Claims Supervisor
Athens Administrators
ATHENS POSITION DETAILS Position Title: Claims Supervisor Department: Workers Compensation Reports To: Division Claims Manager FLSA Status: Exempt Job Grade: 14 Career Ladder: Next step in progression could include Division Claims Manager ATHENS ADMINISTRATORS
Explore the Athens Administrators difference: We have been dynamic, innovative leaders in claims administration since our founding in 1976. We foster an environment where employees not only thrive but consistently recognize Athens as a Best Place to Work. Immerse yourself in our engaging, supportive, and inclusive culture, offering opportunities for continuous professional growth. Join our nationwide family-owned company in Workers' Compensation, Property & Casualty, Program Business, and Managed Care. Embrace a change and come make an impact with the Athens Administrators family today! POSITION SUMMARY
Athens Administrators has an immediate need for a Claims Supervisor to support our Southern California Workers Compensation department. Management that lives less than 36 miles from the Orange, CA office AND have a direct report in the office, are required to work once a week in the office. The remaining days can be worked remotely if technical requirements are met, and the employee resides in Southern California. Athens offices are open for business Monday-Friday from 7:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. Employee work a 37.5-hour work week with the ability to work a flex schedule with every third Monday or Friday off. As a Claims Supervisor, you'll play a pivotal role in leading and collaborating with Athens management to achieve exciting company goals, run insightful reports, and streamline processes. You'll make impactful daily claims decisions, review files for accuracy, and approve payments that exceed examiner authority. Additionally, you'll ensure top-notch file handling, accurate claims coding, and meet unit closing goals. You'll be the guiding force for your team, planning, organizing, delegating workloads, supervising daily activities, providing training, and offering valuable guidance. In client management, you'll address policy and claims issues, build and maintain strong relationships, attend key meetings, ensure compliance with client instructions, and document interactions, always acting in the client's best interest. Join us and make a difference every day! PRIMARY RESPONSIBILITIES
Our new hire should have the skills, ability, and judgment to perform the following essential job duties and responsibilities with or without reasonable accommodation. Additional duties may be assigned: Claims Leadership
- Work with Athens management to achieve company initiatives and performance goals
- Consistently strive to improve and streamline current processes
- Authorize release of payment and settlement
- Make daily claims decisions regarding plan of action, handling of payment, etc.
- Review claim files for accuracy
- Run various reports with an eye for accuracy and confidentiality
- Approve payments and reserve increases when they rise above Examiners authority level
- Work collaboratively with internal and clients senior management as well as with attorneys to draft settlements and assist with litigation strategies
- Provide timely information to clients, attorneys, doctors, investigators and injured workers with strong, professional communication
- Discuss appropriateness of medical treatment with medical case manager
- Assure consistent and accurate claims coding is occurring on the team
- Ensure quality file handling and resolution. This includes meeting unit closing goals, verifying proper reserves, providing thorough claims analysis and guiding to correct resolution
- Use flexibility when working in demanding and changing situations
- Effectively plan, organize and delegate workload for optimal results and to ensure time commitments are met
- Supervise daily activities of the team by monitoring progress, ensuring compliance with policies, and promptly addressing any issues or conflicts
- Identify, coordinate, coach, and perform training with staff to improve performance and increase their growth and knowledge in claims
- Participate in the interview process, onboarding and training of new hires
- Provide general guidance to the team by offering support and advice on work-related issues, fostering a positive work environment, encouraging professional development, and reviewing performance through evaluations, feedback, goal setting, and identifying areas for improvement
- Provide direct feedback and use sound coaching techniques to solve disciplinary or workflow problems. Manage and document employee relations issues at all levels. Work in conjunction with Human Resources to ensure performance issues are managed in a timely and consistent manner
- Regularly lead organized and collaborative staff unit meetings, including both remote and on-site employees
- Maintain an open-door policy and an approachable attitude, and foster open communication with staff
- Work with clients with issues regarding policies, programs and/or claims
- Manage existing client relationships by being accessible, making regular service calls, and proactively identifying and solving potential problems
- Attend client meetings, internal meetings, and workers compensation meetings both virtual and in-person
- Ensure notepads and diaries are set and completed timely in accordance with client handling instructions and Athens Best Practices and have meaningful action plans and information and are concise and well-written
- Obtain audit results meets or exceeds best practice standards of Athens and client
- Display integrity and always acts in the best interest of the client
- Document client meeting notes in appropriate shared location
Supervising, scheduling, assigning, monitoring, and evaluating work of assigned staff are responsibilities for supervisory positions.
