Insurance Customer Service Lead
$70k - $80kERGO NEXT Insurance
Job Description
Job Description
Location: Rochester, NY (hybrid)
ERGO NEXT's mission is to help entrepreneurs thrive. We're doing that by building the only technology-led, full-stack provider of small business insurance in the industry, taking on the entire value chain and transforming the customer experience.
Simply put, wherever you find small businesses, you'll find ERGO NEXT.
Since 2016, we've helped hundreds of thousands of small business customers across the United States get fast, customized and affordable coverage. We're backed by industry leaders in insurance and tech, and we still have room to grow—that's where you come in.
The Lead Support Specialist supports ERGO NEXT Insurance's vision by leading a high-performing, customer-focused Service team and ensuring excellence across the full customer policy lifecycle. This role is responsible for daily team performance, SLA attainment, and fostering a positive, accountable culture where Insurance Advisors are empowered to deliver exceptional service. They maintain deep knowledge of our insurance products and support escalations to ensure timely and effective resolution.
In partnership with the Service Department Manager and cross-functional teams, the Insurance Advisor Lead identifies opportunities to improve processes, reduce friction, and enhance the overall customer experience. They are forward-thinking in leveraging technology, automation, and AI-driven tools to improve operational efficiency, team productivity, and service delivery in the SMB insurance space.
What You'll Do:
- Report to and support the Service Department Manager in daily operations, contributing ideas for process improvements and technology enhancements.
- Directly manage an assigned team of Insurance Advisors and collaborate cross-functionally with other teams and leadership to improve service delivery across the policy lifecycle.
- Monitor phone, chat, Slack, and ticket queues in real-time, leveraging data and technology tools to make necessary adjustments to achieve daily goals. This includes developing tactics, tracking individual development through 1:1 meetings, individual development plans, and performance management.
- Conduct regular team meetings to communicate team goals, performance updates, upcoming events/training, product updates, process enhancements, and overall company direction.
- Answer questions, assist with complex problems, and ensure work complies with quality standards and guidelines, while identifying opportunities for automation, AI support, and skills enhancement.
- Create and maintain a culture of teamwork and collaboration, fostering growth and removing obstacles to enable Insurance Advisors to focus on delivering exceptional customer service through efficient, tech-enabled workflows.
- Provide quality customer service by interacting with customers, addressing inquiries, and effectively handling escalations, while capturing insights to inform cross-functional improvements and smarter operational solutions.
What We Need:
- Hold an active P&C license and minimum 2 years relevant experience in insurance and customer service.
- Demonstrate strong customer focus and service leadership skills.
- Communicate clearly and effectively, both verbally and in writing.
- Be results-driven with strong organizational and prioritization skills.
- Proactively identify problems and recommends process improvements.
- Think strategically about service impact across the policy lifecycle.
- Be comfortable leveraging technology, automation, and AI to enhance operations.
- Posses strong industry and product knowledge.
Note on Fraudulent Recruiting
We have become aware that there may be fraudulent recruiting attempts being made by people posing as representatives of ERGO NEXT Insurance. These scams may involve fake job postings, unsolicited emails, or messages claiming to be from our recruiters or hiring managers. Please note, we do not ask for sensitive information via chat, text, or social media, and any email communications will come from the domain @next-insurance.com or @nextinsurance.com. Additionally, Next Insurance will never ask for payment, fees, or purchases to be made by a job applicant. All applicants are encouraged to apply directly to our open jobs via the careers page on our website. Interviews are generally conducted via Zoom video conference unless the candidate requests other accommodations. If you believe that you have been the target of an interview/offer scam by someone posing as a representative of Next Insurance, please do not provide any personal or financial information. You can find additional information about this type of scam and report any fraudulent employment offers via the Federal Trade Commission's website (-scams), or you can contact your local law enforcement agency.
The range displayed on this job posting reflects the minimum and maximum target for new hire salaries for the position in the location(s) listed. Within the range, individual pay is determined by additional factors, including, without limitation, job-related skills, experience, and relevant education or training. NEXT employees are eligible for our benefits package, consisting of our partially subsidized medical plan, fully subsidized vision/dental options, life insurance, disability insurance, 401(k), flexible paid time off, parental leave and more.
US hourly range for this full-time position:
$70,000—$80,000 USD
Don't meet every single requirement? Studies have shown that some underrepresented people are less likely to apply to jobs unless they meet every single qualification. At ERGO NEXT, we are dedicated to building a diverse, inclusive and respectful workplace, so if you're excited about this role but your past experience doesn't align perfectly with every qualification in the job description, we encourage you to apply anyways. You may be just the right candidate for this or other roles.
