Paralegal
$65k - $75kMadison Approach
Job Description
Job Description
Insurance Litigation Paralegal
Islandia, NY (Suffolk County) · On-Site · Direct Hire
POSITION DETAILS
Location
Islandia, NY · On-Site
Schedule
Mon–Fri, 9:00 AM–5:00 PM
Compensation
$65,000–$75,000 DOE
Start
Immediate
BENEFITS
- Discretionary year-end bonus
- Profit-sharing contributions
- Health insurance — employer contribution toward single-rate premium
ABOUT THE OPPORTUNITY
A well-established New York litigation firm with a strong track record in insurance law is seeking an experienced Insurance Litigation Paralegal for its Long Island office. This is a stable, long-term opportunity with a collegial, low-stress office culture in a convenient suburban setting — no city commute required. The firm values its people and has a strong record of employee retention.
WHAT YOU'LL DO
- Support attorneys handling a high-volume caseload of no-fault auto insurance and subrogation matters
- Draft and prepare legal correspondence, pleadings, and arbitration submissions
- Coordinate with insurance carriers, opposing counsel, and arbitration forums
- Monitor case files and proactively identify next steps and upcoming deadlines
- Prepare materials for arbitration hearings and assist with e-filing
- Handle client communications professionally via phone and email
- Maintain well-organized, current case files
WHAT WE'RE LOOKING FOR
- Minimum 1 year of paralegal experience in no-fault auto insurance, subrogation, or insurance defense litigation in New York
- A true paralegal skillset: able to draft legal documents and apply substantive knowledge of insurance law — not limited to administrative support
- Solid understanding of New York insurance litigation procedures and terminology
- Proficient in Microsoft Office; experience with legal case management software a plus
- Excellent written and verbal communication skills
- Highly organized with strong attention to detail
- Ability to work independently across multiple active matters
PREFERRED
- Experience in AAA or Arbitration Forums, Inc. arbitration
- Workers' Compensation subrogation background
- Paralegal certificate or college degree
Vacancy posted 4 days ago
Similar jobs that could be interesting for youBased on the Paralegal in Islandia, NY vacancy
$83.72k - $96.28k
...delivering unsurpassed services in support of law enforcement and homeland security. We currently have a vacancy for a Supervisory Paralegal. In this role, you will be supporting the overall mission of the United States Attorney's Office (USAO). If you are looking for a...SuggestedContract workTemporary workWork at officeFSA
Central Islip, NY17 hours ago$83.72k - $96.28k
...delivering unsurpassed services in support of law enforcement and homeland security. We currently have a vacancy for a Supervisory Paralegal. In this role, you will be supporting the overall mission of the United States Attorney's Office (USAO). If you are looking for a...SuggestedFull timeContract workTemporary workWork at officeLocal areaRemote workFSA Federal
Central Islip, NY1 day ago$62k - $80k
...Compassionate and Comprehensive SOLUTIONS Position Overview We are seeking a full-time, highly organized and proactive Legal Assistant / Paralegal to support our attorneys in handling estate planning matters. The ideal candidate will have strong administrative skills, be...SuggestedFull timeWork at officeHuntington Chamber
Smithtown, NY4 days ago- ...Feldman,Kramer & Monaco is seeking an experienced Trusts & Estates Paralegal to join our growing firm. The ideal candidate will have extensive experience in estate planning and trust administration, with a very strong emphasis on drafting sophisticated and complex trust...Suggested
EmergencyMD
Brentwood, NY17 hours ago $60k - $70k
...Title: Compliance Analyst (Broker-Dealer / Paralegal Background Preferred) Location: Smithtown, NY (In-Office) Company: CXG ( CXG is seeking a detail-oriented Paralegal to support the formation and ongoing operations of FINRA & SEC regulated broker-dealers. This role works...SuggestedFull timeWork at officeMonday to FridayFlexible hoursCXG Holdings
Smithtown, NY4 days ago- ...Feldman, Kramer & Monaco is seeking a full time Real Estate paralegal who is detail-oriented and with at least 2 - 3 years experience as a Real Estate Paralegal. The ideal candidate will have substantial esperience handling residential real estate transactions, with STRONG...Full timeContract work
EmergencyMD