- Provide direct supervision for 6-10 employees, typically consisting of Senior Claims Examiners, Future Medical Claims Examiners, Claims Examiners, Assistant Claims Examiners and Assistant Claims Examiner Trainees.
- Attend on-site Leadership Summit at Athens Concord headquarters every 18 months (including overnight)
- Review and approve direct reports monthly expense reports
- Ensure that all expenditures are in the best interest of the Company
- Use effective monitoring and reporting mechanisms to control expenses without lowering quality
- Search for and implement hidden cost improvements
- Obtain, maintain, and demonstrate an understanding of wage and hour laws as applicable for employees
- Ensure timely, accurate review and approval of timecards for your staff on payroll processing days.
The requirements listed below are representative of the knowledge, skill, and/or ability required. While it does not encompass all job requirements, it is meant to give you a solid understanding of expectations. Education & Licensing
- High School Diploma or GED required; AA/AS or BA/BS preferred
- Must possess a current Experienced Indemnity Claims Adjuster Designation, provided by an insurer, as defined in California Code of Regulations, Title 10, Chapter 5, Subchapter 3, Section 2592.01(f)
- Administrators Certificate from Self-Insurance Plans. If not already obtained, the Administrators Certificate from Self-Insurance Plans will be required within one year of employment
- Completion of IEA or equivalent courses
- Minimum 3+ years of recent California workers compensation claims handling experience at a high level
- At least 2 years of Claims Supervisory experience required
- 5+ years experience in a workers compensation lead or supervisor position preferred
- Prior Third?Party Administrator (TPA) experience preferred
- In-depth knowledge of California workers compensation laws, policies, and procedures
- Proficiency in determining case value, reserving, and negotiating settlements
- Understanding of medical and legal terminology
- Proficient in Microsoft Office Suite; ability to learn additional systems (e.g., ClaimsXpress)
- Ability to create reports using standard tools or custom document formats
- Able to plan, prioritize, and organize claims workload for a unit
- Leverages technology for self and staff to improve efficiency.
- Ability to lead by example, delegate effectively, and ensure timely task completion, even during stressful situations and tight deadlines
- Demonstrated ability to influence, coach, and motivate staff to achieve unit and organizational goals
- Strong organizational and time-management skills; able to plan, prioritize, and manage unit workloads
- Flexible, adaptable, positive, and aligned with Athens Values
- Ability to develop and maintain effective working relationships with coworkers, clients, vendors, and key stakeholders
- Strong analytical, reasoning, and problem-solving skills
- Ability to interpret information from multiple sources, draw logical conclusions, and make informed recommendations
- Ability to exercise independent judgment in solving complex and sensitive problems
- Strong mathematical calculation skills and high accuracy in work output
- Highly developed written and verbal communication skills
- Skilled at presenting to small and large groups
- Strong attention to detail in documentation and communication
- Strong and tactful negotiation skills
- Athens operations involve handling confidential, proprietary, and highly sensitive information, such as health records, client financials, and other personal data. Therefore, maintaining honesty and integrity is essential for all roles within the company.
- Ability to handle confidential, proprietary, and highly sensitive information appropriately
- Demonstrates care, respect, and concern for team members and clients in a professional manner
- Acts with integrity in challenging situations and consistently supports company values
- Embrace the leadership role and can be counted on to help senior management drive towards the desired results and to exceed goals successfully.
- Seeks to include innovative strategies and methods to provide a high level of commitment to service and results.
- Valid drivers license and ability to travel, including in-office file reviews and meetings
- Ability to type quickly and accurately for sustained periods
We look forward to learning about YOU! If you believe in our core values of honesty and integrity, a commitment to service and results, and a caring family culture, we invite you to apply with us. Please submit your resume and application directly through our website at Feel free to include a cover letter if youd like to share any other details. All applications received are reviewed by our in-house Corporate Recruitment team. The Company will consider qualified applicants with arrest or conviction records in accordance with the Los Angeles Fair Chance Ordinance for Employers and the California Fair Chance Act. Applicants can learn more about the Los Angeles County Fair Chance Act, including their rights, by clicking on the following link: This description portrays in general terms the type and levels of work performed and is not intended to be all-inclusive or represent specific duties of any one incumbent. The knowledge, skills, and abilities may be acquired through a combination of formal schooling, self-education, prior experience, or on-the-job training.
