Sign up to access all features of our service.
  • Job search
  • Favorites
  • Create a CV
    New
  • Salaries
  • Subscriptions

Business Insurance Advisor, Commercial Producer

Gregory & Appel Insurance

Business Insurance Advisor

We're looking for a self-directed, strategically minded Business Insurance Advisor who can drive new business growth, build lasting client relationships, and operate confidently in complex commercial environments.

This role blends entrepreneurial sales ownership with consultative advisory work, developing new opportunities, managing executive-level relationships, and delivering tailored risk solutions to business owners and organizations.

You'll be equally comfortable prospecting new business, managing a disciplined pipeline, and collaborating across internal teams to ensure strong client outcomes. You'll also play a key role in strengthening our market presence through networking, referrals, and community engagement.

What You'll Do

  • Drive new business production across mid-market commercial accounts
  • Build and manage a strong pipeline through referrals, COIs, and strategic prospecting
  • Own the full sales cycle from prospecting to close
  • Deliver consultative risk and insurance solutions to business owners and executives
  • Partner closely with operations and client service teams to ensure seamless delivery and strong client outcomes
  • Maintain clear, accurate, and disciplined pipeline reporting and forecasting
  • Collaborate with carriers to secure competitive coverage solutions
  • Maintain strong presence in the business community for your market/specialty commercial lines focus
  • Consistently achieve or exceed new business and retention goals
  • Contribute to a culture of growth by supporting and mentoring early-career producers when appropriate

What We're Looking For

  • 8+ years of successful commercial lines insurance sales experience (mid-market focus preferred)
  • Proven track record of building a sustainable, high-quality book of business
  • Strong knowledge of Property & Casualty coverages and carrier markets
  • A top-producer mindset with strong closing ability and disciplined pipeline management
  • Highly collaborative approach, with strong partnership across internal service and operations teams
  • Technologically fluent, with experience and discipline using CRM tools and sales pipeline systems
  • Highly responsive to coaching, feedback, and continuous improvement
  • Experience mentoring or supporting junior producers is a plus
  • Strong executive presence, communication, and relationship-building skills
  • Entrepreneurial, growth-focused mindset with long-term commitment to building within an agency
  • Integrity is non-negotiable and central to how you operate
  • Active Property & Casualty insurance license required

We know great candidates don't always check every box. If this role aligns with your ambition, even if you fall slightly outside the listed range, we'd still like to hear from you. Why Join Us

  • We are fiercely independent and proud of it!
  • Culture built on trust, relationships, and long-term partnership
  • Our Guiding Principles are: Belonging, Innovation, Growth, Insight, Giving (giving 10% profit back to the communities we work & live)
  • Highly collaborative environment between producers, operations/client service teams
  • Strong carrier relationships and broad market access
  • Dedicated service support so producers can focus on revenue growth
  • Autonomy to build and own your book
  • Investment in tools, technology, and infrastructure to support top producer performance
  • Opportunity to grow your book while helping elevate the next generation of producers
  • Leadership that values transparency, performance, and long-term success
Gregory & Appel
Vacancy posted 2 days ago
Similar jobs that could be interesting for youBased on the Business Insurance Advisor, Commercial Producer in Indianapolis, IN vacancy
  • $100k

     ...AAI is seeking a driven Commercial Lines Producer with a proven record of generating at least $10...  ...help shape a modern, technology-forward insurance brokerage. Access to relationships...  ...The Producer will develop new business relationships, identify commercial risk... 
    Commercial

    Affordable American Insurance

    Indianapolis, IN
    12 days ago
  • $65k - $180k

     ...Job Description Commercial Producer Job Summary Seeking a dynamic and results-driven Commercial Producer to join a team. This...  ...accounts, and the ability to develop and execute effective business strategies. This role offers a lucrative compensation plan and... 
    Commercial
    Relocation package

    The Jonus Group

    Indianapolis, IN
    1 day ago
  •  ...: Bonus based on performance Health insurance Paid time off Training & development...  ...Management is seeking a high-performance Commercial Insurance Producer who refuses to settle for average....  ...who wants to build a book of business, create long-term wealth, and be part... 
    Commercial
    Work from home
    Flexible hours

    Priority Risk Management Inc

    Fishers, IN
    4 days ago
  •  ...your future? Join our dynamic team as a Property and Casualty Insurance Producer, where your expertise will drive success in our thriving...  ...Services Gaining a thorough knowledge of the client’s overall business, including individual concerns. Analyzing clients’ insurance... 
    Commercial
    Full time

    Houchens Insurance Group

    Indianapolis, IN
    15 hours ago
  •  ...Senior Vice President, Producer About the Company Large US...  ...first culture Industry Insurance Type Privately Held...  ...offers autonomy to develop business, expand a book of clients, and...  ...relationship-management skills, commercial judgment, and the ability to... 
    Commercial