Hauppauge, NY17 hours ago - ...Job Description We are seeking a skilled and experienced Paralegal to support our team. This is a part time position- three (3) days per week. Our firm concentrates on estate planning, real estate matters and professional malpractice litigation. You will work closely with...Part timeWork at office3 days per week
Law Office of Joel J. Ziegler
Smithtown, NY5 days ago - ...Job Description If you’re interested in the law and the legal profession, become an Army National Guard Paralegal, you will assist judges, Army lawyers, and unit commanders with legal matters and judicial work. The Paralegal Specialist provides legal and administrative...Contract workPart timeWeekend work
Chapter 13 Trustee Middle District of Alabama
Central Islip, NY4 days ago $70k - $85k
Benefits: 401(k) 401(k) matching Dental insurance Health insurance Vision insurance Responsibilities include: Draft pleadings. Draft letters. Prepare various documents to be filed with the Note of Issue documents. Draft statements of net worth and statements of proposed...Matrimonial and Family Law Firm
Hauppauge, NY5 days ago- Job Title The United States Attorney's Office for the Eastern District of New York's mission is to investigate, prosecute and deter violations of federal statutes, enforce and represent the interests of the United States in civil litigation, uphold civil, constitutional...Work at officeLocal area
US Government Jobs
Central Islip, NY5 days ago - A legal services provider is seeking an Estate Administration Paralegal to assist attorneys with estate and trust administration in the Smithtown area. This role involves preparing legal documents, managing estate assets, and communicating with clients. Candidates should...
$55k - $65k
...Overview Campolo, Middleton & McCormick, LLP, a premier law firm, is seeking a Corporate Paralegal with at least 1-2 years of experience for a full-time role at our Ronkonkoma headquarters. This position offers the opportunity to play an important role in a wide variety...Full timeWork at officeCampolo Middleton & McCormick, LLP
Central Islip, NY5 days ago- Chapter 13 Trustee Middle District of Alabama is seeking a Paralegal Specialist to assist with legal matters in the Army National Guard. This role involves providing legal documentation for courts-martial and assisting unit commanders with legal affairs. Responsibilities...
- Our client is seeking an Estate Administration Paralegal to join its legal team. Working out of Smithtown, NY or Melville, NY, he/she will assist attorneys in all aspects of estate and trust administration, including probate proceedings, asset collection, and distribution...Work at office
$70k - $90k
A legal recruiting firm is seeking an experienced Estate Administration Paralegal to support its legal team. The role involves preparing probate documents, communicating with clients, and managing estate tax returns. Candidates should have a Bachelor's or Paralegal Certificate...$70k - $90k
A legal firm is seeking an experienced Estate Administration Paralegal to support attorneys in Smithtown or Melville, NY. The role involves managing probate proceedings, asset collection, and preparing estate tax returns. The ideal candidate has 3+ years of experience in...Work at office$135k - $210k
A bit about us: A nationally recognized civil defense firm with decades of experience representing corporate, insurance, and individual clients. The Long Island office has a reputation for being collaborative and approachable - big firm resources without the big firm...Temporary workWork at officeLocal areaImmediate startWork from homeFlexible hoursJobot
Hauppauge, NY9 days ago- Benefits: 401(k) Bonus based on performance Competitive salary Health insurance Paid time off Training & development Law Firm seeks a motivated multitasker to join its Legal Secretary team. The ideal candidate: Is a team player, willing to jump in...Shift work
Simmons Janance DeLuca
Hauppauge, NY3 days ago - ...Fort Lauderdale, Florida. Location: Bay Shore, NY. Posted: 2 years ago. We have a hybrid position available for a Legal Assistant/Paralegal in the Bay Shore office. Looking for a full time person who can review title reports and determine issues on title. Title clearance...Full timeWork at office
Frenkel Lambert Weisman & Gordon, LLP
Bay Shore, NY4 days ago - iRocket is pioneering fully autonomous, fully reusable small launch vehicles to provide responsive, cost-effective access to space. Our team operates at the cutting edge of aerospace innovation, combining advanced propulsion, reusable systems, and sustainable propellants...Temporary workFlexible hours
Innovative Rocket Technologies Inc.