Athens Administrators is an Equal Opportunity/ Affirmative Action employer. We provide equal employment opportunities to all qualified employees and applicants for employment without regard to race, religion, sex, age, marital status, national origin, sexual orientation, citizenship status, veteran status, disability, or any other legally protected status. We prohibit discrimination in decisions concerning recruitment, hiring, compensation, benefits, training, termination, promotions, or any other condition of employment or career development. THANK YOU!
We look forward to reviewing your information. We understand that applying for jobs may not be the most enjoyable task, so we genuinely appreciate the time you've dedicated. Dont forget to check out our website at as well as our LinkedIn, Glassdoor, and Facebook pages! Athens Administrators is dedicated to fair and equitable compensation for our employees that is both competitive and reflective of the market. The estimated rate of pay can vary depending on skills, knowledge, abilities, location, labor market trends, experience, education including applicable licenses & certifications, etc. Our ranges may be modified at any time. In addition, eligible employees may be considered annually for discretionary salary adjustments and/or incentive payments. We offer a variety of benefit plans including Medical, Vision, Dental, Life and AD&D, Long Term Care, Critical Care, Accidental, Hospital Indemnity, HSA & FSA options, 401k (and Roth), Company-Paid STD & LTD and more! Further information about our comprehensive benefits package may be found on our website at
PIa42de736323b-26289-39664273
Vacancy posted 10 hours ago
Similar jobs that could be interesting for youBased on the Claims Supervisor in El Monte, CA vacancy
- ...ATHENS POSITION DETAILS Position Title: Claims Supervisor Department: Workers Compensation Reports To: Division Claims Manager FLSA Status: Exempt Job Grade: 14 Career Ladder: Next step in progression could include Division Claims Manager...SuggestedTraineeshipWork at officeImmediate startRemote workMonday to FridayFlexible hoursNight shift1 day per week
- ...Claims Supervisor Knight Insurance Group is a well-established insurance company committed to providing exceptional service to our clients. We take pride in offering comprehensive insurance solutions and ensuring a seamless claims process for our customers. We are currently...SuggestedWork at officeFlexible hours
$75k - $98k
Hankey Group is seeking an experienced Claims Supervisor in Los Angeles to lead a team of Personal Auto Claims Adjusters. The role involves overseeing claims handling processes, ensuring timely and accurate resolutions while maintaining customer satisfaction. Ideal candidates...SuggestedRemote job$78.5k - $163.6k
Description The Claims Resolution and Reconciliation Supervisor oversees daily claims resolution operations, ensuring timely, accurate, and compliant processing of complex claims adjustments, provider disputes, appeals, and grievances. This role provides direct supervision...SuggestedWork at office- Los Angeles Metro seeks a seasoned Workers’ Compensation Manager to supervise the unit, ensure California compliance, and drive timely payments and fair recovery for employees. You will lead staff, coordinate with outside firms, and advise management on policy and case ...Suggested
£150k per year
A global professional services provider is seeking an experienced sales professional to expand their personal lines insurance team. The role involves driving large TCV sales and delivering solutions in BPO and data services. Candidates are required to have significant expertise...- Mercury Insurance Company in Los Angeles is hiring a Mid-Loss Supervisor to lead a team of claims adjusters in adjudication and settlement of moderate to complex first-party property claims, providing compassionate service and policy compliance. You will coach staff, manage...Remote job
- ...insurance sector. Partner with product and marketing teams to ensure offerings align with insurance-specific needs (underwriting, claims, distribution). Own (and meet or exceed) sales targets in the London Market. Proven track record in SaaS/PaaS sales, specifically...
- ...Job Description Job Description JOB DESCRIPTION JOB TITLE: Claims Supervisor FLSA STATUS: Exempt DEPARTMENT: Claims REPORTS TO: Claims Director AUTHORITY: PDR Claims Examiners JOB SUMMARY: Oversees the daily activities of the PDR Claims Examiners....Contract workLocal area
- Hanson Lee Resourcing Ltd is seeking a Sales Director for PaaS within the London Insurance Market. In this role, you will lead the expansion of PaaS solutions, driving the adoption of MACH architecture to enable carriers and brokers to modernize their platforms. Responsibilities...