One of our core values is 'Play as a Team'; this means making sure everyone has an equal chance to participate and make a difference. We win by playing together. ERGO Next Insurance is an equal opportunity employer and prioritizes building a diverse and inclusive workplace. We provide equal employment opportunities to all employees and applicants of any type and do not discriminate based on race, color, religion, national origin, gender, age, sexual orientation, physical or mental disability, genetic information or characteristic, gender identity and expression, veteran status, or other non-job-related characteristics or other prohibited grounds specified in applicable federal, state, and local laws. ERGO Next's policy is to comply with all applicable laws related to nondiscrimination and equal opportunity and will not tolerate discrimination or harassment based on any of these characteristics. This policy applies to all terms and conditions of employment, including recruiting, hiring, placement, promotion, termination, layoff, recall, transfer, leaves of absence, compensation, and training.
- ...PetSmart does Anything for Pets – JOIN OUR TEAM! Retail Customer Service Lead(Key Holder) About Life at PetSmart Our associates are the heart of Team PetSmart. Together, we're building the best team in retail through our values-based culture, connection, and teamwork....SuggestedHourly payWeekly payMinimum wageFull timeLocal areaImmediate startWeekend workAfternoon shift
$22 per hour
...Integration Manager Location: Rochester, NY 14624 Department: Day Services Reports To: Community Integration Specialist Employment Type:... ...Why Should You Work for Lifetime Assistance?No-Premium Health Insurance: Access comprehensive healthcare at no extra cost.Education...SuggestedFull time- ...Industry leaders will train all new canidates, but you must be: Coachable and demonstrate high integrity Your have a desire to help others Excellent written and verbal communication skills Strong organizational skills with a proactive, customer-focused mindset....SuggestedRemote jobFull time
- ...As a Customer Relations Coordinator, you will be responsible for providing exceptional service and support to customers, including: respond to customer inquiries via phone & in... ...update accounts. proactively generate new sales leads. learn full suite of products and services....Suggested
- ...Order Processing, New/Repeat Quote & Proposal Generation and Order Maintenance globally.Support incoming Customer requests via email and phoneSupport Customers, Service Team, Regional Sales Managers, Distributors, and Technical Sales with Proposal / Quotation Development,...SuggestedRelocation
$17 per hour
...Full-Time Customer Experience Lead If you want an exciting job with one of the largest off-price retailers in the nation, join the Burlington... ...You'll Do Lead by example to deliver excellent customer service across the store Support and coordinate daily front-end...Hourly payFull timePart timeFlexible hoursShift workNight shift- ...Customer Service Team Leader The Customer Service Team Leader is responsible for supporting the Store Manager by serving as the Manager on Duty (MOD) assuring safety, sales, production, programs and services, and other standards are maintained. This position will also...Flexible hoursNight shiftWeekend workAfternoon shift
- Rochester Academy of Science Charter School in New York is seeking a 12-month Recruitment & Enrollment Coordinator to lead outreach, recruitment events, and the full enrollment cycle. This role serves as the public face of the school, promoting programs and collecting...
- ...This position is based in Rochester, NY We are looking for a detail-driven, tech-curious Operations & Customer Service Coordinator to join our team and serve as the connective tissue across departments. This is a cross-functional role where you will be a central...Temporary workWork at officeShift work
- ...prevention programs. You will oversee program performance, staff development, and funding compliance to advance health equity and service access. You will partner across departments, direct community-based testing and education on sexual health, manage budgets and grants...
- ...Are you ready to take your career in the insurance industry to the next level? Do you have... ...insurance accounts, providing exceptional service to clients. Review and assess client... ...detail and organizational abilities. Customer-centric mindset with a passion for...