    Confidential

    Indianapolis, IN
    15 hours ago
  •  ...Commercial Insurance Sales Producer The Industry Specialized Program for Select Commercial Insurance Sales Producer is a comprehensive sales and insurance program focused on outside sales driving new business sales revenue growth of commercial business clients ($10mm... 
    Commercial
    Work at office
    Local area

    USI Insurance Services

    Carmel, IN
    2 days ago
  •  ...Commercial Insurance Producer MHG is continuing to grow and is looking for a driven, relationship-focused Commercial Insurance Producer to support...  ...-market commercial accounts, enjoys working closely with business leaders, and is motivated to both manage existing... 
    Commercial
    Temporary work
    Local area
    Flexible hours

    Spark by Hilton Fishers

    Indianapolis, IN
    2 days ago
  • $175k

     ...Outside Commercial Lines Sales Position Outside commercial lines sales position. Responsible for driving business sales, retention and growing existing client revenue. Manage client...  ...advanced understanding of technical insurance issues. Take part in national and... 
    Commercial
    Temporary work
    Local area
    Flexible hours

    USI Insurance Services

    Carmel, IN
    5 days ago
  •  ...Our capabilities include programme, project, cost, asset and commercial management, controls and performance, procurement and supply chain...  ...or client account to help achieve the company's strategic business objectives. This job is part of the Project Management function... 
    Commercial
    Work at office
    Flexible hours

    Turner & Townsend

    Indianapolis, IN
    1 day ago
  • $90k - $115k

     ...Technical Advisor Make your next move an expert one. At Colliers...  ...to learn about our business and quickly gain experience to...  ...issues primarily focusing on commercial cooking and refrigeration equipment...  ...paid basic life/AD&D insurance and short-term / long-term disability... 
    Commercial
    Full time
    Temporary work
    Local area
    Work from home
    Visa sponsorship
    Work visa

    Colliers

    Indianapolis, IN
    1 day ago
  • $79.4k - $156k

     ...addition to medical, dental, and vision insurance. 401K, continuing education opportunities...  ...architect for services used by Commercial clients to collect payments. As a receivables...  ...overviews tailored to client use cases and business needs. Partners with implementation and... 
    Commercial
    Temporary work
    Flexible hours

    Old National Bank

    Indianapolis, IN
    3 days ago
  •  ...Drive regional revenue growth by identifying high-value commercial accounts, negotiating multi-year service agreements, and managing the full sales cycle from proposal to close. Requires strong consultative pitching skills, pipeline forecasting experience, and the ability... 
    Commercial
    Local area

    JobsTry

    Speedway, IN
    9 hours ago
  •  ...Business Development RepresentativeLocation: Indianapolis, IN area.Industry: Lawn care.Job Responsibilities:Presents proposals for lawncare...  ...to business (B2B) sales revenue by prospecting and adding new commercial customersNegotiates price and design by using company provided... 
    Commercial
    Local area

    MLee Healthcare Staffing and Recruiting, Inc

    Indianapolis, IN
    3 days ago
  • $95k - $105k

     ...The Senior Business Development Manager is responsible for driving new business growth within ABM’s Business & Industry (B&I) vertical...  ..., real estate professionals, and key decision-makers across commercial office, corporate campus, manufacturing, logistics, and mixed-... 
    Commercial
    Work at office
    2 days per week
    3 days per week

    ABM US

    Indianapolis, IN
    4 days ago
  •  ...seeking an experienced, highly motivated insurance professional to join our fleet...  ...develop strong relationships with all our business partners, most critically our customers....  ...skills, a holistic understanding of the commercial insurance process, and a desire to serve... 
    Commercial
    Full time
    Work at office

    DMC Insurance, Inc.

    Indianapolis, IN
    4 days ago
  •  ...most successful organizations in motorsports. The Director of Business Development focuses on identifying, pursuing, and securing new...  ...account management-based sales. ~ Strong business acumen and commercial awareness. ~ Proven ability to generate new business leads... 
    Commercial
    Afternoon shift

    Chip Ganassi Racing, LLC

    Indianapolis, IN
    4 days ago
  • $35k - $45k

     ...looking for a proven path to business ownership and financial...  ...competitive, and self-driven Insurance & Financial Services Sales Representative...  ...directly alongside a top-producing State Farm Agent who will...  ...(Auto, Home, Life, Commercial, and Health). Hit Daily... 
    Commercial
    For contractors
    Relocation package

    Alistair Filmore - State Farm Insurance Agent

    Indianapolis, IN
    2 days ago
  • $90k - $100k

     ...Click our Jobot logo and follow our LinkedIn page! Job details: Business Development Manager - Multifamily Construction - Indianapolis...  ...portfolio of multifamily and mixed-use projects, along with commercial, healthcare, municipal, and education work. Our commitment to... 
    Commercial

    Jobot

    Fishers, IN
    15 hours ago
  • $100k

     ...Benefits: Bonus based on performance Competitive salary Paid time off Training & development Personal Insurance Advisor - New Business & Sales Job Description We are looking for an ambitious, relationship-driven Personal Insurance Advisor to join our growing insurance... 