Hauppauge, NY4 days ago - Let's Feed NY Inc. is seeking an Executive Assistant to work directly with Founder and President Ian Codio. This is a high-trust role at the center of a fast-growing 501(c)(3) nonprofit fighting food insecurity across NYC and Long Island. You will manage the Founder...
LETS FEED NY
Centereach, NY3 days ago - A premier law firm is seeking a Corporate Paralegal with at least 1-2 years of experience for a full-time role at its headquarters. The position involves managing due diligence projects, assisting with real estate transactions, and drafting various legal documents. The...Full timeWork at office
$75k - $80k
...Paralegal Required Qualifications (as evidenced by an attached resume): Bachelor's degree (foreign equivalent or higher). In lieu of a Bachelor's degree, a combination of directly related experience and/or education totaling four years may be considered. Two (2)...Full timeWork at officeVisa sponsorshipWork visaShift workDay shiftStony Brook University
Stony Brook, NY3 days ago- Campolo, Middleton & McCormick LLP, a premier law firm, is seeking a Corporate Paralegal for a part-time role at our Ronkonkoma headquarters. This position offers the opportunity to play an important role in a wide variety of corporate matters and transactions. Responsibilities...Part timeFlexible hours
- ...Paralegal The Paralegal will be responsible for working with attorneys and other departments and/or staff as assigned to provide support through all aspects of litigation in a variety of practice areas. Duties and Responsibilities Under the supervision of an...Full timeWork at officeLocal areaMonday to Friday
Kahana Feld
Melville, NY2 days ago - ...We’re seeking an experienced Trust & Estates Paralegal to join a busy and well-established firm in with a strong focus on estate litigation . This is a great opportunity to work closely with attorneys on sophisticated matters. What You’ll Do Support attorneys on estate...Work at office
SR Staffing
Melville, NY17 hours ago - Executive Assistant to the Founder Location: Hauppauge, NY (In-Office) Position Overview Company is seeking a highly organized and proactive Executive Assistant (EA) to provide full-time, in-office support to theFounder. This is a pivotal role designed to streamline operations...Full timeWork at office
Clinical Dynamix
Hauppauge, NY2 days ago $25 - $44 per hour
Job Overview Merrill Wealth Management is seeking a Client Service Associate to support multiple Financial Advisors, ensuring client advocacy and operational excellence. Responsibilities Provide excellent client service by educating clients on all bank service and banking...Hourly paySeasonal workWork from homeShift workDay shiftBank of America
Smithtown, NY1 day ago$70k - $115k
Morgan Stanley is a leading global financial services firm providing a wide range of investment banking, securities, investment management and wealth management services.As a market leader, the talent and passion of our people is critical to our success. Together, we share...Temporary workWork at officeFlexible hoursMorgan Stanley
Central Islip, NY4 days ago- ...Job Description Busy Plaintiff Personal Injury Law Firm is looking for a Paralegal to join its team! Requirements Plaintiff personal injury experience Need a car for commuting EXPERIENCE WITH MUNICIPAL LIABILITY CASES IS A HUGE PLUS Open to taking people who have legal...Work at officeFlexible hours
Trandon Associates
Melville, NY4 days ago
Do you want to receive more vacancies?
Subscribe and receive similar vacancies to Paralegal. Be the first to apply!