$70k - $90k
...consultative guidance and oversee the delivery of services to ensure client satisfaction and... ...business, primarily consisting of fully insured clients, with some self-insured plans as... ...a positive economic impact. Industry-Leading Programs, Rewards, and Recognition In...Contract workTemporary workWork at officeLocal areaFlexible hours- ...center goals. This position is responsible for the management of customer service staff including all activities that contribute to ensuring... ...through quality, commitment, courtesy, and teamwork. Effectively lead a team of supervisors utilizing management skills including,...Work experience placement
- ...Manager INDUSTRY: Property & Casualty Insurance - Personal Lines ROLE OVERVIEW... ...Personal Lines Account Manager to manage and service personal insurance accounts. The role... ...Property & Casualty license. • Strong customer service, communication, problem-solving,...Work at office
$77.2k - $110k
...Work award winner in Business Insurance. We are an organization of... ...retirement challenges through custom solutions and a people-first... .... This role may serve as the lead consultant and primary point... ...Million) is required. Experience servicing construction-related clients,...Full timeFor contractorsFor subcontractorWork at office$16 - $35 per hour
...oversee front desk operations and ensure guests receive excellent customer service throughout their stay. The Front Desk Supervisor assists... ...eligible for benefits including health, dental, and vision insurance, paid time off, 401(k) with company match, Hilton employee...Hourly payFull timeShift workNight shiftAfternoon shift$55k - $70k
...Job Description Eagleview is a leading provider of aerial imagery, property... ...most accurate data, enabling customers in the government, construction, solar and insurance industries to make timely,... ...Preferred Experience in SaaS, cloud services, or other technology-enabled...Full timeWork experience placementRemote work$55k - $65k
...Institute’s Primary Project and Early childhood services. Primary Project is an evidence-based... ..., and interpersonal communication and customer-service skills and experience creating... ..., dental, vision, disability, life insurance; additional ancillary benefits, an employer...Work at officeNight shiftAfternoon shift- ...Description Coordinate the day-to-day station operations by leading and organizing the activities of Agents/Clerks to ensure a... ...training. Investigates and resolves operational issues as well as customer service issues. Will be provided company uniforms and must adhere to...Work at officeLocal areaShift workNight shiftRotating shift
$60k - $75k
...led, full-stack provider of small business insurance in the industry, taking on the entire value chain and transforming the customer experience. Since 2016, we've helped hundreds... ...markets to ensure prompt, high-touch service delivery. Optimize Operational Workflows...Full timeWork at officeLocal areaFlexible hours- ...Insurance Sales Professional – Auto, Home & LifeAre you a sales professional who thrives on... ...ethics, and always do what is best for the customer? Are you competitive and like to win? Our established Insurance and financial services agency seeks a sales-driven, goal-focused...
- ...help people manage the risks of everyday life, recover from the unexpected and realize their dreams.We help customers with their insurance and financial services needs, including Auto Insurance, Home Insurance, Life Insurance, Retirement Planning, Business Insurance, College...Work at office
$35k - $40k
...Position Overview State Farm Insurance Agent located in Rochester, NY is seeking an outgoing... ...Farm Agent, you will build and develop customer relationships within the community to... ...prompt, accurate, and friendly customer service. Service can include responding to...For contractors$2,932 per week
Job Description TLC Nursing is seeking a travel Registered Nurse for a House Supervisor position in Rochester, NY, paying $2,932 per week. This role works variable shifts totaling 40 hours. The House Supervisor oversees hospital-wide nursing operations, coordinates staffing...Full timeShift work$105.79k - $141.05k
...governments, and communities. At Lumen, you’ll work on infrastructure customers rely on today and build for what’s next, where performance,... ...packaging. We are hiring a Consumption Pricing Monetization Lead with deep expertise in consumption-based pricing to lead the...Full timeContract workTemporary workRemote workFlexible hours- ...Events Manager. The role combines sales, event planning, client service, vendor coordination, and onsite management to ensure each... ...client experience. The ideal candidate will be highly organized, customer-focused, proactive, and able to manage multiple priorities while...Weekend workAfternoon shift
- Trillium Health in Rochester, NY is seeking a Manager of Community Engagement to lead MOCHA Programs. This role provides strategic and operational leadership to ensure services are accessible, equitable, and outcome-driven. You will supervise staff, manage budgets and grants...
- ...Job Description Job Description The Customer Service Team Leader for Donor Acquisition provides on-site operational support across multiple ADC locations to ensure a positive, efficient, and mission-aligned donor experience. This role serves as a flexible team resource...Zero hours contractImmediate startFlexible hoursWeekend workAfternoon shift
- ...Job Description Job Description Apartment Community Resident Services Office Coordinator- full time We are looking for the right person with the following qualities: Strong verbal, communication and organizational skills. Coordinate and manage maintenance...Full timeWork at office
$55k - $90k
...with residents and promote a respectful, service-oriented community environment. Address... ...priorities effectively. Excellent interpersonal, customer service, and communication skills.... ...a valid driver's license and vehicle insurance. Must be able to walk properties, climb...Full timeContract workFor contractorsWork at officeLocal area
Do you want to receive more vacancies?
Subscribe and receive similar vacancies to Insurance Customer Service Lead. Be the first to apply!
- customer engineer Rochester, NY
- amazon customer Rochester, NY
- work from home customer Rochester, NY
- customer marketing Rochester, NY
- customer retention Rochester, NY
- customer Rochester, NY
- customer satisfaction Rochester, NY
- customer project program manager Rochester, NY
- customer liaison Rochester, NY
- commercial lines insurance Rochester, NY





