays and vacation, health care insurance, 401k, and an excellent work environment.Perez Morris is an...Work experience placementWork at office
$150k - $200k
...specialized Ohio-based civil litigation firm focused on serving insurance-related clients managing high-volume, statewide litigation. The... ...Serve as trial counsel Experience: 10+ years of civil defense litigation experience Active Ohio bar license in good standing...Local area- ...Litigation SpecialistAt First Chicago Insurance Company, our employees are our biggest asset! It is our mission to attract and retain intelligent... ...appraisals.Litigation Management including strategizing with defense counsel and experts on defense cases, as well as declaratory...Full timeWork at office
$21.78 per hour
...citizenship is required for this position due to Department of Defense restrictions. Our Claims Examiner III LPN protects the integrity... ...(100% vested immediately) Competitive paid time off Health insurance, dental insurance, and telehealth services start DAY 1 Professional...Contract workFor contractorsLocal areaImmediate startRemote workMonday to FridayFlexible hoursShift work- Job Description Job Description Our client is looking for 1-2 Civil Litigation Legal Assistants for their Columbus, Ohio Office. This role will most likely be for a few different practice areas, but insurance defense is a must.Work at office
- JurisTemps, Inc. is seeking an experienced Litigation Associate Attorney to join its growing Columbus office. This position involves handling sophisticated civil litigation matters in a collaborative environment. The ideal candidate will have at least 3 years of civil litigation...Work at office
- ...involves drafting pleadings, motions and discovery, performing legal research, and assisting in case strategy for medical malpractice defense matters. The ideal candidate has 2-6 years of litigation experience, with strong writing, research, and oral advocacy skills. A JD...Full time
$89.87k - $99.85k
...Teleworker, Missouri - Home Teleworker {+ 20 more} Job InformationCSAA Insurance Group (CSAA IG), a AAA insurer, is one of the leading personal... ...will help shape claim strategy by providing clear direction to defense counsel, evaluating settlement opportunities, establishing...Remote jobH1bLocal areaWork from homeFlexible hoursWeekend work- Navigate complex claims and drive effective resolutions. Hastings Insurance is seeking an experienced Claim Litigation Specialist to join... ...claim handling and settlement strategies. Collaborate with defense counsel, insureds, claimants, attorneys, and other involved parties...Full timeWork at officeRemote workMonday to FridayNight shift
- Hastings Insurance seeks an experienced Claim Litigation Specialist to investigate, evaluate, and resolve complex coverage and high-exposure claims across jurisdictions. You will manage a caseload, work with attorneys, insureds, and claimants, and develop effective strategies...Remote job
$20 - $22 per hour
...navigate complex immigration matters. Our work includes removal defense, asylum, family immigration, employment immigration,... ...TOTAL REWARDS • Paid time off • 9 company holidays • Health insurance • Dental insurance • Retirement savings plan with a 3% company...Hourly payFull timeWork at officeMonday to Friday- Perez Morris, a women-owned business defense firm, seeks an experienced Litigation Associate to join our Columbus or Toledo offices. The role emphasizes handling a broad range of commercial and employment litigation with independence and collaboration. Ideal candidates...
- ...Perez Morris is a women-owned business defense law firm headquartered in Columbus, Ohio... ...administrative duties as assigned by attorneys or paralegals Paralegal Responsibilities Assist... ...paid holidays and vacation, health care insurance, dental, vision, life insurance, 401k...Work experience placementWork at officeMonday to Friday
$105k - $145k
...ownership of your own cases and build your litigation career with meaningful responsibility. Work on diverse civil litigation insurance defense and workers compensation matters. Enjoy potential hybrid flexibility and an excellent benefits package. Join a...Full timeRemote workWork from homeFlexible hours- Perez & Morris LLP in Columbus, OH seeks a seasoned Legal Administrator/Assistant to support a workers' compensation defense team. The role covers attorney support, docket maintenance, evidence handling, and filing with the Industrial Commission, along with client coordination...
$80k - $100k
...impact. Expand your expertise in real estate closings title insurance financing and complex transactions. Enjoy competitive... ...benefits and meaningful opportunities for career growth. Prior paralegal or commercial real estate experience is welcome! You dont need...Full timeWork at officeRemote work$160k - $200k
...respected litigation firm with a history spanning more than a century. The firm's attorneys represent businesses, organizations, insurance carriers, healthcare clients, and individuals in sophisticated disputes throughout the country. The firm's approach combines aggressive...Permanent employmentPrivate practiceLocal area- ...Benefits 401(k) Health insurance Paid time off Dental insurance Vision insurance About the Role Haynes Kessler Myers and Postalakis is looking for a skilled and dedicated Family Law Paralegal to join our team in Worthington, OH. This is an exciting opportunity to work...
$60k - $70k
...LLC, we empower our team to make a real impact by advocating for clients navigating tough times. As a Personal Injury Litigation Paralegal, you'll be essential in ensuring clients receive the justice they deserve through your proactive and enthusiastic approach. We're...- ...that treats every case with the attention it deserves. We are seeking a dependable, detail-oriented, and motivated Personal Injury Paralegal to join our team. We are considering candidates with experience in either pre-litigation or litigation, and the position will be...Immediate start
- ...Job Description Join Our Team as a Paralegal at Lawrence Law Office - Redefining Legal Excellence! At Lawrence Law Office, we don't just... ...Time Off (PTO) Hands on Training Retirement Benefits Health Insurance Dental Insurance Vision Insurance Mon-Fri Schedule Responsibilities...Work at office
$75k - $85k
...at The Phoenix Group Top Law Firm Client Hiring: Experienced Paralegal Opportunity I'm working with one of my top law firm clients—recognized... ...by 2x Inferred from the description for this job Medical insurance Vision insurance 401(k) Get notified when a new job is posted....Full time
Do you want to receive more vacancies?
Subscribe and receive similar vacancies to Insurance Defense Paralegal. Be the first to apply!
- paralegal document review Columbus, OH
- remote document review paralegal Columbus, OH
- commercial real estate paralegal Columbus, OH
- senior paralegal Columbus, OH
- disability paralegal Columbus, OH
- travel paralegal Columbus, OH
- personal injury paralegal Columbus, OH
- civil litigation paralegal Columbus, OH
- contracts paralegal Columbus, OH
- legal paralegal Columbus, OH