    RELIABLE FAMILY INSURANCE - Allstate Insurance

    Indianapolis, IN
    2 days ago
  •  ...Business Development Manager Identify new customer targets in alignment with the Go-To-Market strategy on the V/TO Develop relationships...  ...necessary. Support delivery teams as appropriate to manage commercial situations. Identify additional solution opportunities at... 
    Commercial
    Work at office

    Cognify Global

    Indianapolis, IN
    6 days ago
  •  ...excess auto liability product Industry Insurance Type Privately Held About the...  ...working with brokers while managing a busy submission flow. The successful...  ...collaboration, and the ability to balance commercial opportunities with disciplined risk selection... 
    Commercial

    Confidential

    Indianapolis, IN
    1 day ago
  • $60k - $75k

     ...remodeling since 2010, is looking to enhance our Business Development team! We specialize in roofing and siding for commercial properties across Indiana. Position:...  ...achieving revenue goals ~ Benefits: Health insurance, Dental insurance, Vision insurance, 401(k),... 
    Commercial
    Full time
    For contractors

    Cochran Exteriors

    Indianapolis, IN
    4 days ago
  •  ...As an insurance producer working for a Farmers agency owner, you can assist prospective and existing customers in your community with products and services they need. Compensation for this position is solely up to the Farmers agency owner, which may include base salary... 
    Base plus commission

    Farmers Insurance Agencies

    Indianapolis, IN
    1 day ago
  • $200k

     ...Outside Employee Benefits sales position. Responsible for driving business sales, retention and growing existing client revenue. Manage...  ...market knowledge and advanced understanding of technical insurance issues. Take part in national and regional meetings and video... 
    Temporary work
    Local area
    Flexible hours

    USI Insurance Services

    Carmel, IN
    15 hours ago
  • $95k - $105k

     ...6-10-27Job Category: SalesWork Days: Full Time DaysThe Senior Business Development Manager is responsible for driving new business growth...  ..., real estate professionals, and key decision-makers across commercial office, corporate campus, manufacturing, logistics, and mixed-... 
    Commercial
    Full time
    Contract work
    Work at office
    Local area
    2 days per week
    3 days per week

    ABM Industries

    Indianapolis, IN
    3 days ago
  • $200k

     ...Outside Employee Benefits sales position. Responsible for driving business sales, retention and growing existing client revenue. Manage...  ...market knowledge and advanced understanding of technical insurance issues. Take part in national and regional meetings and video... 
    Temporary work
    Local area
    Flexible hours

    USI Insurance Services

    Carmel, IN
    4 days ago
  •  ...audiences worldwide. Job Summary: The Manager of Strategic Business Development and Partnerships role drives Trends International...  ...and brands. Maintain a pipeline of strategic partners and commercial opportunities. Collaborate with Licensing to expand... 
    Commercial
    Worldwide

    Trends International LLC

    Indianapolis, IN
    4 days ago
  • $95k - $120k

     ...Business Development Manager | Bristol, IN (Main) Regular Employee | Salary Exempt | $95...  ...Key qualifications: •Experience in the commercial truck, truck body, fleet, upfit, or related...  ...: 401(k) with match, Disability, Life Insurance Work/Life & Growth: Educational Reimbursement... 
    Commercial
    Summer work
    Local area

    The Shyft Group USA, Inc

    Indianapolis, IN
    4 days ago
  • $38.18k - $70.64k

     ...basis. Job Description Professional B2B (business-to-business) sales position responsible...  ...sales revenue by prospecting and adding new commercial customers Negotiates price and design by...  ..., including Medical/Dental/Vision insurance and Company-matching 401(k) in addition... 
    Commercial
    Long term contract
    Work experience placement
    Work at office
    Local area

    TruGreen

    Indianapolis, IN
    2 days ago
  • $103.7k - $163.02k

     ...WE ARE HIRING: BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT MANAGER, U.S. HEAVY COMMERCIAL Join Us! Let’s build the future of Delta Commercial together. At Delta Commercial, we are building more than just products - we are designing solutions that transform spaces into commercial plumbing segments... 
    Commercial
    Full time
    For contractors
    Work at office
    Local area
    Shift work

    Delta Faucet

    Indianapolis, IN
    4 days ago

Do you want to receive more vacancies?

Subscribe and receive similar vacancies to Business Insurance Advisor, Commercial Producer. Be the first to apply!