$123.28k - $168.82k
...leader in property and casualty insurance, servicing a broad range of clients from small businesses to Fortune 1000 accounts. Job Title Claims Technical Director - Excess Claims Location Los Angeles, CA Responsibilities Manages a book of excess claims for significant,...Work at officeRemote work$19.5 per hour
Public Storage is the self‑storage industry leader and we are hiring now for the Self Storage Manager position. Salary: $19.50 per hour. Benefits include flexible full‑time schedules, medical, dental, vision, 401(k) with match, paid time off, sick time, flex spending,...Hourly payFull time$150k - $190k
About the Position We’re seeking Contracts and Claims Managers to support large, heavy‑civil infrastructure programs—including highways, roads, bridges, transit (rail and bus), and airport projects delivered through both traditional and alternative methods. You’ll safeguard...Contract workTemporary workWork at officeLocal areaFlexible hours- Clyde & Co is seeking a Senior Insurance Coverage Litigation Counsel in Los Angeles with over 10 years of experience in insurance coverage litigation. The role includes developing litigation strategy, conducting legal research, drafting legal documents, and managing cases...
$71k - $122k
Employers Insurance Group is looking for a Territory Sales Manager to join their team in Los Angeles/Inland Empire. This role focuses on building relationships with insurance agents and providing sales leadership. Responsibilities include managing producer relationships...$140.04k - $195.62k
Oscar Health Insurance is looking for a Senior Manager, Insurance Growth Strategic Implementation to lead high-priority growth initiatives. You will manage complex cross-functional implementations, ensuring projects align with enterprise timelines. This hybrid role requires...Work at office- Victor seeks a talented Business Development professional to join our team in California, Oregon, or Washington. This hybrid role requires working at least three days a week in the office and focuses on engaging with insurance partners, brokers, MGUs, MGAs, and aggregators...Work at office3 days per week
$106k - $136k
Brand Assurance Lead - Consumer Products United States Mob Entertainment is a startup multimedia studio that is best known for our hit indie horror game " Poppy Playtime ". This franchise is one of the hottest new properties in gaming, and our team is naturally expanding...Full timeSeasonal workWork at officeLocal area- Oscar Health Insurance is seeking a Senior Manager for Insurance Growth Strategic Implementation to lead high-priority initiatives. This role focuses on managing complex projects and driving operational excellence. You will coordinate cross-functional teams and ensure effective...
- ECCO Select is seeking a Program Manager in Rosemead, CA, to lead large-scale programs and manage financials, ensuring timely delivery and quality outcomes. Candidates should have over 10 years of experience in program management, including extensive experience in technology...
$108k - $162k
...confidence that drives positive outcomes for our customers. Sells, negotiates and coordinates account services between underwriting, claims, agent/brokers partners and prospective accounts. In addition to promoting loss cost containment initiatives provided by The...Temporary workWork at officeLocal areaRemote work3 days per week- A leading insurance firm is seeking a candidate for a Property Underwriting role in Los Angeles. The position focuses on developing solutions for clients and requires extensive interaction with clients, brokers, and internal stakeholders. The ideal candidate should have...
- Mitchell Martin Inc. in Los Angeles, CA, is seeking a Manager, Claims Compliance for a full-time onsite role. You will interpret regulations, monitor compliance, and develop operational training for claims operations. The ideal candidate has a Bachelor's degree (Master...Full time
- Starr Companies in Los Angeles is looking for a motivated and experienced Commercial Underwriter to evaluate and underwrite large property insurance applications. Candidates should have at least three years in commercial underwriting and strong analytical skills. This role...
- A leading global insurance firm in Los Angeles is seeking an Underwriter to select and underwrite complex property risks while ensuring compliance with corporate goals. The role requires 7+ years of experience in multi-line insurance and excellent communication skills. ...
$110k - $215k
A leading insurance firm is seeking a Senior Property Underwriter/Underwriting Specialist to underwrite complex property risks on a nationwide basis. The ideal candidate should have a Bachelor's degree and 7+ years of relevant experience. Strong negotiation and communication...$110k - $215k
A leading insurance provider is looking for a Senior Property Underwriter/Underwriting Specialist to manage and underwrite complex property risks across the United States. The ideal candidate will have over 7 years of experience in multi-line underwriting and strong negotiation...- AXA Group is seeking a Property Facultative Underwriter for their Los Angeles office. In this role, you will manage underwriting activities for individual risk accounts while developing strong client and broker relationships. The ideal candidate will have moderate experience...Work at office
$87.4k - $170k
A leading global insurance firm is seeking a Property Underwriter in Los Angeles, California. The role focuses on developing tailored insurance solutions, evaluating risk premiums, and maintaining client relationships. Candidates should have property underwriting experience...- EY is seeking a technically skilled consultant to lead Guidewire-based digital transformations for insurance clients. You will design and deliver frontend-enabled solutions, integrate with backend services, and help shape architecture and data models across projects. The...Remote job
Do you want to receive more vacancies?
Subscribe and receive similar vacancies to Claims Supervisor. Be the first to apply!

